New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Personalized Wooden Watches, Engraved Free

display or use antique wooden plane

Posts

display or use antique wooden plane

#1

display or use antique wooden plane

Stephanie Suesan Smith

I was given this wooden plane for Christmas. It has no maker's mark but is well made, probably of oak. It has a tag that says it was an early 1900s plane from the Hines farm in Euless, Texas. Do I put it in the china hutch or use it?


img

Re: display or use antique wooden plane

#2

I'd try it out, myself

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

If it doesn't work out as a tool, it can honorably go on display. From the photo, it looks like the sole is moderately flat, a big issue with wooden planes. I once owned a wooden jointer with a sole apparently shaped by time and warpage for planing airplane propellors. Never did work well.

It looks to me like the wedge is in backwards - if you flip it over, does the wedge rest flat against the iron?

Re: display or use antique wooden plane

#3

Moses Yoder

Re:Firewood Planes

Moses Yoder

A friend of mine who deals in antique tools always calls these firewood planes, and I generally have to agree with him. They are often so beat up you can no longer see the makers mark on the front, the mouth is normally at least 1/4" wide (basically big enough for a cat to crawl through) and the iron is rusty and pitted beyond salvation. In my opinion, if you think the plane looks nice, you would be much better off putting the plane in the china cabinet and buying a new bench plane from Lee Valley. If you want a new wooden plane that looks nice and functions like a wood plane should, buy a Clark & Williams. After getting my hands on several Clark & Williams for trial purposes, I don't think I would ever use a plane like the one shown in your picture. I don't really intend to be the bearer of bad news but I do consider myself to be honest.

Re: display or use antique wooden plane

#4

"Display" doorstop ?

steve mackay

Re: display or use antique wooden plane

#5

Re:Firewood Planes

Stephanie Suesan Smith

I appreciate your honesty. My sister found it in an antique shop and got it because she knew I liked hand tools. However, she knows even less about them than I do. At least she gets points for trying.

Re: display or use antique wooden plane

#6

I have one like that

Bruce, a MN Galoot

a jointer by Scioto Tools, a cheap branch of Ohio tools. It's a spiffy looking jointer with a badly pitted laminated iron, and acracked tote, but it was varnished very nicely by someone. It was given to me as a parting gift when I left my last job. I prize it for that, not its woodworking abilitiy. It sits prominently on a display shelf. It's the sentiment that counts.

Re: display or use antique wooden plane

#7

Re: display or use antique wooden plane

Larry Williams

It actually looks like an early plane. Can you make out a maker's mark on the toe? We have a similar plane and it took me a couple years of working on it to be able to read the maker's mark. Tom Elliot and Mike Humphrey, two of the major authorities on American wooden planes, tried to make out the mark without success When I finally did manage to read the I KING maker's mark it filled in some of the history of a maker about whom very little was known because the tote style is specific to one region and time frame.

Learn to identify early wooden planes and don't toss them until you know what they are.

Re: display or use antique wooden plane

#8

I had one until I sold it...

John in NM

A Stanley 45 :D

They make great displays though...

Re: display or use antique wooden plane

#9

about those 45's

Bruce, a MN Galoot

I keep looking for a dedicated 1/4" plow plane and occasionally take a peek at the 45 sitting on my shelf. Somehow it never gets put into action. Why is that?

Re: display or use antique wooden plane

#10

'Fer sure ! . . .

steve mackay

Folks bring me stuff too. They see "antique". Of course, at that point, they become treasures to me.

Re: display or use antique wooden plane

#11

Intimidated by the mythology?

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

A lot of folks talk about the 45 being tricky to set up, hard to use, etc. I haven't found that.

It is true that they could have made some better engineering decisions. For instance, the fence screws are very sensitive to the condition of the tips - on my 45, these screws have a couple of small burrs, which always cause the fence to go slightly out of parallel (I compensate by using the fine-adjustment feature and skewing that in the opposing direction, not a good solution; and not all the 45s had that feature). But tune-up is an issue on every tool more complex than a rock...well, really, even there, you don't want rough spots where you grasp the rock.

If I could leave mine set up - space does not permit that - I think it would be about as easy to use as the LV small plow, which is saying quite a bit.

Re: display or use antique wooden plane

#12

Re:Firewood Planes

TomD

I agree about getting the new stuff when possible, or making it. That plane has a very pleasing look to it to my eye, and looks as though it would make a better display piece than a user. A few display planes are nice to have to remind one of the roots of the craft.

Re: display or use antique wooden plane

#13

Too many adjustments...

John in NM

They weren't hard to figure out, I found it hard to keep everything tight and aligned the way I wanted for more than about 5 passes. For those 5 it worked well enough, but the 6th would invariably screw up the work. Perhaps I had a well worn individual, but the darn thing always had me ready to reach for a router instead :D

Re: display or use antique wooden plane

#14

Re: display or use antique wooden plane

Todd O. Cronkhite

Stephanie, I'd sharpen it up and take it for a spin---I think that you'll be Pleasently surprised----as I was when I decided one day to sharpen up the blade of a Jointer plane that I had collecting dust for many years. I am now a STRONG advocate for "Woodies"

yours does seem to have a problem tho---the wedge is not setting on the blade properly. I dunno if that is because in is not the correct blade or if you have it intentionally set that way. The blade should noticeable taper--get thicker from thetop to the cutting edge---unlike blades from vintage metal bodiel Stanley type planes.

There is a small learning curve on getting the wedge and blade depth set, but really it's not that hard to learn and do, and IMO is well worth the Time spent learning how to do so.

Those old blades are HARD and will take a little bit more Time to flatten the backs, but again, it's worth it, because they will take---and hold an edge like you wouldn't believe.

If worse comes to worse I'd be willing to get it set up for you and if it needs a proper blade I have an assortemt to dig thru to find one for it.

Re: display or use antique wooden plane

#15

Re: display or use antique wooden plane

Stephanie Suesan Smith

I think the problem is I put it back together backwards after taking it apart to take the picture. I will see if I can sharpen the iron and try it out. At worst, I can display it after that. Thanks for the help.

Re: display or use antique wooden plane

#16

Re: display or use antique wooden plane

Todd O. Cronkhite

I'd be VERY interested in your findings and thoughts once you get it up and running.

Since this plane appears to be a Jack and thus used cross-grain, I'd camber that blade much like a scrub planes blade and have at it.

Now, one would think that compared to the metal bodied planes of "the Stanley area" and before, plus what with the "modern reproductions" i.e. LN and LV that Woodies would be so FAR behid that they'd think that they where First, but I feel that they are so much better then all of the above because the wood asorbs and stops/kills/dampens the vibrations from the cutting action of the blade, unlike the metal bodies that would actually transmit those vibrations thru out the entire body--tho of coarse we can't feel them, but on a microscopic level---for lack of a better term---they are there. Also, consider the fact they are SOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO much lighter you can use one for much longer streatches of Time without the fatique you get from the heavier metal bodied planes. I have a Jointer plane that is 32" long, and if that was made of metal you'd barely be able to pick it up, say nothing about use it for very long.

Several years ago I made some homemade Infills using square tubing as the body because I wanted to see what all the hype over Infills was---but I couldn't afford---or more accurately put, was unwilling to pay the price that old Infills was going for on e-bay. I must say that I did like them better then the Stanley type, et al. planes, but they are Soooooooooooo HEAVY that they wear you out rather quickly.

Woodies, IMO are much over looked and discounted because again IMO they are not all shiney and pretty. I have a Jack that looks like it spent some type laying in the middle of a highway, but it works absolutely fantasticly! It's a Jack afterall and dosen't need to have a sole that is within .000001 of being dead flat. It's flat enough to look flat to the naked eye and that's plenty good enough, and unless the soles of the Smoothers and Jointers are in just horrible condition, that is good enough for them as well. There is a reason that the Japanese just to name one have continued to use wooden bodied from ancient times all the way to present day, and there is a reason why suddenly we are starting to see not only many Hobbiests making their own Woodies, but also several "boutique" makers of them as well.

Re: display or use antique wooden plane

#17

Ellis Walentine

Maybe use it

Ellis Walentine

If you are up for a challenge, it could be fun and potentially rewarding to fix it up and use it. Wooden planes have a personality and a tactual dimension you won't find in metal planes.

Ellis

Re: display or use antique wooden plane

#18

Re: display or use antique wooden plane

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I have to agree, Larry, my first thought was 18th century. The iron is single and really thin at the top, suggesting an older plane. The handle seems nicely shaped; it's too bad it is broken at the top.

Re: display or use antique wooden plane

#19

Ain`t but one way to tell

Bob Hackett

Tune it up and see how it works.

If it works good then use it. If it doesn`t work worth a darn then display it,trade it or sell it.

This approach has served me well over several decades and I apply it to most anything old that I buy or drag home from the dump.

I`m betting it will prove just as universally applicable and useful to you too.