New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Support WoodCentral when buying things you need

The diamond plane blade

Posts

The diamond plane blade

#1

The diamond plane blade

Bill Tindall


Thought some might be interested in seeing what a sharp plane blade looked like on the micron scale of things. This image is the back(flat side) of the diamond coated blade. Steve Elliot sharpened the blade before coating.

I will leave it to Steve to describe the sharpening used for this test.

Re: The diamond plane blade

#2

Blade Back Polishing

Steve Elliott

The diamond coating was done on a Lee Valley A2 blade for a BU smoother. My goal was to get the back of the blade as polished as I could and I don't actually recall what the grit sequence was. I started with waterstones to see if I could remove any rogue scratches and found that I couldn't. Then I went to fine diamond on cast iron and I think I stopped at 1/4 micron. After that I used 1/4 micron diamond on boxwood, which increased the brightness of the mirror finish quite a bit but left a few rogue scratches, as can be seen in the microscope image.

My gut feeling is that this level of sharpness is not necessary for any practical work and is probably only useful for fine shaving contests, if then. It�s humbling to see what my best edge looks like at that magnification.

Re: The diamond plane blade

#3

It would be interesting.....

Bill Tindall

to have pictures of my sharpening efforts, your better efforts and the finest edge on a Japanese iron. So far Ron Hock, you and especially myself are all humbled at the micron scale of imaging.

Re: The diamond plane blade

#4

Very Sharpest Edges

Steve Elliott

". . . the finest edge on a Japanese iron"

I've found that for edge sharpness an arris formed by the intersection of two narrow bevels beats one formed by the intersection of one or more larger surfaces. The hollows on the backs of Japanese plane blades naturally result in a narrow surface being honed next to the cutting edge--a very effective and practical aid to achieving sharpness.

For the diamond coated blade I was polishing a much larger area and despite the mirror-like surface the edge itself was less sharp than what I usually get by using a very narrow back bevel, and took much longer to achieve.

Re: The diamond plane blade

#5

Re: Why?

TomD

If the coating is successful, does it mater whether it is applied over A2 or O1, for example. A Japanese Blade is basically an Iron blade that is coated with tool steel. What the Iron is doesn't mater much to the edge holding. As a secondary characteristic though, it may mater as far as retarding sharpening, etc... which could mater to edge holding as relates to initial sharpness. On that basis a cleaner sharpening steel like O1 could even be better...

Re: The diamond plane blade

#6

role of underlying metal

Bill Tindall

These coatings are very thin, only a few microns in thickness. Hence, they provide no mechanical properties to the object, only potential abrasion or corrosion resistance. For example, I hardness tested the TiN coated blade and it didn't matter whether I tested where the coating was applied or where it wasn't. If nothing else, a hard and tough material under the coating is required to prevent dulling by edge deformation and chipping.

What kind of abrasion resistance is optimum under the coating is a question worth pondering. A beaver maintains sharp teeth by employing a tooth with an abrasion resistant outer layer and a soft interior. Such a structure is self sharpening and it works well for milling wood. I was told by the coating companies that this situation was replicated with TiN coated tooling, such as end mills and the like. This is not the situation we found for the plane iron as revealed by the pictures of the TiN coated edge after planing maple.

It is becoming clearer that the topic of dulling in hand tools is complex. In these cases optimums are often found by trial and error over a long time, a variety of evolution. The current problem is that we have had a discontinuity in the "trials and errors" resulting from a pause in wide spread hand tool use(machine age) and the appearance of new technology (new metals, new fabrication, new woods, etc).

I have no doubt that a Japanese chisel fabricated traditionally is the optimum for that metal, wood material worked and process of working it. They had many years to evolve the tool and product in a stable environment. Now change the game by introducing western joinery, African wood, modern steels and fabrication, amateur craftsmen and it could well be that there are dozens of optimums for these combinations with the result that the optimum for your combination is different from another's combination.

Thankfully, they are all "good enough" as evidenced by the fine furniture being made by persons using a great variety of tooling.

Re: The diamond plane blade

#7

A good reason for the ruler trick ?!

David Charlesworth

Steve's comment ties in well with my experience with the ruler trick.

And anyway, why polish large areas of metal which do no cutting?

David

Re: The diamond plane blade

#8

Re: A good reason for the ruler trick ?!

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Because there's more to a chisel than simply cutting. How about cutting reliably? Straight up or down or sideways? Angled up or down or sideways? Knowing that the edge will cut where you expect it to? Not slashing your hands?

Pam

PS I don't intend to trash your trick, think it's quite innovative; but I do have to wonder why the manufacturers go to the trouble of flattening the backs.

Re: The diamond plane blade

#9

Re: Why manufacturers do not use the ruler trick

North of the Border

There're many reasons why David's trick is not used that we can venture, including the fact that the trick applies only to plane (or scraper) irons/blades but not chisels. Manufacturers may prefer to have one set of operation for flattening.

Another reason can be that flattening the whole piece of metal or steel is simpler than otherwise in terms of set-up or cutting as no angle is involved. Or perhaps, resistance to change is the explanation (if it ain't broke, don't fix it). Of course, these are just my guesses and the best answers should come from the tool makers.

Re: The diamond plane blade

#10

Re: Why manufacturers do not use the ruler trick

David Charlesworth

Pam,

I have never suggested ruler trick for chisels. It would be silly. Chisel would have to be raised by 2/3rds of a degree to make a straight cut.

David

Re: The diamond plane blade

#11

Re: Why manufacturers do not use the ruler trick

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

My rhetorical question was: I wonder why manufacturers bother to make the backs of chisels (should have been "blades") flat. The point being that manufacturers go to a lot of trouble to flatten blade backs, chisels and plane blades. Perhaps we should just tell them not to bother, we'll take care of it?

Pam

Re: The diamond plane blade

#12

Re: Why manufacturers do not use the ruler trick

David Charlesworth

Well I don't think so. For ruler trick to work well, (it is performed on polishing stone only), the back of the blade needs to be reasonably flat, with deep manufacturers grinding scratches removed by something like 800 or 1,000 grit.

Flatness is also needed for a good chipbreaker fit.

Of course with the wonderful new lapped Veritas blades, I can go straight to ruler trick. My polishing stone is something like 8,000 or 10,000 grit.

best wishes,

David

Re: The diamond plane blade

#13

Re: role of underlying metal

TomD

"I have no doubt that a Japanese chisel fabricated traditionally is the optimum for that metal, wood material worked and process of working it. They had many years to evolve the tool and product in a stable environment."

"Now change the game by introducing western joinery, African wood, modern steels and fabrication, amateur craftsmen and it could well be that there are dozens of optimums for these combinations with the result that the optimum for your combination is different from another's combination."

Japanese do have plenty of African hardness woods. The first great Japanese chisels I bought back around 1980 had macassar ebony handles, which is a fairly hard wood. And planes were also made of that wood. Both of which I regard as a mistake... But they do use hard woods.

I was interested that one of the links Derek provided for plane makers showed quite a massive variety of plane materials, including some plane blades made with Sandvik Steel!

Re: The diamond plane blade

#14

Re: Why manufacturers do not use the ruler trick

Chris Friesen

I seem to recall reading a quote from Rob Lee in a woodworking article that the current level of manufacturing precision is basically due to the fact that it's what customers are asking for, not what they actually need.

That said, the lapped blade backs are sweet. Lapped chisel backs would be even better. :)

Re: The diamond plane blade

#15

Re: Why manufacturers do not use the ruler trick

joel moskowitz

In Japan backs aren't flat. They aren't supposed to be flat. In the west, when manufacturing was done traditionally after hardening, chisel and plane blades were checked for concavity and then the bevels were put on the other side.

In both traditions that gave you a chisel or plane iron that was hollow in the back and could be trivially sharpened on the back to the cutting edge.

With drop forged tools the side bevels are done at the forge before hardening so you can't do this. And most manufacturers don't want to take the time/ have the skilled labor force can can orient their raw blanks correctly - so the practice died out.

So you started getting blades and chisels with bellies on the backs.

Grinding them however doesn't really cure the problem as most magnetic chucks will pull whatever is being ground flat and then after grinding it springs back.

Most modern makers pretty much have licked the flatness issue and can grind things flat most of the time.

If you take a flat surface and try to hone it you either put pressure on the edge to get the edge fully polished or you do something like the ruler trick to explicitly just polish the tiny bit at the cutting edge. in both cases you end up with a back that is rounded more or less. If you polish the entire back of a tool when you first get it you will remove any concavity you might have - which is bad, and long term the chasing the burr will cause a convexity. Over the years folks have realized that this isn't really a big deal to worry about.

N.B. All the Iles Brothers are still making sure the backs of chisels and irons are hollow but they are a special case.