New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Rare Exotic & Domestic Hardwoods, Milled In-House in Oregon. Browse Unique Stock.

A new lesson learned

Posts

A new lesson learned

#1

A new lesson learned

patrick gibbons

I'm building a small occasional table for my nephew's wedding next week. It's made out of cherry and I used ruby dewaxed shellac on it. This proved to be a beautiful color for the piece and it looks like a cherry piece that is old and dark. The problem is that I have more orange peel and surface blemishes than I normally have. I've come to the conclusion it's because I used an old cotton knit shirt rather than old tee shirt as I normally do to make the muneca (the rubber). Next time I'll pay more attention to repeating that which succeeds.

Re: A new lesson learned

#2

Ellis Walentine

Contamination?

Ellis Walentine

What are the odds that there is some oil or silicone on the surface of the wood that is causing the shellac to react badly? And I'm trying to imagine orange peeling when you're rubbing the finish onto the wood. I thought orange peel only happened when the film is wet and thick? If there's a lesson here, I'd like to be sure of what it is...

Ellis

Re: A new lesson learned

#3

Re: A new lesson learned

Paul M.

I tried to french polish with knit T-shirt fabric once. It didn't work.

I don't know this for certain, but I'm guessing that the problem is that knit fabrics are so easy to stretch. It's easy for the knit fabric to catch and stretch before it releases and jumps to the next place where it catches. A tougher linen fabric will continue moving without the waves of catching and releasing.

Old pillowcases and sheets work much better. Convince the wife that she needs to go out and buy some nice new sheets so you can have the old ones. Win-win!

The best part of french polish is that problems like this are so easy to fix. Use 600 grit and level the surface with a solid wood pad (no cork or other flexible surface). It will only take 5-10 minutes of french polish to bring the rough 600 grit leveled surface back to mirror glow.

Re: A new lesson learned

#4

Re: A new lesson learned

charlie belden

Orange Peel, as I know the term, is caused when spraying on a finish, indicating that the finish is partially drying before making it to the surface of the piece. Seems to happen more often when using HVLP because the air is warmer and the solvents in the finish evaporate quicker.

I've never heard of french polishing producing Orange Peel. Rubbing on a "hot finish" (one that partially dissolves the surface of the previous application) CAN'T create orange peeling - unless you're blotting on the finish with a wet muneca and put down thick coats.

Are you sure your orange peel isn't a lot of "fish eye" - which is often cause by a contaminate on the wood - silicon contamination is notorious for causing "fish eye". Sometimes using a "tack cloth" to clean the surface can be the problem - if the "tack" is from wax rather than rosin.

Re: A new lesson learned

#5

Re: A new lesson learned

Joe Rogers, Northern Virginia

Interesting about the contamination angle. I had to refinish a worn Oak kitchen table. I couldn't get the poly (I know heresy!!) to cover due to old polishes in the pores of the surface. I used Shellac to seal the surface after resanding and it cured all but 1 or 2 nasty fisheyes. I always heard that Shellac was not as sensitive to contamination as other finishes. I am interested in additional discussion on the subject...

Joe

Re: A new lesson learned

#6

Orange peel is the wrong term

patrick gibbons

Paul M. has it right about what is going on. Rather than a glass-like surface all over the piece there is much sticking of the muneca and rough areas with bumbs. The only thing I've done differently is the use of a more open weave cotton. I'm more convinced it's the culprit. The wedding is next Wednesday, I'm almost out of the shellac I'm using and Shellac.net is out of stock on this stuff as well. It looks better now after much work but still not as good as I've achieved in the past. I'll evaluate my store of shellac, I believe I have enough to fix the problem, and try to fix it tomorrow or Saturday. Otherwise I'll give the piece as is and fix it at a later date. If I do that there's a strong possibility it will never be fixed so the Saturday option is my best. Thanks Paul for the quick info on fixing the problem. Ellis, I don't believe I've contaminated the wood with any foreign substance.

Re: A new lesson learned

#7

Re: Orange peel is the wrong term

Paul M.

Wow. That's a tight deadline to order and recieve finishing supplies. I feel your pain.

In that case, I would go with a compromise. Level with a finer grit like 1000 (cleaning the fine paper constantly to remove gooey lumps!), and then use just alcohol with a tiny bit of shellac to soften the surface to flow it back towards a mirror. Without a complete leveling, it will still be a bit bumpy, but the bumps will be softer pillow type bumps instead of the sharper ones you are probably seeing.

Another great source for shellac is www.shellacfinishes.com (I get all my shellac from them). If you ask for a rush, you might be able to get it in time. Vijay (the proprietor) lives right by me so I can just drop by and pick it up supplies when I need it, so I've never tried a rush shipment.

Re: A new lesson learned

#8

Re: A new lesson learned

Ron Hock

Two shellac application tips I learned from guitar maker, Brian Burns (yes, the same one who wrote the Double Bevel Sharpening Book -- he's a smart guy, I tell you): use microfiber cloth for your wiping pad. It will leave much less lint behind. And use mineral spirits (paint thinner) for a pad lubricant. Used liberally it works as well as, or better than, mineral oil and doesn't need to be cleaned when you're done.

Re: A new lesson learned

#9

Thanks everyone, ain't shellac grand?

patrick gibbons

Re: A new lesson learned

#10

Yes. Temperamental, but grand nonetheless.

James Watriss

Re: A new lesson learned

#11

Stephen Shepherd

Re: A new lesson learned *LINK*

Stephen Shepherd

I have used commercial tack rags as well as having made my own. But no more, I found while researching my last book of 'washing leathers', chamois, a marine oil treated leather. Get it damp with water, wring it out and it is good to go and no lint. Wash it out with soap and water and they will last a long time.

Stephen


Washing Leather

Re: A new lesson learned

#12

Reusable?

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Re: A new lesson learned

#13

Stephen Shepherd

Yes

Stephen Shepherd

Re: A new lesson learned

#14

You're right Stephen

patrick gibbons

Back in the 60's my father used to import chamois from England and sell it to automotive customers (which back then meant service stations). For the same reason they're wonderful for cars they should be good for furniture. Are they absorbant enough for shellacking?

Re: A new lesson learned

#15

What I did

patrick gibbons

I poured more alcohol in my mixture, which was a 2 lb cut. For polishing, a diluted solution should be better. I cleaned the piece up as best I could. It's not my best effort but it will have to do this time. At least I learned some more about shellacking. A good polished finish will go a long way toward making a so-so project look great. I got a lot of good information from everybody. Don't know where else I could have done that.

Re: A new lesson learned

#16

Question for Stephen

patrick gibbons

What historical use of chamois for shellacking did you discover. Finishing is one of those topics that much is assumed but not explained.

Re: A new lesson learned

#17

Stephen Shepherd

Re: Question for Stephen

Stephen Shepherd

Patrick,

I will answer both of your questions. Chamois would be too thick to use for a fad or rubber, the alcohol would pass through but not the shellac. I haven't tested its filtering abilities, but I have a test in mind.

The only reference I have found for chamois is as a 'wash leather' used for 'leathering' a surface, the traditional tack cloth. Chamois can also be used for making a gilder's cush.

Stephen