New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Urban Salvaged Hardwood Slabs, Milled In-House from Rare Trees. Shop Unique Walnut Stock.

Peening dovetails in wood

Posts

Peening dovetails in wood

#1

Peening dovetails in wood

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

I was planing and scraping the outside of the military chest carcases, happy with the joinery so far, when it occurred to me to show the underside of the cabinet - the part that will not be seen - and in particular the dovetails there.

Obtaining a tight fit for dovetails is not a big test if the wood combination used is sympathetic. For example, one hard and one soft wood. The soft wood will compress inside the harder wood and create a gap-free join. Well .. most times. :\

Joining a carcase that is built of medium hard wood is similar. As long as the woods involved have a little elasticity, they will compress. However, when one uses hard wood against hardwood, particularly woods that do not compress, such as the Jarrah of these carcases, then you had better take care to saw accurately. There is minimal compression with such woods.

For this reason I am extra careful with carcases in Jarrah. I saw to the line, but if I err I would rather that the fit is oversize - then test for fit and pare away any excess wood.

The result here was as good as I could have wished ...



Now the underside of both cabinets was another matter altogether. The dovetail fit was not bad, but I did not aim for a perfect fit, just a good join. If I needed to pare away a tad more than usual to make the sides fit easily, well so be it. As a result there were gaps. No one would know.

We all know about filling gaps with thin wood wedges or slivers of wood. This can make gaps disappear.

There is another method - peening or sometimes called Bishoping - and this is particularly easy if the tails are slightly raised above the pins (in other words, the end grain is raised above the face grain).

Here is the underside of one end. There is one tail that split away as I pared it, and I did not both with a repair at the time ..


Peening is the process of working the surface - in this case wood - and moving excess into gaps. To do this we need a hammer with a domed head - the traditional Japanese gennou is perfect (these have a domed end on on side and a flat end on the other side).


Step one is to squeeze a little glue into the gaps. I place a little on my fingertip and then push it in ..


To peen one does not hammer downwards. Instead you need to hammer at an oblique angle and similtaneously drag the hammer head across the surface, as if you were pulling the wood into the gap. Several controled gentle taps are better a single heavy-handed slam.

You should achieve something like this ...


Now clean up the dovetail with a plane and see the result ...


Not perfect but not bad.

Update:

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Peening dovetails in wood

#2

Stephen Shepherd

Re: Peening dovetails in wood

Stephen Shepherd

I know of at least two historic examples, a tall case clock and a chest that both exhibit this technique. And I know of several modern examples of this technique used successfully on furniture I have made.

Stephen

Re: Peening dovetails in wood

#3

Peening dovetails in wood had never occurred to me

Bruce, a MN Galoot

when I have had a gap worthy of notice (far too frequently, I might add) I've used the trick I learned in one of Frid's books of cutting a kerf and filling it with a sliver of the same wood.

I'll give your method a whack next time the opportunity arises.

Re: Peening dovetails in wood

#4

Re: Peening dovetails in wood

Dean J in MN

Our friend Thomas, from The Joiner and Cabinet Maker, notes:

"... a further degree of tightness may be obtained by carefully hammering the ends of the pins, especially if they have been cut to stand a little above the wood round them. This clenches them, and makes them both hold tighter and fit more perfectly. Some careless workmen look to this hammering to fill up the spaces which their bungling has left, but it is impossible to hammer a bad dovetail into a good one, though a good one may be made better byt this means."

I've run across a similar description elsewhere, so it seem there was some use if this method historically. Keeping in mind you can't fix a bad joint with it. :)

Re: Peening dovetails in wood

#5

Re: Peening dovetails in wood

TomD

A similar result is obtained if you just clean up the dovetails with a file. If you follow Krenov's filing instructions it might seem that you would be cutting delicately and leaving stuff as it was, but in fact you will be forming the dovetails to any gaps. You just have to file in the right direction, which is basically the direction that you would expect would force the ends up agains the sidegrain sockets. It is fairly amazing the erors this will hide.