Re: Observation
Sgian Dubh
"It strikes me that those who are dedicated freehand sharpeners (essentially to whom this article is aimed) are less likely to use a BU plane..."
I guess I fall into the category of "dedicated freehand sharpener" Derek. Whilst it's true that most of my planing is undertaken with bevel down planes such as jack, try and smoothing planes, I frequently use a block plane, which is a bevel up plane.
I have always sharpened these bevel up plane blades freehand, and without any frustration. Granted, I use a grinding angle of about 25� or thereabouts-- it's hard to know for sure as I work the grinding angle freehand as well, and not the sort of angles you're discussing, about 50�.
Getting a curve on the blade using freehand honing techniques is fairly straightforward I find, ie, sharpen as normal on the stone which means adding extra pressure towards one edge of the blade for a few strokes, followed by adding a bit of pressure on the other edge for an equivalent number of strokes. That seems to do it quite nicely, but I admit I'm not working at the same high angles you are working on, which quite possibly makes it all a bit trickier.
I suppose another old trick is to just use a slightly hollowed out oilstone, which is something that seems to occur quite naturally I've found! There's a joke in that last statement-- all oilstones with evidence of some use seem to be at least slightly hollow, if not actually rutted, ha, ha. Slainte.