New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

VPS-Level Performance. Fully Managed. No Hassle.

Mindless plug for HNT Gordon

Posts

Mindless plug for HNT Gordon

#1

Mindless plug for HNT Gordon

James Watriss

A few years ago, I bought myself a Gordon A55 try plane.

The wedge had split, from the previous owner over-tightening, and the sole really needed flattening.

Well, the epoxy I used on the wedge is holding well enough, and I finally got around to flattening it the other day. (Needed a high angle plane, LAJ was at home...)

I still think they should use brass wedges in this context, but the plane is performing well enough that I thought I'd give a little shout out. Wedge issues aside, I'd forgotten how nice it feels to use a wooden plane. So I may take a walk to the machinist sometime soon and see about getting a

Re: Mindless plug for HNT Gordon

#2

Re: Mindless plug for HNT Gordon

James Watriss

...see about getting a brass replacement wedge made.

(Previous message posted from the shop via iPhone, which can't scroll through messages that are bigger than the posting window. No editing for me.)

(edited 2 minutes later: epoxy gave out. Definitely getting a brass wedge made.)

Re: Mindless plug for HNT Gordon

#3

Re: Mindless plug for HNT Gordon

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

You could find some desert ironwood and duplicate the wooden wedge, which works quite nicely for me, love this plane.

Pam

Re: Mindless plug for HNT Gordon

#4

Re: Mindless plug for HNT Gordon

bugbear

I still think they should use brass wedges in this context

Can you expand on why? Wooden planes with wooden wedges have a (very!) long history of working just fine.

Is there some variation in the HNT design that puts extra stress on the wedge?

BugBear

Re: Mindless plug for HNT Gordon

#5

Re: Mindless plug for HNT Gordon

James Watriss

This isn't just a wedge. It's a sloppy fit wedge with a brass insert and a thumb-screw. Tighten the screw to tighten the wedge.

Problem is, with a wooden wedge a) the wood moves more than the brass does, and shrinking around the insert doesn't help the wood much, and b) if the screw is overtightened, it splits the wedge. (Middle gets forced outward, while the sides are held down.)

Previous owner overtightened.

Re: Mindless plug for HNT Gordon

#6

Re: Mindless plug for HNT Gordon

Pam Niedermayer

Perhaps an email to Terry Gordon would find you a replacement ironwood wedge. Honestly, that ironwood just doesn't expand and contract, harder than brass it is.

Pam

Re: Mindless plug for HNT Gordon

#7

Re: Mindless plug for HNT Gordon

James Watriss

It's a good idea, Pam. But I get the customizing bug sometimes, and there's a machinist right downstairs.

I, too, am really loving this plane... Split wedge and all.