New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Super Resolution Thermal Imaging Camera

Bun Feet

Posts

Bun Feet

#1

Bun Feet

Bill Tindall


Derek asked in an email about bun feet and I thought it might be useful to post the reply. Pictured is a poor bun foot. Alan Batty gave me a lesson on bun feet and this is what I learned from this poor example. First, it is too flat at the equator. Alan took about 1/32 off just above and below the equator and things looked much better. Second, and far more subtle is the transition between the sphere and the cove. The arc of the sphere should smoothly make the transition from the sphere to the cove. The result is that the cove will be asymmetrical. The radius of the part adjacent to the sphere will be less than the other half.


Now here is a magnificent bun foot employing the improvements described above. A day with Alan convinced me that I will never be able to turn to the standards of a professional turner. There are too many details to learn.

Re: Bun Feet

#2

Re: Bun Feet

Bruce, a MN Galoot

that's a pretty good bun foot, Bill. I've made them for a couple pieces and have never been satisfied with the results. It's good to know what makes for a better one.

Re: Bun Feet

#3

Re: Bun Feet

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Bill

Many thanks for posting the pictures of the bun feet (for the benefit of others, Bill and I have been communicating about this construction off-forum, but this is the first time I have seen his buns :) ).

My first response is that I would have liked to see the cabinet the bun feet was intended for. This makes a difference ... big difference. I may get into some hot water on glue, but I (like others) have an opinion about buns (OK, no more suggestive puns intended).

It is all about proportons, and the bun feet have to blend in with the cabinet. It may be possible to see the choices as being buns-for-high-cabinets and buns-for-low-cabinets.

Here is a high cabinet:


You will see that the bun is "stretched" - tall. I would place the bun that was shaped for you into this category.

Then there are buns for low cabinets. They come out squat and short...


I was planning something along the lines of the last example. However I disliked the transition area and intended to reshape it similar to the one you posted.

Back to yours ..


.. appears to be a combination of the two above. I like the transition. I am not sure about its height. I would want to try and reduce some of the area between the transition and the "bun" part.

Ideas?

I have a second area I want to run past the forum, but will post this separately.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Bun Feet

#4

Question for Derek

patrick gibbons

What if you made a bun for your cabinets that had no transition and were just a flattened round bead? As if one took a ball of bread dough and patted it between two hands to flatten it out. In my mind's eye it looks good.

Re: Bun Feet

#5

Re: Question for Derek

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

What if you made a bun for your cabinets that had no transition and were just a flattened round bead? As if one took a ball of bread dough and patted it between two hands to flatten it out. In my mind's eye it looks good.

Hi Patrick

I've been playing around with something like that...

This is the "squat" bun ...


I think that the square transitional section needs to be rounded. Now if I manipulate the bun that Bill posted, we have this ..


That is very close to what I have in mind (just a little more hollowed at the start of the transition). What do you think?

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Bun Feet

#6

I like it

Ian (in Sydney, Australia)

but maybe a bit more curve into the cove at the top

Re: Bun Feet

#7

Ellis Walentine

Re: Question for Derek

Ellis Walentine

Hi Derek,

I would agree that the square transition element isn't very attractive. What to do about it is another matter. In Bill's example, there is a classical transition from the round of the bun foot to an accelerating cove, mediated by a quirk. When looked at from a distance, Bill's example takes on a nicely proportioned, vase-like shape, ending in the artfully contrived bun shape. It is a comparatively tall foot, probably best suited to a more vertical chest where the intent is to thrust it visually off the floor.

In your mocked-up image of the shape you are contemplating, the transition from the foot to the cove is more abrupt, with no real transitional element. That's just a statement of fact, not a value judgment. The real question is, how do we design these sorts of elements?

Here's a bun foot with no transition at all, designed without much agonizing, in a rush to get the job completed by Christmas morning, about ten years ago. In retrospect, a little transition like the one you're considering would have lifted the chest visually, but since the space between the floor and the bottom of the chest is so small, you'd almost have to be on your hands and knees to see any quirks or coves that I might have made there. So, I think I would subscribe to the theory that squatter feet and lower transitions are more suitable for low case pieces like this.


I'm not clever enough to have a formula for the size or shape or placement of the foot element. Antique masterpieces are probably the most instructional influences we have, but, even then, original design will always rely on our own sense of what works best. This is one reason why mockups are so helpful. Often, what looks good on paper shows its flaws and shortcomings when mocked up at full size, usually because of differences in perspective as you walk around the piece and view it from all angles.This is one reason why circles and ellipses are among the most pleasing forms, as they retain a pure shape regardless of the viewing angle.

Just trying to lend a couple ideas to a really interesting discussion.

Ellis

Re: Bun Feet

#8

The heck with the feet where'd ya get the bear?

Ron Bauman

Re: Bun Feet

#9

Ellis Walentine

Original art

Ellis Walentine

... well, original knockoff by my artist wife. :)


Re: Bun Feet

#10

Oh my.... bun foot placement......

Bill Tindall

When I installed my first bun feet I wondered where should they go. So I researched antique pieces and found much variation in their location under the piece. I finally made two feet without tenons and two matching blocks for the back of the piece. I located the piece in its destination and moved the feet around over the course of some days until I thought I had found the best address for them.

BTW, the better bun foot from my pictures is on a chest of drawers about waist high. It looks mighty fine there. A better version of the oak foot is on a trunk and it looks good there too. But for Derek's piece I agree that a shorter foot is appropriate.

Re: Bun Feet

#11

Re: Question for Derek

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Ellis

That is a really nice chest. Really sweet.

I take your point about the issue of the transition being moot at this height. A simple bun, in fact, fits in better with my return to a minimalistic design.

Regard from Perth

Derek

Re: Bun Feet

#12

Ellis Walentine

Thanks, Derek

Ellis Walentine

I had fun with that chest. It was a present for my infant grandson, and a good use for some 18"-wide spruce boards that would have been barn siding otherwise. The simple bun feet seemed in keeping with the nature of the design.

Ellis

Re: Bun Feet

#13

I think Ellis' solution was simple and elegant

patrick gibbons