Re: Interesting
TomD
"Until today, I was convinced that Japanese planes are purposely made with tight grooves so that the user can adjust the depth and tightness of the iron in his own environment."
With the Japanese it is always hard to know why they do stuff, since culturally there is some barrier there about the Q&A format, but also as with any culture there can be reasons that are purely traditional and would not be directly acertainable by simply reasoning it out.
But logically, with a good dai, the variation is pretty minimal yet many of the planes sold in the West at least required the blade to be set the final 1/3rd. My comment relative to the pro, related to a blade I had already sharpened. So I bought these planes from Harrelson, sharpened them on his extensive stone collection, gave them to the master to touch up, and bingo. Some blades, can take a significant dimensional change during the fettling process, possibly these would be the cheaper ones of my early carreer, that sometimes even needed nocking out. So if the blade is taken out of the equasion, then the degree to which the plane could be set, and deal with purely environmental changes would certainly be nothing like 1/3rd depth, a few hundreds at most.
Both our cultures have the plane as a kit thing, but equally either of our cultures could supply a finished blade, and in the case of a Japanese dai a nearly finished dai.
"Likewise, I always thought that no particular care was taken to clearance the sole (or flatten it) because of the likelihood that the wood will move between factory and user."
It is possible to make a guitar in the US and send it to Japan, or a in Japan make a guitar and send it to the US. There are some tricks to the process, but basically just the mater of having a target moisture content in mind, comtroling for it, and sometimes determining steps in assembly around it. A plane dai is much simpler as regards this kind of thing, than a guitar.
Where soles are concerned though, there are maters of personal preference involved so finishing that part might be something a chraftsman would want to do himself. That said, you can get great results from fairly crude approaches so whether our market needs this option for the most part, is debateable.
" I've had cupped soles and irons that were extremely tightly held between the sides of the plane body opening because (presumably) of wood shrinkage. "
That sounds like they were made for Japanese conditions and shipped to the US.