New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A55 Smoothing Plane

Hybrid Profile for Freehand Sharpening BU Blades

Posts

Hybrid Profile for Freehand Sharpening BU Blades

#1

Hybrid Profile for Freehand Sharpening BU Blades

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

A new article on my website. This one is about freehand sharpening a camber on BU plane blades. Hope you find it useful.

http://www.inthewoodshop.com/WoodworkTechniques/HybridProfileforFreehandSharpeningBUPlaneBlades.html


Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Hybrid Profile for Freehand Sharpening BU Blades

#2

Observation

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

An observation about the contents of this article ...

It strikes me that those who are dedicated freehand sharpeners (essentially to whom this article is aimed) are less likely to use a BU plane, either because they attempted to freehand the 25 degree primary bevel (that the plane comes with) and consequently obtained horrible results (well what do you expect with an included cutting angle of 37 degrees?!), or because they became frustrated at needing a honing guide for a specific, higher secondary bevel.

Then we have the dedicated group of honing guide users who are comfortable with their BU planes because they require the same attention to detail as their BD planes. For this group I anticipate that they are unlikely to appreciate the difficulties with freehand honing and BU plane blades. (This is not a criticism of using a honing guide).

So one group lack experience with BU planes, and the other group are short of experience with freehanding issues. As a result of this, the relevant information in the article is likely to missed by most. It's probably a small group that want to freehand their BU plane blades to a high angle and include a camber at the edge.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Hybrid Profile for Freehand Sharpening BU Blades

#3

Re: Observation

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Very nice article, Derek, thanks. As it turns out I only have one BU plane, the LN BUJ; but I seldom use it for anything but the occasional shooting these days, for which no chamfer is needed (long story short: as I've added specialty planes to replace its functions, I've stopped using it, mostly, I really need to lose sentimentality and sell it).

Now, why did I replace it with BD instead of BU? Primarily because I use high carbon blades, and the BU planes seemed to be A2 for quite a while, several years; so the BU planes took themselves out of contention. And, of course, there aren't any BU Japanese planes with which I'm aware.

I find it interesting that you prefer BU for super woods like jarrah. Do you know why?

Pam

Re: Hybrid Profile for Freehand Sharpening BU Blades

#4

Re: Observation

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

I find it interesting that you prefer BU for super woods like jarrah. Do you know why?

Hi Pam

When smoothing and jointing woods with interlocked grain, a high cutting angle is preferred. The HNT Gordon planes were designed for the Australian market and with a 60 degree bed for a good reason :)

BU planes are easy to set up this way. Added to this, they have a low centre of gravity, which makes them easier to push. The low aspect HNT Gordon planes have a similar feel.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Hybrid Profile for Freehand Sharpening BU Blades

#5

Re: Observation

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Ah, so you're saying that a lower bed angle and higher bevel angle works better for jarrah and the like?

Which HNT's are lower aspect? I've scanned through the available sets and don't see anything that qualifies.

Pam

Re: Hybrid Profile for Freehand Sharpening BU Blades

#6

Re: Observation

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Pam

I use the Smoother and Trying Plane. These planes - compared with Bailey-pattern - place your hand low and you push them about 1-2" above the surface of the wood, about mid point if you use the handle. Blades are 2" wide and short.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Hybrid Profile for Freehand Sharpening BU Blades

#7

Re: Observation

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Yeah, I do, too, plus that wonderful little palm smoother; but I see that we've cleared up a misunderstanding: you meant a low aspect for hand placement. I agree. You also may want to try pulling them.

Pam

Re: Hybrid Profile for Freehand Sharpening BU Blades

#9

Re: Observation

Sgian Dubh

"It strikes me that those who are dedicated freehand sharpeners (essentially to whom this article is aimed) are less likely to use a BU plane..."

I guess I fall into the category of "dedicated freehand sharpener" Derek. Whilst it's true that most of my planing is undertaken with bevel down planes such as jack, try and smoothing planes, I frequently use a block plane, which is a bevel up plane.

I have always sharpened these bevel up plane blades freehand, and without any frustration. Granted, I use a grinding angle of about 25� or thereabouts-- it's hard to know for sure as I work the grinding angle freehand as well, and not the sort of angles you're discussing, about 50�.

Getting a curve on the blade using freehand honing techniques is fairly straightforward I find, ie, sharpen as normal on the stone which means adding extra pressure towards one edge of the blade for a few strokes, followed by adding a bit of pressure on the other edge for an equivalent number of strokes. That seems to do it quite nicely, but I admit I'm not working at the same high angles you are working on, which quite possibly makes it all a bit trickier.

I suppose another old trick is to just use a slightly hollowed out oilstone, which is something that seems to occur quite naturally I've found! There's a joke in that last statement-- all oilstones with evidence of some use seem to be at least slightly hollow, if not actually rutted, ha, ha. Slainte.

Re: Hybrid Profile for Freehand Sharpening BU Blades

#10

Re: Observation

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Richard

I think you covered it all.

Yes, it is fairly straight forward freehanding a thin blade with a low bevel angle (25 degrees), such as a Bailey-pattern plane. And thick blades (3/16") for these same low bevel angles are even easier since there is even more registration area. No one needs to be told how to suck eggs in this department :) Adding a camber to a low bevel angle is par for the course with thick blades, such as found on infill planes and even the 1/4" thick HNT Gordon blades. Working with straight blades (no camber) is easy-peazy, such as small block planes and the 3/16" thick blade on my LA Jack (for use on the shooting board). And not forgetting chisels here as well.

However, freehanding a camber on a thick blade with a high bevel angle (say 50 degrees), as used in a BU smoother, is another matter altogether! That is what this hybrid method is about.

Regards from Perth

Derek