New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

200+ woodworking book reviews

Japanese planing question

Posts

Japanese planing question

#1

Japanese planing question

Bill Tindall

A Japanese researcher at something akin to our Forest Products Lab is studying plane blade wear. A typical experiment is a planing speed of 8 M/ min, 50 micron shaving thickness, 30 degree bevel, planing orientation essentially equivalent to hand planing on face grain of wood.......the conditions are very similar to hand planing. Studies are being done with a computer controlled planing device that takes a repetitive shaving thickness and records planing forces. Wear profile of edge is also measured. One study is in collaboration with NC State. Nearly a dozen published papers have resulted from this work, i.e. someone has spent a ton of money funding it for some purpose.

It does not seem likely that this much effort is being expended on studying wear of hand plane blades for the local furniture shop, is it .?. Is there a Japanese machine that is used to production "hand plane" lumber for some purpose?

Anyone with insight to Japanese woodworking that could offer a reason for these studies?

Re: Japanese planing question

#2

Super Surfacers *LINK*

Steve Elliott

While I don't claim to have signficant insight into Japanese woodworking I have seen a planing machine called a super surfacer being used by a Japanese shokunin to prepare timbers for a traditional wooden structure. The cutting action is almost identical to hand planing and when the machine is working well it leaves a very smooth surface.


A Super Surfacer in Action

Re: Japanese planing question

#3

well if that ain't slick

Bill Tindall

A company like that would certainly be interested in plane blade edge life. Love those shavings. I'll bet it is a bit more involved to set up than my Stanley #5.

Re: Japanese planing question

#4

Re: well if that ain't slick

TomD

I doubt it. There is a sharpening machine for the blades, and the rest is plug and play. They have neat features like variable angles of skew.

Back in the 80s they used to be regularly advertised in the pages of FWW by both Hitachi and Makita. FWW even had a tool test. I get regular emails from an outfit that sells all these wacky Japanese tools, and there are relatively large ones for sale at astronomical prices. The only time I ran into one for sale I got the SS version of an old lady who only drove it to church. To wit, it was only used to make shavings for hamster cages.

One of the reasons Japanese hand tools might deserve some respect is that their serious wood working biz is so much larger than ours. From sailing off Atoria watching the shiploads of logs being sent to japan, to talking to a Makita salesman who said the japanese catalog had 100s more pages of ersatz woodworking tools than ours, to seeing the huge number of specialty resaws, mortisers, and SSs they regularly employ over there. It is part of the reason that when I hear that inserting a biscuit, or whatever, is the only way a pro shop would do that job, I have to smile. The shop that keeps sending me sale material is located in Ontario Canada, and I do wonder who uses all the Japanese machine over here.

Re: Japanese planing question

#5

Who's the author of the papers?

wilbur

Re: Japanese planing question

#6

Authors & Title

Steve Elliott

Bill and I have been discussing a paper by Chutaro Kato and John A. Bailey called "Wear Characteristics of a Woodworking Knife with a Vanadium Carbide Coating Only on the Clearance Surface." It describes tests using coated blades in both orthogonal cutting (in a straight line like hand planing) and peripheral milling (using a rotating cutterhead like a jointer or planer).

In one test they found a vanadium carbide coating 3 microns thick on the clearance surface of a blade gave a self-sharpening action that kept the blade working sharp after 50 kilometers of planing through Sitka spruce. That's working sharp for peripheral milling, not hand planing. Still, it's not bad.

Re: Japanese planing question

#7

Re: Authors & Title

Schtoo

I don't have complete details, but when it comes to planing here's something to shoot for.

The current record for edge durability is a 6 micron shaving in 'softwood' (likely hinoki/Japanese cypress) for a distance of 327 metres/1080 shaku. It's been held for 10 years, and is a measure of edge taking, holding and overall planing performance.

Doesn't sound like much, but that thickness shaving requires an exceptionally sharp edge, and to maintain it for 1/3 of a kilometre is impressive.

Good blue steel runs out of edge after about 100 metres IIRC.

The plane was a Tsunesaburo HAP40 (powder metal M4 HSS) 'Miki' plane.

That's all the information I have, and to date nothing has even come close to touching that mark. Perhaps with some of the newer PM steels becoming available, something else will work better and last longer, but then you still have to sharpen it and HAP40 is about the limit of what's actually sharpenable with pre-existing and widely available sharpening media. M4 is not too dissimilar to 3V, but with all the good stuff slightly more prevalent.

And no, diamonds were not used sharpen the blade.

(Just as a side note, HAP40 is not used for chisels here. X7 PM has better impact and shock resistance, sacrificing some edge holding ability for that. It's a Hitachi proprietary steel IIRC, so information is difficult to come by. The chisels however are easy to find.)

I hope that adds something to the discussion.

Stu.

Re: Japanese planing question

#8

Actually.....

Bill Tindall

Kato is author of a series of papers referenced in the paper Steve cited all having to do with wear on edges planing stuff.

Re: Japanese planing question

#9

Quite a Feat

Steve Elliott

A 6 micron shaving is impressive no matter what. Taking that thin a shaving for 1000 lineal feet is amazing.

For perspective, let me say that I find 3V to be about as wear resistant as I care to use for practical woodworking. It�s slower to grind but worth it (to me) for its edge holding properties. The problem with extremely wear-resistant alloys is that even a small nick in the edge requires considerable time to remove, and avoiding any nicks at all is hard to do unless the wood itself is free from inclusions and debris.

If coated blades have an advantage it will be that the ability of the cutting edge itself to hold an edge will be accompanied by relative ease of sharpening because the body of the blade is easier to abrade. That�s one of the advantages of laminated blades, though the size scale is different.

In the study the powder metal alloys HAP10 and HAP72 were used both uncoated and with vanadium carbide on the clearance faces. With HAP72 the uncoated blade had worse cutting geometry after � km than the vanadium carbide coated one had after 10 km.

Re: Japanese planing question

#10

Question answered

Bill Tindall

The studs in some(most?) Japanese homes are exposed beams that are planed with either a hand plane or a machine that produces a desirable hand planed appearance. Now I know where the prime grades of Douglas Fir stacked up at NW ports are destined to be. No doubt Kato was doing this work for this industry to explore how to improve the process.

Re: Japanese planing question

#11

Re: Question answered

TomD

Yeah, they are buying all the wood they can scab off the west coast. Apparently it is shipped over there and sunk underwater where they hold it till it is needed some future time like decades or centuries. Whether this machinery is for domestic construction or temple reconstruction, and they probably have a shrine to Juicy Fruit gum over there, so there are alot of shrines... I don't know. Apparently there is often one beam that has a traditional sheen to it. I remember many moons ago, there was an article in FHB about a couple in Minesota who built a Japanese style house. The got Carl Swensen in to do a single beam/trush type instalation. They gently commented on how huge an amount of time just that took.