New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A55 Smoothing Plane

Image test *LINK*

Posts

Image test *LINK*

#1

craigd

Image test *LINK*

craigd

I complained to Ellis that I wasn't able to post an image, with resizing, from Wordpress using the "Optional Image" text box and he suggested using the Image icon. Doh! He also suggested testing so here goes:



(This is a #2 sized plane with a 50� frog, completely shop built except for a some screws and a cut down level cap)


The big image

Re: Image test *LINK*

#2

Ellis Walentine

Hey, whaddya know?

Ellis Walentine

It worked!

That is one nice looking plane, too, Craig. I'll bet there's a Shop Shot lurking there. A lot of people would probably like to know what tools and skills are necessary to build something like that, me for one.

Ellis

Re: Image test *LINK*

#3

I, for one, would like to know the particulars

Bruce, a MN Galoot

That's a snazzy looking plane, more so if you built it.

Re: Image test *LINK*

#4

craigd

Re: I, for one, would like to know the particulars *LINK*

craigd

Thanks!, yes, it is one of my early efforts. It's a hybrid of bedrock, Veritas and laziness (no lateral or depth adjuster). Here is a action shot:



And a write up:


http://zkprojectnotebook.wordpress.com/2010/11/23/zk-2/

Re: Image test *LINK*

#5

Moses Yoder

Re: Veritas planes

Moses Yoder

Veritas planes are patented. Did you use any of the patented features with permission, or were none of the features you used patented?

Re: Image test *LINK*

#6

Re: Veritas planes

Alex Grigoriev

I am not a lawyer, but as far as I know the patents cannot be enforced against things made purely for personal use (not to be sold).

Re: Image test *LINK*

#7

craigd

Re: Veritas planes

craigd

All of the above. As in, I looked at the planes in the Lee Valley catalog, said, "hmmm, good idea" and used it. I didn't do a patent search, I didn't contact LV or email Rob Lee. I do know that Rob has pointed out that even "one offs" are not exempt from patent infringement. I also know that Shaw patent planes have very similar ideas to what I did.

Take a look at the exploded view and let me know which Veritas patents I'm infringing on. I suspect Rob also has better things to do with his lawyers.

Re: Image test *LINK*

#8

Actually...

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

Technically you are right, you can copy any patented device as long as it's for personal use (from what I understand, I'm not a lawyer either).

However, if you publish your endeavor, then you are guilty of what's called "inducement to infringe", even if you don't get a penny for publishing your work. Now is a Wordpress blog considered to be publishing, I don't know if the law has kept pace with the information technology world.

But in any case, if the concern is the "frog through the sole" feature, then there's nothing to worry about I think, this feature was used on the Millers Falls' Buck Rogers plane line in the '50s. So unless Veritas has managed to get a patent on their version of the feature, and that version's patent covers what has been presented here, I wouldn't worry about it.

DC

Re: Image test *LINK*

#9

Re: Veritas planes

Mark Nowicki

The only patent Veritas can lay claim to is the ugly one. All their planes should have a a smiley sticker stickers on their handle and be pushed backwards. You missed that by a country mile.

Nice work

Mark

Re: Image test *LINK*

#10

Question of taste

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

I've come to appreciate the styling; and I definitely appreciate the lower cost relative to LN; though I will admit that, if I were in the market for a bevel-down bench plane and had money, I'd probably go for the LN, because I'm not so sure about the LV's design functionally.

Re: Image test *LINK*

#11

Re: Image test

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

I'm intrigued by that pivoting arrangement for the tote screw. How rigid have you found the tote to be in use?

Re: Image test *LINK*

#12

Re: Question of taste

TomD

I think the LV functions well. I have both. I generally prefer LN when they are available. My biggest gripe with LV planes is that they keep changing them so that if you liked it last year it will be different this year, and some of them I wouldn't buy due to the main handle seeming to be flimsey in attachment, I think that was bevel downs though. The LV BD jointer and wide finish planes are treasures.

Re: Image test *LINK*

#13

I like the lever cap

John in NM

It has a nice shape to it now. Ever think of bluing it or the body?

Re: Image test *LINK*

#14

Re: Veritas planes

TomD

http://dilbert.com/strips/comic/2011-08-06/