New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Good Hope Hardwoods - Walnut Slabs & Specialty Hardwood Lumber

Carcase Saw

Posts

Carcase Saw

#1

Carcase Saw

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

I like building tools, partly because it is pleasurable working with tools we make for ourselves, and partly because I needed a quick fix .. to see something completed now as the military chests are still some weeks away in this regard.

It's been a while since I built a saw. I convinced myself another carcase saw would be useful. I already had one from Andrew Lunn at Eccentric Tools. This is a very fine saw and it gets much use. It could use a partner.

About a month ago I ordered a 11" long and 2 1/4" wide saw blade and brass back from Mike Wenzloff. The total was $34 for a blade toothed, sharpened and set 14 ppi crosscut. Really, that is as cheap as chips. Add in $14 for the slotted brass back, and the basic costs from a world class sawmaker is under $50! Unbelievable!

For some months I have had a bee in my bonnet about a design for a carcase saw. Firstly, I wanted to build a closed handle saw. This is quite unusual, with the exception of one from Bad Axe Works, all I have seen are open handles. Secondly, I wanted to do the lamb's tongue as a raised carving rather than either the minimised one on this Harvey Peace tenon saw I have from Mike ...


... or carved below, in the gorgeous sash saw handle from the Two Lawyers ..


This was a lot more work than the end result indicates. The raised lamb's tongue (if I may even call it that) is tiny for the extra effort involved. What extra effort? It was necessary to carve away all but the raised areas (one on each side of the handle) before shaping the handle.

The design is also meant to be a little sporty ... you may realise that the fun in designing this saw was sufficient motive to build it. :)

OK, so here it is. The wood is Jarrah, the handle fits my rather broad paw perfectly. Where most handles are shaped from 7/8" thick stock, I used 1" (after the waste was removed for the raised sections). Finish is Organoil and wax.



The split nuts also came from Mike, but I had a stash from about a year ago.



The slotted back is a slip fit and needs to be secured with Loctite. The brass is a rectangular section and needs to be both shaped (bevelled) and polished.


In use the saw performed faultlessly ...


One final shot, here it is with the Eccentric Tools carcase saw. Although the handles look different, they have the same hang angle..


Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Carcase Saw

#2

Stephen Shepherd

Re: Carcase Saw

Stephen Shepherd

Nice saw Derek. Why didn't you time the split nuts?

Stephen

Re: Carcase Saw

#3

Re: Yeeesssss!!!! What a gorgeous saw!

George in hot n sticky Lowell, Mich.

Re: Carcase Saw

#4

Re: Carcase Saw

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Stephen

Thanks.

It's amazing how many faults I picked up after the photos (evidence from raking light?) - rasping and sanding and chips .. and split nuts. I plan to sort these out.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Carcase Saw

#5

Questions

Bill Tindall

I have been wanting a carcass saw but so far too cheap to buy one. I like the economics of your saw but there are some details that are not clear to a novice perspective builder.

Where exactly does one get the parts- blade, back and nuts? I am not familiar with any of the names/sources mentioned. Are the holes already drilled in the blade?

You kind of skipped over the details of handle making. I don't know where to begin shaping a handle. Do you copy one from a saw you already own or does the blade supplier offer a pattern? If I have to design a handle by trial and error that is a show stopper.

Re: Carcase Saw

#6

Some answers

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Bill

Mike Wenzloff sell all the parts. He does this in one of two ways, either a full kit (which comprises all the parts required, including the wood - just finish the shaping - and all the drilling, marking out, templates, etc - $100), or sells the parts individually (which is what I bought). If you have the know-how and/or confidence, then the cheaper route is extremely attractive ... hell, both are amazingly cheap when you realise the potential cost of a saw from either Mike or a few other top notch sawmakers.

I have said this in the past and believe that it is worth repeating - the saws from Mike, the original ET, Gramercy, Medallion, LN, and Adria - all of whom include a lot of handwork - are very cheap for the time expended. The low price of the Veritas is incredible. I know how much time I expend when I shape a saw handle, a plane tote, a knife, and so on. This is pennies on the hour for a guy like me - I will get there in the end, but I am slow. I think that Mike's saws are very under priced. The public were taken aback when Andrew Lunn raised his prices, ending somewhere around the $500 mark. Ed at Medallion is now selling at this price. I think the price is right for the work that goes into these saws.

Why did I not include a Pictorial how-to? Mainly because there are so many around. Mike Wenzloff has one on his website. It is also possible to download a template from Gramercy (TFWW). Also, don't ignore just looking at the way your vintage saws were designed and constructed - the old timers generally got all the points correct. I will add that a closed handle is more difficult than an open handle, so I would begin with the latter if you have not done this before.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Carcase Saw

#7

Going the extra mile

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Ok, so I'm my worst enemy - physician heal thyself ... I admit, I'm a touch perfectionistic :D

I looked at the pictures on the forum, and was not happy. The raking light showed up chips and, especially, that the handle was not the rounded shape I like. So I pulled the saw apart and re-sanded and re-finished it. It is now finished in Shellawax. Most probably wouldn't even notice the difference. But I am happy now.


I also removed a little of the mass at the inside lower curve. Klaus had commented about there being too wide for the pinky. I cannot say it actually was so, but I respect his views, and it played on my mind. So ..

Stephen Shepherd suggested I time (line up) the split nuts - this one is for you Stephen. It didn't matter too much at the time, but now ..


One picture about the brass back. It is bevelled on both the upper and lower edges. The upper edges are a fine bevel, while the lower is stronger. The end of the back has been both bvevelled and rounded ...


And lastly, for Bill, when you build your you will need a driver for the split nuts. I made mine from an old screwdriver ...


Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Carcase Saw

#8

holes?

Bill Tindall

do the saw plates come with holes already drilled/punched? If not, how does one make a relatively large hole in thin stock?

I'm a bit confused on the kit. The blade, back and nuts (it would seem the whole saw) are about $50. The kit $100. What more could there be in the kit for the additional $50?

Re: Carcase Saw

#9

Re: holes? *LINK*

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Bill

What I purchased was the saw plate and brass back only. The kit contains in addition the saw nuts and the wood for the handle (in plan only - still needs to be rasped). The saw plate for the kit is already drilled, as is the handle. So everything is ready to go - with the exception of sharpening (this can be had for $15 - sharpen and set) together one the handle is finished. The saw plate I bought was a solid piece of steel. No holes. I drilled/punched/drilled these myself.

Regards from Perth

Derek


Saw kits and parts

Re: Carcase Saw

#10

Re: Carcase Saw

Todd Nebel

Derek,

That is a beautiful saw. You make everything look so easy I would almost think of trying to build my own saw.

Todd

Re: Carcase Saw

#11

Moses Yoder

Re: Carcase Saw

Moses Yoder

I guess it's my job to point out what people do wrong when they post pictures of their projects. Since I can't find anything wrong with yours, and in fact think it looks magnificent, I simply won't respond.

Re: Carcase Saw

#12

Outstanding!

Don Orr