New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This $39 jig will make you a WOODWORKING GOD!

Shooting board question. #5 a good choice?

Posts

Shooting board question. #5 a good choice?

#1

Shooting board question.  #5 a good choice?

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

Hello.

I made a shooting board over the weekend. I had some left over pieces of cherry plywood I used for it. I cut 2 pieces and put one on top of the other. The top board is about 3" narrower than the bottom with a strip of straight grained ash glued to it for the plane to ride against. My fence was made from a scrap piece of walnut. The fence is attached with a steel pin at one end and a knob at the other with an elongated hole for squaring up.

Seems to work fine; except I got a blister on my hand using it somehow - wasn't sure the best way to hold and/or control the plane... I put some wax on the bed for the plane to ride on.

I was using a #4 and it occurred to me later I should maybe use a heavier plane.

I have a limited number of planes - #4, #5, and a #6. As well as a few others like

a LV BU smoother that wouldn't work for this.

Two Questions:

#1

I'd like to get a new #5. My current #5 is in pretty bad shape. I had been thinking about getting one of the

Woodriver V3 #5 and trying one of those. For the money, are these decent

planes? The V3 versions seem to get okay reviews.

I know the source of the Woodriver plane, and would prefer an LN or LV plane, but the Woodriver plane fits my budget nicely.

#2

I had the #4 set to a very fine shaving. But once in a while it would catch and dig

into the piece of ash it rides against. I noticed the lateral adjustment lever kept

moving on me. I've never had that happen with normal use. Am I doing something

wrong?

It has never been clear to me how tight the screw should be on the lever cap.

Thanks for any advice or suggestions.

Joe

(not a hard-core hand tool guy)

Re: Shooting board question. #5 a good choice?

#2

The BU smoother is worth a try.

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Re: Shooting board question. #5 a good choice?

#3

Re: Shooting board question.  #5 a good choice?

James Watriss

I'm not a fan of wood river. I'm a snob, and I get that. Maybe they're decent planes. I don't really care. I think you could get a decent vintage bailey, or bedrock, for less, and it would work as well or better.

That said, I'll second the recommendation for the bevel-up. The logic being that it's basically a large block plane, which has a lower angle better suited for trimming end grain, like you do on a shooting board.

Not only that, they tighten up a lot better, which is something you want in a plane.

Re: tightening the lever cap...

Old school woodies used a wedge that pretty much immobilized the iron. Infill planes use a different method, but the screw down lever cap also bolts things down pretty tightly. If you needed to adjust the iron, you use small hammer taps. Japanese planes, the iron is wedge shaped. Modern low-angle planes also use a screw-down lever cap, and some of them you can do your lateral adjusting with a small hammer. It seems to be the common theme among planes that function well... from infills to Clark and Williams woodies, Holtey to Krenov, the blade is bolted down nice and tight... and that's what makes it work so well.

Ideally, you simply don't want the iron to be able to move at all. But, this causes a lot of wear and tear on mechanical adjusters like you get on the Bailey style planes and their numerous descendants, so we ended up with lever caps and the like, which hold things tightly enough to get by, but loosely enough that they can move. But... if you can make things fit more tightly, you're better off.

Re: Shooting board question. #5 a good choice?

#4

A few references that may help ...

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Joe

I have a bunch of articles on building, setting up, and using shooting boards ..

http://www.inthewoodshop.com/ShopMadeTools/Setting%20Up%20and%20Using%20a%20Shooting%20Board4.html

http://www.inthewoodshop.com/ShopMadeTools/Advances%20in%20a%20ramped%20shooting%20board.html

This one is a significant upgrade: http://www.inthewoodshop.com/ShopMadeTools/RunningFencefortheShootingBoard.html


Then there is an article on comparing planes for shooting boards ...

http://www.inthewoodshop.com/Furniture/ShootingPlanesCompared.html


If nothing else the reading will keep you out of trouble!

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Shooting board question. #5 a good choice?

#5

Derek covered it very well

Neal in San Jose

A couple of points. I think people tend to over think the plane. I've used many different planes successfully, everything from a small block plane to a #8. I usually grab whatever plane is on the bench at the time. If I'm going to do more than a couple of pieces, tho, my go-to plane is my LN BU jack. The determining factor, like everything else hand-plane-related, is sharp.

I own a couple of Wood River planes, and like them quite a lot. Disclaimer: I teach at a couple of venues, and one of them is a Woodcraft shop. I tried the Wood River planes when they first came out, as they seemed to be a good answer to a question that comes up often: What is a good, reasonably priced plane that a beginner might buy and use until s/he decides if this hand tool gig is what they want to do. I can recommend the Wood Rivers and know they will really never need to upgrade.

Re: Shooting board question. #5 a good choice?

#6

Re: Shooting board question.  #5 a good choice?

Doug Reynolds in Seattle

Joe: I've been paying close attention to Derek's testing reviews and, went to a recent Lie-Nielsen Handtool Event. I don't think you will be happy with anything less than a brand new Lie-Nielsen 51 shooting plane ;^). We can all dream right? My vote is for the LN Low Angle Jack otherwise.

Re: Shooting board question. #5 a good choice?

#7

I know Doug, all I do is...

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

dream too. :)

The LN would be nice, as well as the LV.

Woodcraft is having a nice sale this Friday and Saturday. 15% off everything. I think that is the local Cleveland store only - need to look at the flier again.

I also have a $25 off card. So I am leaning towards the woodriver #5.

Thanks.

Re: Shooting board question. #5 a good choice?

#8

It doesn't have a flat side though.

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

Re: Shooting board question. #5 a good choice?

#9

Thanks, and a couple comments

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

Thanks for the responses.

Pam, I gave my Veritas� Bevel-Up Smoother Plane another try. Although is doesn't have a flat sided sole (is that the correct term?) it actually worked well; better than my current #5 and/or #6.

Derek, thanks for the links to your articles. I have actually seen those before. I am a fan of your work and writings. I've spent time on your site.

Thanks everybody.

Joe

Re: Shooting board question. #5 a good choice?

#10

Glad it worked for you, non-flat sides and all.

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Re: Shooting board question. #5 a good choice?

#11

Why not?

North of the Border

I don't have any WR planes, but if I had a $25 card and could get the 15% off deal, I'd definitely get one of those...I'd still use my LV planes mostly but would put a blade sharpened at a different angle in the WR and use it for certain planing tasks. FW has given the best value tag to one of the WR planes (forgot which #) as well as to two other LV planes.

Re: Shooting board question. #5 a good choice?

#12

Re: Shooting board question.  #5 a good choice?

bugbear

My preferred plane for shooting (from quite a wide range I happen to have...) is my #6.

You may find a grip you find comfortable, or you could try this, from the sainted Alf.

http://cornishworkshop.blogspot.com/2011/01/peters-principle.html

(re-told here:

http://www.leevalley.com/US/newsletters/Woodworking/5/5/article1.htm

)

BugBear

Re: Shooting board question. #5 a good choice?

#13

Interesting.  Thank you.

Joe in a Cleveland suburb