If I were to join two large planks...
Stephen Shepherd
8 inches thick and 45 feet long, how many rather large dowels [loose tenons] should I use to keep them in line?
Stephen
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
If I were to join two large planks...
Stephen Shepherd
8 inches thick and 45 feet long, how many rather large dowels [loose tenons] should I use to keep them in line?
Stephen
that's one awesome work bench!
Bill Tindall
It would depend on species- oak will overcome restraint more than pine. It will depend on grain orientation changes along the length. Any area like around a knot where the long grain runs out to the edge will experience severe deflection forces upon drying. It will depend on how dry to begin with and what sort of moisture swings the assembly will experience.
Before or after running them over the jointer?
James Watriss
I dunno, man. I'm thinking bolts, not dowels. You're talking about using twigs to align tree trunks, and hold them there.
When I modified my Sjobergs bench, I found that they run a 3/8" groove full length, along the face grain between boards, and use short, 2" wide pieces for alignment, instead of dowels, spaced no more than 1/2" apart. And that's for a 3" thick surface. 8"? I think I'd run a 3/4" groove, and cut a bunch of 1" pieces off the end of some s3s common soft maple.
Aligning those things is another story...
Re: If I were to join two large planks...
Moses Yoder
If they are pretty flat on top, I wouldn't use dowels. I would use a spline, because the spline tends to guid itself into alignment as you clamp from one end to the other. That is, if you are glueing them together. I think trying to do that with dowels would be one major hassle.
Tell more about the design problem
Ellis Walentine
Just for a sense of relative scale, I used to build driveway gates, often of 16/4 mahogany or teak. The leaves might be up to 8' wide and tall, and we used double tenons 7/8" thick by 4" w x 9" long for all the M&T work. Depending on what you are trying to achieve with your tenons, you might consider pieces about 2 1/2" thick by 4"-6" wide by as long as you need them. If the tenons are supposed to keep the boards not only aligned but also co-planar, you'll need longer tenons and more of them. If it's only to align the joint for gluing and to provide a mechanical backup, I'd suggest a continuous spline the full length of the planks, sort of like a Woodruff key, maybe with large loose tenons near the ends and at intervals, similar to breadboard construction.
What on earth is this project all about?? I sense a shop shot. 
Ellis
Re: Tell more about the design problem
TomD
I think unless there is some aesthetic restriction, etc... Cleats would be a better approach. These can run full width, or something less if hiding them is important, than bolt up through them and into the bench. A lot stronger and less damage to the material, and more strength to the part. There is a limit to how much structure you can get in an internal tenon, but no real limit to an external one.
Another option is metal pins and hardware bonding with epoxy.
Re: If I were to join two large planks...
Warren in Lancaster, PA
I would say 10 3x3 tenons (one every 5 feet) would keep the planks fairly well in line.
If you want to take a modern approach I would get nine guys, each with a paint brush and a bucket of Titebond III. It is waterproof and has a pretty good open time. Give each guy 60 clamps; that is 540 in all. If you have to buy a few just remember you can't have too many clamps in your shop.
I sort of agree with Ellis
Ian_N
(did I spell Ellis properly?)
but I'd use a double row of loose tenons made of 1" ply -- each tenon say 4" wide and 12" long spaced every 2 foot or so.
The tenons one side of the joint could be held with your favourite glue, the other side of the joint I'm not so sure -- the open time of hide glue is possibly not long enough for what is in effect 40 large M&T joints
BTW,
how do you get two mating faces on a joint that long and wide?
how do you clamp a joint that long?
how do you handle the boards? -- I'm calculating an assembly that would weigh at least 2000 lbs
Re: I sort of agree with Ellis
TomD
Use epoxy, then you can have pretty much as loose a joint as you want. 
another vote for spline
Chris Friesen
I'd suggest jointing one face and edge and then immediately cutting a groove for a spline before it has a chance to warp. Then mill your spline material and get that sucker glued up. I'd probably use epoxy since it requires minimal pressure and it's structurally gap-filling.