New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

ADVERTISE HERE - FREE TRIAL

Katsusaburo by Tesshinsai Hohraku

Posts

Katsusaburo by Tesshinsai Hohraku

#1

Katsusaburo by Tesshinsai Hohraku

Mike in Toronto

Does anyone have experience with this japanese plane at iidaTool?

Tesshinsai Hohraku - Katsusaburo

http://japantool-iida.com/plane_smoothing/2008/10/katsusaburo-by-tesshinsai-hohr.html

I am looking for my first japanese smoothing plane. Is this a good plane to start? i.e. will I need to do much work to the plane other than just sharpening the blade?

They said they can order a dai with 45* bed angle. Would that be enough for curly maple without much tearout?

Re: Katsusaburo by Tesshinsai Hohraku

#2

Ellis Walentine

A general comment

Ellis Walentine

I've never purchased a Japanese plane that didn't need to be fettled (or whatever the Japanese term is for getting it ready to use). Usually, I've had to flatten the sole, clearance the areas of the sole where it is needed (using a Japanese scraper plane, which is the customary way to establish the necessary hollows in the sole), pare the side grooves that hold the blade, open the mouth, etc. It is not a simple process, and you will have to repeat several of these actions relatively frequently, as the dai (plane block) is bound to move slightly with changes in relative humidity, and very small changes can affect planing performance.

Don't let that dissuade you from buying a plane, though. A properly tuned Japanese plane is a joy to use.

Ellis Walentine, Host

Re: Katsusaburo by Tesshinsai Hohraku

#3

Re: Katsusaburo by Tesshinsai Hohraku

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Mike, contact Stu at Tools from Japan

http://www.toolsfromjapan.com/store/index.php?main_page=index

He has a ready-out-of-the-box smoother that has excellent performance. He certainly will advise you in the best way. Excellent fellow.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Katsusaburo by Tesshinsai Hohraku

#4

Re: Katsusaburo by Tesshinsai Hohraku

TomD

The list I had from Mahogany Masterpieces back los day said 42 degrees for birdseye and curly maple. So 45 should be fine. Most of my Japanese planes have been 40 or lower and they plane pretty much everything. My feeling is don't overdo it on the cost side of things for a user. Performances gets real good at low prices. I have at least one treasured plane that has a blade in it from Lee Valley that cost 10.50. I wish I had bought every one. A lot of folks don't use the sub blades so you can buy the planes with the stamped SBs and you can save a lot of money on several fronts. Japan Woodworker has a plane blade for 57 dollars that they claim is hand tempered, yatta, yatta. I'd buy it, other than the fact it is narrower than I personally prefer.

The shipping is pretty horrendous on those plane blades.

I made my early planes myself using white oak, and they worked great. I don't think it is worth the money to get unfinished planes, but ones that are sharpened and set would be worth it for someone possibly starting out. I am not sure how realistic it is to expect those settings to remain stable from one place to another. I have only had one Japanese plane that was unstable, all the rest pretty much stayed stable once in the shop.

Re: Katsusaburo by Tesshinsai Hohraku

#5

Re: A general comment

Schtoo

I've used a kanna, out of the box, and smoothed curly maple, cherry and walnut with it, no tear out. I did sharpen the blade, but even that wasn't absolutely required.

I can even supply video of the feat, if it's necessary...

I've also had kanna that need a goodly amount of working over to be useable, and some that needed sharpening, but not much else.

Of course, I've got more than just a couple dozen laying about too.

Decorum and trumpet blowing prevents me from mentioning much more than that, but it's not always a case of "buy one and hope for the best", even when trying to avoid spending too much money.

Stu,

(Who has Tsunesaburo on speed dial...)

Re: Katsusaburo by Tesshinsai Hohraku

#6

Re: Katsusaburo by Tesshinsai Hohraku

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

I don't have any experience with Katsusaburo planes/blades; but I have considerable experience with Japanese tools and Tomohito Iida (or Iida Tomohito, I never know when they reverse their names just for us, or don't).

First, I highly recommend that a first Japanese plane be relatively small, certainly less than 60 mm, and probably 40-50mm, and cheap. This is because a small plane is easier to fettle and a cheap plane is easier to throw away if fettling is mucked up (however, don't, dai are replaceable).

So, go for it, and tell Tomohito hi for me.

Of course, Stu is also a good vendor (if I get my last order any time soon, that is :)), and Tsunesaburo a great maker.

Pam

Re: Katsusaburo by Tesshinsai Hohraku

#7

Re: Katsusaburo by Tesshinsai Hohraku

wilbur

I'd go for it. Looking around at the Iida Tool website, it's clear that Tesshinsai has the ability to make very high quality planes, and Iida Tool doesn't sell crap. And the price is right for someone looking for an introduction to Japanese planes.

The set up process really isn't too hard. If you can fit a mortise and tenon joint, you can set up a Japanese plane. I have a write up on my blog on how to set up a Japanese plane. Even better are two really good DVDs on Japanese planes and how to set them up, one by Jay Van Arsdale, who is going to be a speaker at Woodworking in America this fall, and one by Harrelson Stanley.

Most Japanese planes are bedded at about 40�. If you're starting out, and if you plan on working with curly maple, if you can get a plane bedded at 45�, I'd take that option. I have a 60mm Japanese plane bedded at 45�, and it's really effective on harder to plane boards. The 40� planes I've used successfully on cherry, walnut, and poplar, but I've had trouble with them on hard maple. Then again, I don't use hard maple much.

Re: Katsusaburo by Tesshinsai Hohraku

#8

Re: A general comment

TomD

I've had very few I didn't build the dai for. When I did the plane seminar (second one) I bought a few weird planes and just asked the plane maker to set them up. This he did in a few minutes. It was worthwhile seeing someone else do it even though I had been doing it for 25 years at that point. But as always it is nice to see a guy working at speed with total confidence. Other than that, they have all required a lot of work. At one time all these tools required a lot of work, in the pre LV or LN days. Normally it was less for the japanese planes and more for their blades. But given one can buy ready to go out of the box western planes, I guess there is a market for that kind of thing.

Re: Katsusaburo by Tesshinsai Hohraku

#9

Re: Katsusaburo by Tesshinsai Hohraku

Mike in Toronto

Thanks everyone. I appreciate your help.

Re: Katsusaburo by Tesshinsai Hohraku

#10

Re: I have some of his work....

David Weaver

I have had three yamamoto planes (that is the maker listed here). They are high quality and a reasonable price. He has a reputation for making good quality straight-forward planes for professionals at a price lower than most other makers.

I have not had a blue steel plane, just special blue cutting steel planes, a white #1, a couple of white #2s and some other specialty steels. From what I know of it, the blue steel #1 shown is a good choice for a first plane - more durable than white #2 that is in a lot of intermediate planes, and more consistent results for the irons that turn out well. Disregard the info out there that it "doesn't get as sharp", that may be true with a lot of older stones or with natural stones that prefer a very plain carbon steel, but there are scads of stones out there now that will sharpen it well.

45 degrees is a good start if you're going to work a lot of hardwoods and you're not used to the type of plane. You can smooth curly maple pretty well with a 38 degree bed, but there is not a lot of margin for user error when doing that, and punishment for making a mistake can be steep.

I have not seen another maker offering as much as yamamoto for as little in cost. It's likely that the backing iron on those planes is wrought iron. If you're going to use it to smooth lots of stuff, I would get the 60mm plane. Small planes might be easier to use initially, but as you get used to the plane, it's easier to get eye-pleasing results (very flat shiny surface) from wider irons.

Re: Katsusaburo by Tesshinsai Hohraku

#11

Ellis Walentine

Interesting

Ellis Walentine

Until today, I was convinced that Japanese planes are purposely made with tight grooves so that the user can adjust the depth and tightness of the iron in his own environment. Likewise, I always thought that no particular care was taken to clearance the sole (or flatten it) because of the likelihood that the wood will move between factory and user. I've had cupped soles and irons that were extremely tightly held between the sides of the plane body opening because (presumably) of wood shrinkage.

I will have a look at Harrelson's tutorial and see how he goes about the preparation process. Thanks for the wake up.

Ellis

Re: Katsusaburo by Tesshinsai Hohraku

#12

Re: Interesting

wilbur

I've had the chance now to see a (small) number of Japanese planes that are new in the box. The soles are really flat. Although you'll be conditioning the sole, it saves a lot of work if you have a flat sole to begin with.

It also seems that the planes are finished to the point where the blade comes down to within 1/4" of the mouth. It doesn't take much work at all to get it much closer.

I don't claim to be an expert on setting up Japanese planes, but I'm comfortable enough with the process now that I can get one completely set up within half an hour, and that's probably pretty slow compared to woodworkers who really know what they're doing, as Tom said. I think Harrelson's DVD is great, but its one downside is that it leaves you with the impression that setting up a Japanese plane is a matter of great delicacy and patience, when I think you should be thinking along the lines of fitting a tenon (the blade) to a mortise (the dai) in terms of how long it should take you to complete this task.

Re: Katsusaburo by Tesshinsai Hohraku

#13

Re: Interesting

Mike in Toronto

Would a tsutsumi style mouth make it trickier to fit the blade into the dai? I was reading Odate's book and he said a tsutsumi mouth does not provide much performance benefit. What is the experience?

Re: Katsusaburo by Tesshinsai Hohraku

#14

Re: Interesting

David Weaver

It can (cause trouble) if it's bumping the bevel of the iron.

I have never noticed *any* benefit that it provides, but it's usually an indicator of a high quality dai because it's not going to be machine cut.

as far as I know at least...

Re: Katsusaburo by Tesshinsai Hohraku

#15

Re: Interesting

TomD

"Until today, I was convinced that Japanese planes are purposely made with tight grooves so that the user can adjust the depth and tightness of the iron in his own environment."

With the Japanese it is always hard to know why they do stuff, since culturally there is some barrier there about the Q&A format, but also as with any culture there can be reasons that are purely traditional and would not be directly acertainable by simply reasoning it out.

But logically, with a good dai, the variation is pretty minimal yet many of the planes sold in the West at least required the blade to be set the final 1/3rd. My comment relative to the pro, related to a blade I had already sharpened. So I bought these planes from Harrelson, sharpened them on his extensive stone collection, gave them to the master to touch up, and bingo. Some blades, can take a significant dimensional change during the fettling process, possibly these would be the cheaper ones of my early carreer, that sometimes even needed nocking out. So if the blade is taken out of the equasion, then the degree to which the plane could be set, and deal with purely environmental changes would certainly be nothing like 1/3rd depth, a few hundreds at most.

Both our cultures have the plane as a kit thing, but equally either of our cultures could supply a finished blade, and in the case of a Japanese dai a nearly finished dai.

"Likewise, I always thought that no particular care was taken to clearance the sole (or flatten it) because of the likelihood that the wood will move between factory and user."

It is possible to make a guitar in the US and send it to Japan, or a in Japan make a guitar and send it to the US. There are some tricks to the process, but basically just the mater of having a target moisture content in mind, comtroling for it, and sometimes determining steps in assembly around it. A plane dai is much simpler as regards this kind of thing, than a guitar.

Where soles are concerned though, there are maters of personal preference involved so finishing that part might be something a chraftsman would want to do himself. That said, you can get great results from fairly crude approaches so whether our market needs this option for the most part, is debateable.

" I've had cupped soles and irons that were extremely tightly held between the sides of the plane body opening because (presumably) of wood shrinkage. "

That sounds like they were made for Japanese conditions and shipped to the US.

Re: Katsusaburo by Tesshinsai Hohraku

#16

Re: Interesting

TomD

I guess the question would be whether it provides any benefit at all. I am always loath to discount the preferences of really serious craftspeople, since it can simply prove out that their being at a totally different level is the necesarry prerequisite. But I really feel this kind of mouth does not offer any benefit, particularly if the plane in question is relieved on the sole behind the cut line. I just don't see the advantage. Maybe it could dampen a harmonic. For the most part it will be slower to fit because you are removing some material from a much more perpendicular surface, this means that you come closer to needing to do a single fitting to advance the blade even the thickness of a shaving. Also, there is a special chisel to do the work. That said I am not sure it will make your job that much worse since if you will be unable to see the benefit, you won't be missing anything, and you will just end up proceeding a little more slowly, no greater skill is really required.

Re: Katsusaburo by Tesshinsai Hohraku

#17

Ellis Walentine

Thanks, Tom

Ellis Walentine

Good insights. It seems that tuning a dai isn't quite a walk in the park. That was and is my experience. I also found that occasional seasonal tuneups were necessary over the life of the plane.

Ellis

Re: Katsusaburo by Tesshinsai Hohraku

#18

Re: Thanks, Tom

David Weaver

Seasonal tune-ups, yes.

There is a comment in one of the books that I have that says japanese planes are less suitable for a casual hobbyist who might use them on a seldom basis because of the movement and fitting.

I can't remember which book it is, though. They do move some, but a good quality dai will not move much. What's more of an issue is if you're going to be very precise about the fit on a good quality dai, don't cut them near loose in a dry winter because they'll surely be loose when summer comes around and they get warmer and wetter.

In my experience, it's good for them to be a tad tight in the winter as long as they have enough lateral room such that the cheeks don't interfere with the iron. But bed to abutment fix can be a tad tight and make for a nice working plane that works well all year.

My seasonal tuning is usually about 5 minutes. a few swipes across 400 grit 4x, a scrape across the hollow with an LN small scraper and some beeswax on the contact strips. Refresh as needed if wear dictates.

The first dai I fit took about 45 minutes or an hour ( a cheap funjii plane ) . The last dai I fit took less than ten minutes in a never-used plane ( a mosaku with a maker-stamped dai - can't remember the maker, but the high $$ maker stamped dais have been closer to perfect in my experience, with only little uniform material removal to advance the iron).

Re: Katsusaburo by Tesshinsai Hohraku

#19

Re: Thanks, Tom

TomD

I haven't had to do seasonal tune-ups. I have one plane that just went bat crazy the first season, but other than that I have not had to do much. I have two thoughts on that:

- My work might be a little seasonal also. That just isn't the main story, but it is part of it. Here I am again a thousand miles away not spending summer in my shop, though I have.

- I use a range of planes. While I don't do a lot of tuning on my finish planes all that much, I also have planes that run the gamut through planes that take such heavy cuts that a seasonal move would not be an issue anyway. People have been oversold the whole finish plane idea for Japanese planes also. I have planes that hog off like an axe, and they get a lot of use.

Another thought is on the wood. I make most of my dais I have made everything from dais of laminated ebony to beech. The only ones I didn't like were maple, but that could even have been a skill thing at the time. There are ways of limiting wood movement that are not normally tried, like lamination, certain more effective sealings and grain orientation, so there could be progress.

I don't really think beginers should be steered away from japanese planes even if they do move a little. You only leave beginner status behind through embrassing opportunities, and as david says there are pretty easy ways to get good results. Japanese planes need less tuning once they are in place, because they have only two small contact areas to flatten, and seasonal movement certainly hasn't bothered my seating depth. I'm sure there could be cases, but that has not been an issue for me.

Re: Katsusaburo by Tesshinsai Hohraku

#20

Re: Thanks, Tom

Mike in Toronto

Another beginner question. Since there is no wedge in a Japanese plane like the western plane, does that mean once the plane is setup to take thick shavings like a jack plane, it can't be setup to take thinner shavings? The blade would have been quite loose when it is backed up, no?

Thanks.

Re: Katsusaburo by Tesshinsai Hohraku

#21

Re: Thanks, Tom

David Weaver

Depending on how you have the plane set up, you will likely not use the same plane to do both, unless it's something like setting a narrow smoother to take a thick cut.

The fit of the iron to the abutments will allow you plenty of movement for a plane to be set up for a heavy shaving (as heavy as you'll want to tolerate on an iron that has a smoother camber or no camber) as well as a smooth shaving, especially on a white oak dai.

I also agree with Tom that it's a bit of a disservice for anyone to try to tell beginners that japanese planes are not suitable for them. Like sharpening saws, it is far easier to take care of and tune japanese planes than it is to do good woodworking with *any* style of planes.

Re: Katsusaburo by Tesshinsai Hohraku

#22

Re: Thanks, Tom

Schtoo

Nope, no problem at all unless you open the mouth up as well.

The 'wedging' action is very slight, and it's more friction fit than actual wedging.

Plus, when Japanese white oak is used there's a lot of spring in the wood, so even when the fit is tight and the cut depth heavy, it'll spring back without any trouble. Other woods, including Japanese red oak, less spring. The worst is ebony, but still it's used for plane bodies because folks like the look of it. I don't own one of them and probably never will. I'd get disowned if I did, and they're becoming rarer to find anyway.

However, if you've got a tsutsumi (closed) mouth body, then the blade may push that out, which will cause more problems.

While we're on the subject, a better quality plane will most often have a tsutsumi mouth, but it's not a sign of superior quality just an 'expected feature' and a hold over from an earlier time where the tsutsumi was a sign of a superior quality plane body. None of the extra bodies I've ever sent out were specified to have tsutsumi, nobody has said anything about it and Tsunesaburo have never asked "Hey, does this thing need tsutsumi?" because it doesn't actually mean anything on a better class of plane. Folks here expect it, they're made with it in place and I leave it be, even though I could ask for all planes to be made without it and perhaps save a few bucks on the price.

Kinda like having a brass knob and screws on an iron plane. It doesn't do anything, it doesn't improve the performance but it's expected and woe betide any plane maker who dared eliminate it without finding another way to dress up the pig. ;)

Hope that helps.

Stu.

Re: Katsusaburo by Tesshinsai Hohraku

#23

Re: I have only made one...and a question..

David Weaver

..I've only made one dai. About 18 inches long because I wanted one of that size and I already have the iron.

I made it out of hard maple, and I don't like it. It chipped out a bit around the mouth. Not much, but enough to be annoying, and for its hardness and durability, maple just isn't that nice to work with given that there are beech, birch and other woods very close in hardness to maple that are a lot nicer to work.

Here's the question: How do you mark the abutments to fit the irons before you saw them? I cut the center of the dai with an old firmer chisel, and then marked for the iron, but since you can't fit the iron in the mortise before cutting the plane for it, it's difficult to mark the abutments accurately, which results in creeping up on what they should be - a major pain. Do you make something of similar taper to the iron to mark the inside of the mortise to cut it to fit?

Re: Katsusaburo by Tesshinsai Hohraku

#24

Re: I have only made one...and a question..

TomD

The dai is squared up David. A line marks the back of the iron, and this is the primary angle line. If using a sen layout rule the basic angles are functions of the basic sen fractions that are decimals (like 8/10, etc...) But in this case call it 45 degrees (I use 40 the most). That line is carried all the way around the dai. The blade is then brought up against that line on the side of the dai, but held up it about 1/3 the line's length, so that if you could perfectly laser cut out everything the blade would only sink in 1/3 of the way before tightening starts. Since this line when traced at the back of the blade will be short of the base, it is then extended all the way around the plane.

The mouth etc... if memory serves is one ruler width ahead of the mouth position (projected to the top of the block) drawn down to the line just described that will bed the back of the blade. this makes it land behind the mouth, and it is either drawn down perp to the mouth or parallel to the blade depending on whether a sub blade is used.

Sorry I don't have CAD here to make this simpler, but I think your primary answer is in the first few lines.

OK, so as regards your abutments, you will have two parallel lines across the top of the dai, and two across the base, connected on the side. You open the mouth in line with the primary angle line and back of blade line. You set the block on it's side, and place the saw so the tooth engages at the mouth position on the base of the plane, and is visible about the forward layout line on the top of the dai, just cut it in. Flip it over and do the same again. The angle line is the index at the mouth and the visual reference to the layout. It is a pretty easy cut, and I don't generally try to clean it up unless something went wrong. I used to use the Lee Valley flush cut ryobi for this cut, but got an actual saw for doing it just like a big time saw maker. But in all honesty the LV Ryobi is about as reliable. Once you have the forward cut made you can either do the rear the same way but flush to the ramp, or you can do it with a chisel.

The blade is fitted by chisel, but a float doesn't hurt. I contend that the reason the blade bevel side is transverse hollow is to make chisel fitting easier, though who cares. One thing I noticed was the master drives the blades home like the last spike in the railway. This may accelerate fitting, ensure the fit stays tight, but it also makes correct max dept repeatable. Just drop the blade in, a few taps and it is there. Before I copied this practice, many of my blades were loose. It is amazing how little retention is required to get a cut but it is better when tight.

Re: Katsusaburo by Tesshinsai Hohraku

#25

Re: I have only made one...and a question..

TomD

I should say that by holding the blade up the layout line, you make the abutments and ram position too tight for the blade, but this allows you to do these initial rough cuts without a worry that the blade will be loose.