New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

200+ woodworking book reviews

Diamond Paste-scratch pattern

Posts

Diamond Paste-scratch pattern

#1

Diamond Paste-scratch pattern

George Symula

My substratum is an older cast iron table saw that I flattened and kept whole. I felt by not cutting it into smaller pieces i didn't have to worry about releasing forces and potential warping. In addition, if it works out I have a complete sharpening station with potentially six sharpening areas on a single element.

I've just finished sharpening my small stable of chisels, (all vintage, Stanley, Buck, Witherby, etc.) and I have a question regarding my results. I did not hollow grind. I did not use a jig of any sort and I did start with good flat and even bevels. My sharpening regimen consisted of working backs and bevels through paste grits of 600, 14000 and 50000. My results were pretty good, ( I had no problem trimming pine or maple end grain) but I could not get to a mirror finish that I achieved using scary sharp. The 50000g station yielded an ok edge but fine scratches were clearly visible with the naked eye. I did not count my strokes but I used many more than on my 2000g wet/dry sandpaper. I did work to a wire edge through all grits. My intent is to use this "workstation" to provide a quick and always ready means to sharpening as I'm working.

I guess my questions are, 1) do diamond give a different scratch pattern than sandpaper, 2) How do visible scratches affect durability, 3) what is the polishing characteristic of 2000g sandpaper versus 50000g diamond 4) are my goals unrealistic?

Re: Diamond Paste-scratch pattern

#2

Re: Diamond Paste-scratch pattern

Bill Tindall

I guess my questions are, 1) do diamond give a different scratch pattern than sandpaper......yes, because it is harder it penetrates more, and easier

2) How do visible scratches affect durability,....depends on magnitude of the scratch. I do think that we don't know if a bight mirror finish is sharper or more durable than the more matt finish one gets from 1 micron diamond on cast iron.

3) what is the polishing characteristic of 2000g sandpaper versus 50000g diamond...I don't know. If you are using silicon carbide paper these particles are readily crushed by tool steel so the actual grit size is less than what you start with.

4) are my goals unrealistic?....I think diamond particles will embed in the tool and carry over to the next plate. This problem is discussed in an old machinist manual I have(abrading tool steel with diamond is hardly a new idea, it has just gotten more practical because the price of diamonds is much less) . I made an attempt to confirm this suspicion but I was unable to interpret the microscope images of the cast iron surface. I will try again soon.

Re: Diamond Paste-scratch pattern

#3

Re: Diamond Paste-scratch pattern

TomD

"I guess my questions are, 1) do diamond give a different scratch pattern than sandpaper......yes, because it is harder it penetrates more, and easier"

Do we know that? A plastic fork penetrates jello just as well as a stainless one. If diamond had a better geometry, sharper so to speak. Could retain that particle shape due to it's hardness, that would help. Distribution might make a difference. If you have twice the points it should be harder to get them to penetrate with the same pressure, unless the threshold is very low. One could argue that fine particles create a finer surface just because of that, not due to particle size. I think it is real hard to know what is actually happening.

Re: Diamond Paste-scratch pattern

#4

Re: Diamond Paste-scratch pattern

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

My substratum is an older cast iron table saw that I flattened and kept whole. I felt by not cutting it into smaller pieces i didn't have to worry about releasing forces and potential warping. In addition, if it works out I have a complete sharpening station with potentially six sharpening areas on a single element.

Hi George

I would cut up the tablesaw into several plates, leave them to do their twisty thing, then flatten each if necessary.

At some time in the future all substratums will show wear and need to be flattened. It may be negligble for a couple of years, but eventually .. You may find flattening a tad difficult with a single plate the size of a tablesaw!

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Diamond Paste-scratch pattern

#5

Re: Diamond Paste-scratch pattern

George Symula

Bill, I do use sc paper and like diamond, scratches are visible in the direction of stroke but significantly fewer and shallower. However, waterstones that I have used leave a matte finish that appear to scratch in multiple directions. I have no idea what any of this means. Just an aside, I often hone, (very lightly) on the back of a sheet of 2000g Norton wet/dry paper. It provides a very fine finish.

Derek, thanks for the reply but after spending a few hours flattening I really don't relish more should each blank twist/warp.

I guess, for me at least, diamond sharpening/honing will remain a mystery. My next effort in this direction will be toward a different substrate like maple, corian or whatever.

George

Re: Diamond Paste-scratch pattern

#6

Re: Diamond Paste-scratch pattern

Ron Hock

I used silicon carbide wet-or-dry paper for years for sharpening until I tried honing films (lapping films). They use finely graded, very uniform aluminum oxide grains glued to a tough Mylar backing. They last FAR longer than SC papers, both in the way they cut and the integrity of the sheet. I haven't used any SC paper since I tried the honing film and I'm not going back. Honing films may cost a bit more but are completely worth the (small) extra cost. Readily available wherever fine tools are sold (mostly) -- HIGHLY recommended.