New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

THE WOODRAT IS BACK!

Does the back of the plane blade need sharpening?

Posts

Does the back of the plane blade need sharpening?

#1

Does the back of the plane blade need sharpening?

Bill Tindall

There was a recent discussion on whether the flat side of a plane iron should, or was best to, abrade during a sharpening routine or whether it was adequate to just abrade the bevel. One claim was that it was more efficient to abrade the back and the bevel. Another claim was that grinding the bevel removed wear from the back just fine and that it was not essential to touch the back. The following picture provides some data in this discussion.

The picture shows the flat side of two plane irons after planing 50 meters of hard maple, approximately 0.001" shaving thickness. The gold blade is titanium nitride coated. Both blades are Hock A2. The image was made with light reflected perpendicular to the blade surface ("bright field illumination".

The worn surface of the metal is easily distinguished by the pitted , or lumpy (we know not which), surface. The length of this wear is indicated by the scale. In the case of the TiN coated blade the wear is easily seen because it has abraded away the gold coating.

The length of this wear is in the order of 0.0015". So, to remove this wear by grinding only the bevel the length of the blade would need to be shortened by more than 0.0015". We do not know how much the thickness would have to be abraded to remove the wear by only grinding the back.

The wear pattern is curious. It looks just like pit corrosion. Corrosion is a significant wear mechanism in high speed wood machining. Or, what looks like pits could be bumps. In this case the bumps may be hard alloying carbide grains. We hope to get an scanning electron microscope image to resolve this question.

Re: Does the back of the plane blade need sharpening?

#2

Moses Yoder

Re: Does the back of the plane blade need sharpeni

Moses Yoder

Very interesting pick, Bill. It really looks like pits to me, and almost has to be, because of the woods force on the iron. There really isn't any way to tell how deep they are, is there? I don't remove metal from the front edge of the iron when I grind, I just come close to the edge. Then hone on 1000 grit stone until I get a burr. So maybe the full .0015 is being removed when the bevel is honed. I polish the bevel, then remove the burr on an 8000 grit stone, polishing the back with a few extra strokes. It would be interesting to see the iron (without plating) sharpened with your standard technique and then photographed on the back before use to see whether the pits have been removed.

It does appear as though the coating prevented the wear on the back from being as bad as the uncoated.

Re: Does the back of the plane blade need sharpening?

#3

Re: Does the back of the plane blade need sharpeni

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Bill

Those are wonderfully clear photos. However I am a little confused by them - are they the "back" of the blade? Surely the bevel would not be visible when photographing the back of the blade?

What we are wanting to see is the formation of a wear bevel. That would be on the back of the blade.

One last point. For reference, if this blade from a BU or BD plane?

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Does the back of the plane blade need sharpening?

#4

Some Additional Information

Steve Elliott

�The length of this wear is in the order of 0.0015". So, to remove this wear by grinding only the bevel the length of the blade would need to be shortened by more than 0.0015". We do not know how much the thickness would have to be abraded to remove the wear by only grinding the back.�

I�ve been working on ways to determine the shape of a worn edge. My best results have come from using a shoulder plane and putting the corner of the blade under my 540x microscope. I�m on my fifth test of this type and was going to wait for more complete results before posting this but since the issue has come up I�ll post a representative image.

Here�s a microscope image of a blade after it had planed 250 lineal feet of cherry. This blade was somewhat soft and the plane had begun to balk at this point in the test.


The blue line shows the bed angle of the shoulder plane and the part labeled �back bevel� shows where a 2-1/2 degree back bevel was put on the blade when it was sharpened. The part of the image in the black box was enlarged in Photoshop to produce this diagram:


On the left of the image are two lines that show the thickness of the shavings. The gray lines show the profile of the blade when it was sharp. The amount of metal loss on the top surface was a surprise to me. My mental image of a worn edge was based on a diagram in Bruce Hoadley�s excellent book �Understanding Wood� (figure 5 on p. 153) which shows �stages of dulling." That image shows an increasingly rounded edge but no significant loss of steel higher on the upper surface of the blade.

I�m working on making more images at different stages of dulling to determine how shaving thickness and blade geometry affect this wear shape.

These images give an idea of how much steel would need to be removed from the back of the blade to remove the upper wear bevel.

Re: Does the back of the plane blade need sharpening?

#5

Re: Some Additional Information

Warren in Lancaster, PA

It would be interesting to see a picture of the edge before any dulling also. I think how you impose your original (sharp) profile on the picture has a big influence on how you interpret the wear. There is a hump in the lower surface that is outside of your original line.

Re: Does the back of the plane blade need sharpening?

#6

More Images *LINK*

Steve Elliott

I have the original sharp edge image that I can post but my time is short today because I'm getting ready for a backpacking trip over the weekend.

Here's a more complete set of images from another test.


For a full-size version of this image click on the link below.

Each of the images in this composite are small portions of much larger microscope images. If you have a program that supports layers it's possible to assemble the edge profiles in sequence and watch the edge as it progressively wears away.

The hump on the lower edge may be the result of a piece of debris on the blade or it could be caused by some deformation of this fairly soft blade. I've been tuning up an infill shoulder plane with a laminated blade to use in future tests because the steel in it is much closer to what I consider typical for good blades.


Full-sized Image

Re: Does the back of the plane blade need sharpening?

#7

Answers.

Bill Tindall

The image is of the flat side of the blade. The details of the microscope stage and mode of imaging precludes me from imaging the bevel. The blade was mounted in an ancient but refurbished Stanley 605 for planing.

Re: Does the back of the plane blade need sharpening?

#8

Re: Answers.

Bill Tindall

As these blades are mounted in the plane you are looking at the top of the blade (the non-beveled side).

The microscope used for this imaging is set up (lenses, lighting, etc) to view metal surfaces. While it would be of interest to image the blade bevel this imaging would require construction of some device to hold the blade on the microscope stage such that the bevel surface was perpendicular to the axis of observation.