New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

200+ woodworking book reviews

Natural Waterstone question

Posts

Natural Waterstone question

#1

Stephen Shepherd

Natural Waterstone question

Stephen Shepherd

Has anyone use the fine grit waterstone quarried in The Guangxi Province of China?

Stephen

Re: Natural Waterstone question

#2

Chris Scholz

Re: Natural Waterstone question

Chris Scholz

Hi Stephen,

I have no idea about stones from the Guanxi but there are two thinks I have learned about Chinese natural sharpening stones:

1) There is a very common (and extremely inexpensive) natural finishing stone that you pick up for a few bucks (or kuai) at the local hardware store.





No idea where they are quarried.

2) There is the infamous Sung Hua stone.

According to the National Palace Museum in Taipei the story is that an the Sung Hua stone was originally used as a sharpening stone. At some point an emperor (or most likely the imperial works) figured out that this stone makes fantastic inkstones.

http://www.npm.gov.tw/en/collection/selections_02.htm?docno=1079&catno=12

Are you sure the stones you are looking for actually come from GuangXi or is this where the distributor is located?

What are you trying to do? Carve your sharpening stone? Thinking about which sort of makes you wonder how you actually CARVE the stone that is used to sharpening the carving tools...

Re: Natural Waterstone question

#3

Re: Natural Waterstone question

wilbur

I think that Stephen is talking about this waterstone that Woodcraft sells:

http://www.woodcraft.com/Family/2004920/Natural-Polishing-Water-Stone.aspx

I haven't used it myself, but a friend of mine says it's pretty hard. Using a diamond plate on the surface of the waterstone to flatten it and raise a slurry greatly speeds up how fast it cuts. I do have a Japanese waterstone that is very similar: very hard, and really needs a slurry to be raised before it cuts.

Re: Natural Waterstone question

#4

Re: Natural Waterstone question

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

It very strongly resembles one I bought about 4 years ago. A very, very hard stone. Reputed to be about 12K, but I found it impossible to work up a slurry. It created a shine, but I disliked the feedback and, basically, it was just too much work.

Good idea about the diamond stone, Wilbur. I am tempted - curious - to find out whether this makes a difference, and what the stone could possibly do.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Natural Waterstone question

#5

Re: Natural Waterstone question

wilbur

It's easy to do. Take your super hard waterstone, wet it down, and rub the diamond plate on it. Then take the diamond plate off, and leave the waterstone swarf on the surface. Sometimes I'll take a spray bottle and spray the diamond plate over the waterstone so that the waterstone swarf washes off the diamond plate and lands on the waterstone. Then sharpen your tool like you normally would. The results I got with my waterstone were quite impressive in terms of how much faster the waterstone seemed to cut.

Re: Natural Waterstone question

#6

Re: Natural Waterstone question *LINK*

Warren in Lancaster, PA

A few months ago a fellow named Brian Greene stated that the Bester stones were six times as fast as the King stones. When I asked if someone who could sharpen a chisel in 70 seconds with the Kings could sharpen a chisel in 12 seconds with the Bester stones he said yes. Afterward it occurred to me that I could probably effect a four-fold difference in speed just by how I handled the King stones and that maybe Brian just did not know how to get the most out of them.

If one wants to use the Chinese stone as a polishing stone, I wonder how important speed of cutting really is. For myself, I don't expect to remove much material with a polishing stone. Tim Zowada has some pictures of razors honed on the Chinese stone showing the difference between using the stone with and without slurry.


http://www.tzknives.com/razorbevels.html

Re: Natural Waterstone question

#7

Re: Natural Waterstone question

David Weaver

I have it. It's a better razor stone than a woodworking stone.

You can work up a slurry one of two ways:

1) get a small one and a big one and cut the small one with a diamond hacksaw blade and use the small piece to rub a slurry

2) use a diamond hone to make a slurry

It's VERY hard, and it cuts ok with a slurry. Without a slurry, it's hard to tell how fine it is because it does not cut quickly.

Given how it makes a razor a pleasant shave (speaking from experience, not parroting what I saw elsewhere), I would guess it does not cut deep grooves, but instead shallow ones. Even in the razor community (which is tolerant of very slow hones), it is known as a hone that will take 100 laps where a higher cost natural stone will take 25 or 50. I would agree with that with no slurry.

If it isn't flat when you get it, you will need a diamond hone to flatten it, and be prepared to spend a lot of time. Folks who went really cheap and bought rough stones on razor forums have been reporting times of many hours (i would belt sand it before doing that).

If I had my choice, I would rather use a good quality oilstone, and if it's not cutting fast enough, scuff the surface with something.

Summing up,

* it's a fun stone to play with, but it is not comparable to a good fine natural stone that costs hundreds of dollars

* it's difficult to tell if the 12k is accurate, with a slurry, it's certainly more coarse

* isn't nearly as practical speed-wise as a synthetic stone with al ox or some other common modern abrasive

* one last thing to think about, it's somewhat difficult to see how much cutting it's actually doing without a slurry (the slurry is tan, and will change color as it loads with metal), because it's dark black when wet.

Re: Natural Waterstone question

#8

Re: Natural Waterstone question

David Weaver

Warren, the besters are VERY fast for their grit, and it's more evident if you use something other than carbon steels (but they remove carbon steels very quickly compared to kings, too). It's senseless to describe how they'd be used as a polish stone, they stop at 2k.

You know and I know, though, that only part of the 70 second process is rubbing the steel on the stone - a fraction. Trying to trip someone who is telling you something into making a pigeonholed statement might make you feel good, but it's not productive to the material point - a bester stone is much faster than a natural stone of the same grit. But it is only an issue if you intend to remove a lot of metal with the stone.

The chinese picture there makes the stone tempting for people who think they'll find a magic edge, but a razor edge and practicality for woodworking is not a good comparison. It would take eons to get an edge that good on a woodworking tool without a slurry, and you would wear the edge to look like the slurry edge in very little use - the slurry edge would be a lot more practical, and it does a good job of describing what I said in my other post - that with a slurry, i'd be hard pressed to consider the stone a 12k stone.

Good razor stone (though there are plenty better), but that's where I'd keep it - in the john with the razors. That's where mine is.

Re: Natural Waterstone question

#9

Re: Natural Waterstone question

Warren in Lancaster, PA

David, I had no intention of trying to trip Brian into making a statement about being able to sharpen in 12 seconds (six times faster). I was quite shocked and baffled when he said "your extrapolation is obviously logical and valid."

My point here is that there is some trade off between aggressiveness (with slurry) and polish (without slurry). That there is a continuum between these extremes. And that an experienced worker like Zowada has some measure of control over the degree of aggressiveness and the degree of polish.

Re: Natural Waterstone question

#10

Re: Natural Waterstone question

TomD

That`s Tim Zowata of Zowata forge fame for those of you not yet in the know. I never really bought the whole slurry thing, interesting to see some ragged looking pics of slurry surfaces.

Re: Natural Waterstone question

#11

Re: Natural Waterstone question

Schtoo

Most folks don't know what 'slurry' even is, never mind how it works and how it affects different stones in different ways.

It's often said "washing away the slurry will make the stone cut faster". I'm sure most folks who say that are just regurgitating the same thing without actually finding out for themselves what works and what doesn't.

I know I've got several stones that just don't work unless there's some slurry worked up (then they cut, cut, cut like nothing else), some clog like there's no tomorrow and some need to have their slurry managed well to get the most out of them. Some don't have any slurry at all, and of those some of them work better with artificially created slurry, some work worse and some don't care.

Some stones create 'mud' (Rika? Dave?), which is not the same as 'slurry' and they tend to be very smooth to sharpen with, very fast, but you're sharpening in a bowl most of the time too with them.

Just a general observation. Best bet is to experiment and find out what works best for whoever's hanging off the blade being sharpened.

Generally speaking however, a stone that generates some slurry (doesn't need to be very much) will be nicer to use, cut faster and have more scope for adjusting performance (cut/polish/burnish/etc.) than a stone that stays relatively slurry free.

At the same time, the slurry stones can be more likely to dish, will likely wear faster and may be a bit of a handful compared to their slurry-free brethren.

These aren't hard and fast rules however and there's no blanket statement that holds true all of the time. Too many variables and too many people sharpening in too many different ways for any one statement to be true, all of the time.

Kinda like claiming a Bester is 6 times faster than a King. Sounds like a shill for folks to buy Bester stones to me.

(There are very few, extremely limited situations where a Bester would actually be 6 times faster than a King, and they're only when the Bester is already out of it's element and the King can't even work. Think of it as you will like having a one legged turtle racing a no legged turtle...)

Stu.

Re: Natural Waterstone question

#12

Re: Natural Waterstone question

TomD

This place is like a diet, if I just hang around long enough everything you know will come back in style again.

Re: Natural Waterstone question

#13

???


Re: Natural Waterstone question

#14

Stephen Shepherd

Re: Natural Waterstone question

Stephen Shepherd

Thank you all. wilbur you are right it was the one the WoodCraft has on sale and I got the last one they had at the local store.

I have yet to give it a good test, but looks promising. It actually has an odor when it is used, kind of smells like cement. I am in the non-slurry camp, no I am in a camp all of my own, all of my stones are used dry and I only get them wet to clean them.

This is the first time I went to WoodCraft and came out with more money than I went in with, I sold the clerk copies of three of my books. Got a couple of pieces of rosewood, one Honduras and one Yucatan, for repair work.

Stephen

Re: Natural Waterstone question

#15

Re: Natural Waterstone question

David Weaver

I hesitate to ask experienced woodworkers questions like that, because people can often do things better than they can explain or reason them.

With all of the hard stones, oilstones, hard naturals, etc, an experienced woodworker should be able to get a lot of different things out of a stone they know, I agree. Slurry or no slurry, refreshed surface or purposely worn surface, amount of lubricant and type.

As far as I can tell, the very aggressive stones like a bester are intended to be used one-dimensionally, more for the knife sharpening crowd, but they are in my opinion excellent tool stones because they cut fast for their grit in the steels we use, and they leave a very uniform surface. But I don't find the same level of versatility with them that I do with something like a hard arkansas, or like the chinese stone with a razor (i just don't find the chinese stone to be much for woodworking tools, slurry or not, because the slurry in an amount appropriate for woodworking is difficult to raise even with a diamond hone).

But with some time, I can find favor in just about any type of stone that doesn't leave random deep scratches. I'm sure you can, too. I have besters now, no kings. I used kings for a while, and I never felt that bad about using them. I could still be using them and get along fine.

Re: Natural Waterstone question

#16

Re: Natural Waterstone question

David Weaver

It'll be interesting to see how you feel about the stone after a few months of no water and no slurry. I like mine enough to keep it, but I was down on it for a while trying to sharpen A2 plane blades on it when I first got it.

I think it'll load up and stop cutting in short order if you do not dress it from time to time or use water with it, but if you're stepping up to it from something fairly fine (black arkansas, etc), it probably won't matter.

Re: Natural Waterstone question

#17

Re: Natural Waterstone question

David Weaver

I love hard stones. But mostly because the option to have a stone that creates enough slurry to be effective but no more is not that easy to come by. There's another dimension to it that goes especially with natural waterstones - water management with the slurry. I guess it goes also with the synthetic finish stones.

Alex Gilmore mentioned to me when I said that I liked any hard stone as long as it wasn't a slow cutter, that really the most highly regarded and long ago exhausted japanese stones were the ones that shed grit fast enough to remove cuttings.

You know as well as I do with the glasstone that an experienced user will load the surface of a shapton stone and scratch up whatever they're trying to polish. The super fine quality natural stones are just hard enough to let go of enough grit to allow you to manage the slurry, feel smooth, and flush the metal off to the side. I only have one stone like that. The chosera will work like that if you soak it, but it's not quite the same because it doesn't get less effective if you overdo it with water. Hopefully i'll have a finish stone that works like that soon without requiring soaking. ;)

I may be coming around from the harder is better camp at some point, but safe to say the move will be a fractional distance between where I am now and what the rika is like! (slurry would be where that stone is after a couple of strokes. After a minute of use, it's like being lost in space. Great on knives (makes a very uniform finish and a knife edge can dig through the mud), not so handy on a flat bevel plane iron.

Re: Natural Waterstone question

#18

Re: Natural Waterstone question

David Weaver

Stephen, have you had a chance to play with this stone a little bit more yet?

Any thoughts about it?

Re: Natural Waterstone question

#19

Stephen Shepherd

Re: Natural Waterstone question

Stephen Shepherd

David,

Yes I have and I find it interesting. I never use lubrication when sharpening, so I used this stone dry. It is a very fine abrasive when used dry.

Then I tried a little universal solvent [spit] on the stone and it cut more aggressively than when dry?

Stephen

Re: Natural Waterstone question

#20

Re: Natural Waterstone question

David Weaver

I suppose it loads dry pretty quickly and becomes very fine - like a burnishing stone. They have to be one of the slowest wearing stones I've ever seen.

Mine is still in the razor room, but I did get to use it twice this weekend with its own slurry bringing two razors into shape. Low water and some of its own grit on the surface and it's pretty nice to use - a nice hard feel, but not sticky. And slurry seems to beget slurry - i have done at least five razors on it without refreshing the slurry itself. Only issue is that it's not the finest cutting stone in the world with slurry, but you can always push that to one end and pull it back in when you need it.

Lots of water and no grit, and it becomes tedious to use, and the way you used it dry is probably a better way to go as a polishing stone. Spit is good, too - you'd really have to work to overwater it with that.

Popular on the razor forum is to get another fragment of the same stone or to sacrifice one as a second slurry stone.

I get to like the thing a little bit more each time I use it. It's really a more versatile stone than it lets on at first.