New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Fast and affordable laser cutting – so you can make the parts you can’t find anywhere else

New steel in the oven soonish...

Posts

New steel in the oven soonish...

#1

New steel in the oven soonish...

anotherBob

I'll post progress as I make it here in the future...

Doing a bit of plane iron homework this weekend I ran across some new (to me) M4 stock from Bohler-Uddeholm. From what I heard, this is their 3rd generation PM steel (was told that the CPM stock from Crucible is still 1st generation), that they use magnetization to further refine for smaller particles resulting in a steel that will hone as fine as O1... but keep its edge like M4! Placed an order earlier today for a couple feet of it from Alpha Knife Supply, 1 ft/1.5" wide, 1 ft/2" wide for a couple planes I'm making.

When I told them what I planned on using it for, these were the specs recommended for the heat treaters:

Austenitize: 2100�F - 15 minutes or 2150�F - 10 minutes for HRC 63

Could have sworn that I read in a forum post (my bad... didn't take notes) here that they wished they would have hardened their CPM-M4 irons to 64. Anyway, 63 was recommended to maintain toughness, so unless I hear different... 63 it'll be. :)

Also of interest... they mentioned something else which is new, and might be very promising... K390 Carbon Steel. Looks like for this, they added Cobalt, and lessened the amounts of Molybdenum and Tungsten. Supposed to hold an edge... incredibly.

What I'm blabbing about:

M4 Carbon Steel - Bohler S690

http://alphaknifesupply.com/bladesteel.htm#BS-M4

M4 Information & Composition

http://alphaknifesupply.com/zdata-bladesteelC-M4.htm

------------------------------------

K390 Carbon Steel

http://alphaknifesupply.com/bladesteel.htm#BS-K390

K390 Information & Composition

http://alphaknifesupply.com/zdata-bladesteelC-K390.htm

Re: New steel in the oven soonish...

#2

It's the vanadium.

Bill Tindall

That stuff has 9% vanadium! Vanadium is the hardest of the carbides and there is 3 times more of it than 3V. You will be sharpening that with diamonds ....or not at all.

Re: New steel in the oven soonish...

#3

do you know the grain orientation?

Ian_N

Some years ago I had a longish conversation with Paul Williams then owner of the Academy Saw Works (ASW) blade business. IIRC, testing some years ago demonstarted that the ASW blades were some of the best -- if not the best -- commercially avaialble plane blades.

Paul made his plane blades from M2 and contended there was superior edge holding when the steel grains were aligned along the length of the blade compared to across the blade. Presumably the same is true for knives, the difference being that because a knife is longer than it is wide with the cutting edge down one side, the grains should be aligned across the blade. i.e. at 90� to the direction desired for a plane blade

So my question is

are your blanks knive blanks -- with the grains should be arranged across the steel or

a plane blade blanks where the grains are aligned along the length of the steel?

Re: New steel in the oven soonish...

#4

Re:  grain orientation?

George in hot n sticky Lowell, Mich.

Isn't that the beauty of powdered metal steels? There is no grain direction to orient. Conventionally produced, rolled or extruded steel has a grain.

Work safe,

George

Re: New steel in the oven soonish...

#5

thanks, but ...

Ian_N

from what you say there's a whole world of unknown (to me) metal forming technology to explore