New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Want Better Milling & Firewood Knowledge?

English slip question

Posts

English slip question

#1

English slip question

Bill Tindall

I had occasion to be in Shelbyville, Ky this past few days. There is a gallery there that specializes in high end English furniture, antique and reproduction. The staff was accommodating for this visit and I was invited to explore any piece I wished. I looked into a lot of drawers and felt the inside of a lot of French Feet (I have a foot fetish) to determine the bracing strategy. I also explored hardware placement and bow front construction. Nothing beats an accommodating gallery for answering construction questions.

Except for a very old bun footed oak piece with the highest angle dovetails I have ever seen, and one modern new piece with machine cut dovetails, the rest were the usual tiny affairs cut into quartered white oak. And every drawer in the place had slips. A few were as I expected with the drawer bottom dadoed into the slip attached to the drawer side and a quarter round of the slip showing inside the drawer. Some of the drawer sides were as little as 1/4" even on a 36" wide drawer.

However, in most all cases the slip was a strip of material fastened to the drawer side under the drawer bottom, with the drawer bottom slightly dadoed (1/8")into the drawer side so as to just capture the drawer bottom in the drawer side, and some greater part of the drawer bottom resting on the top slip surface.

My question involves how this construction is accomplished. The goal must be to have the top surface of the slip even with the dado and the bottom of the slip even with the drawer bottom. It is not at all clear by what process these two goals are met. I suppose one could insert a glue repelant filler strip into the drawer side dado and then glue on the slip. After the glue sets plane the slip to be even with the drawer bottom. But I suspect a more productive way is employed that I have not considered.

I have two more chests of drawers in my mind and these things are all about drawers.

Re: English slip question

#2

Re: English slip question

Phil Smith

You could glue the slip on first even with the draw bottom and then use the slip as a fence for a dado plane.

The English liked their dado planes in variety of widths.

Re: English slip question

#3

Re: English slip question

TomD

What you describe would not seem to preclude gluing the slip on, and then running the dado adjascent to it with a plane. In the modern world you could glue it on, then run it past a fly cutter, on a router table, with support provided by a slip attached to the fence. At 90 degrees the same thing could be done with a table saw, though it would not be as easy in my shop, or as easy to stop, if required. Or any of a million other methods.

That method is still somewhat cheap, at least for heavier drawers. In some cases a larger piece is attached, that fully wraps the bottom of the side, and that the drawer bottom is supported in. It can also be offset to provide a looser fit to the drawer side, which is desireable in some situations.

Re: English slip question

#4

Re: English slip question

Ian (in Sydney, Australia)

The way I was taught is you glue the slip onto the drawer side AFTER you dovetail and assemble the drawer.

The glue can be reinforced with brads, but for a 1/4" drawer side this would be difficult.

When I made my drawers, I used a piece of ply of the right thickness to position the slip relative to the groove in the drawer front and the drawer back -- the glue area is well away from the groove so there is no need for a release agent on the ply

The slips I used were oversized and were planned down to match the drawer sides after the glue set, with teh final twaeking being part of the drawer fitting. I used a #5, but a scrub plane along the grain would be faster.

The other "trick" I was shown was to glue up the drawer and then put it in the carcass while the glue dried, ensuring the drawer -- even if slightly off square -- fitted its opening.

Re: English slip question

#5

Re: English slip question 

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Bill

Richard Jones has written great info on this subject. Here is one of the photos I found helpful:


Essentially, the front is grooved, and the slips utilise a tenon into the groove for strength.


Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: English slip question

#6

Re: English slip question

Adam Cherubini

Hi Bill,

First, I'm confused by the term "dado". Not trying to be obtuse but my theory is that guys who work with machines call every feature THEY cut with a dado stack a dado. Dado has a specific meaning to me. Please describe the features you are talking about. I think you mean groove, but you could be talking about rabbets. By my definition a dado is a groove cross grain. Grooves have three sides. Rabbets have 2.

I suspect what you saw were nailed up bottoms with slips or fillers glued on to cover the nail heads. You and I have been talking about this construction for years so I know you know about it. Is that what you saw?

Folks in the 18th c probably didn't know or care if their drawer bottoms, restrained on 4 sides, split or cracked. Many lined their drawers with paper to protect the textiles they usually stored in chests of drawers. But restraints on all sides doesn't guarantee a crack. Many drawer bottoms were made of of quartered stuff. I recently saw some early 18th c English chests where the bottoms were uncracked oak. Ditto, I've seen good philly pieces in the PMoA with uncracked white cedar bottoms.

I find this deal (no pun intended) with trying to protect the drawer bottoms kinda backwards. Screw the bottoms, we want to protect the drawer divider at the front of the case. I think that's why they wanted nice wide runners and slips. I'm not sure why folks moved away from that. It may well be because they substituted commercially flat sawn boards for the previously riven quaterted stuff. The flat sawn boards would have cupped and split. So the mini furiture factories of the 19th c started redesigning drawers to "improve" them because they were too stupid to recognize that the superior earlier designs were predicated on materials their new machines couldn't produce.

Moral of the story: Machines are evil! Okay okay. Rereading this was a little much but I'm leaving it in so you can laugh at me. Guess I'm in a rebellious mood. Happy 4th of July everybody!

Adam

Re: English slip question

#7

Re: English slip question

TomD

I looked it up before I responded, because for me it is a longi vs cross grain, but I couldn't get a definition in a few times trying that really made that point. Pretty much all the definition, including in FWW were for different parts of the joint. The problem with words is that if they stop having an agreed meaning it becomes pretty pointless. With all respect to a truly serious problem, I do at times wonder whether the various wars would go better if every time something went "bang" the people involved didn't seem to feel required to say. "... An improvized explosive device, or I. E. D. ..." If after 10 years nobody feels able to just say IED, what is the point? What happened to "bomb". I think they even refer to stuff that is actually not improvized, and certainly stuff that nobody really knows whether it was improvized or not, as "... An improvized explosive device, or I. E. D. ..."

Re: English slip question

#8

But.....

Bill Tindall

this construction was rare in the 100 or so drawers I investigated spanning, according to the tags, late 1700's to current reproduction. More common was the less complicated slip I described in the question.

The construction illustrated by Richard doesn't weaken an already frail drawer by dadoing into the thin side. I like that. But, this complicated alternative involves making a complicated slip rather than a simple strip of wood attached to the drawer bottom.

Re: English slip question

#9

Groove

Bill Tindall

and I suppose it would have been planed into the drawer side with a "grooving plane"?

Re: English slip question

#10

THANK YOU

Bill Tindall

I was hoping someone familiar with the trade practices would respond for it was how this assembly was made in the factory shops that I was searching for.

This style of drawer construction makes such good sense I wonder why it never made it across the Atlantic ocean. Is it common in AU and/or NZ? India?

Re: English slip question

#11

PS

Bill Tindall

change dado to groove and reread the post. Even with my handicapped communication skills it should be clear that I am not discussing the drawer construction you described.

I have seen the construction you describe in this gallery's furniture but not on this trip.

Re: English slip question

#12

The response from Allan Batty

Bill Tindall

For those that are unfamiliar with Allan, he worked in the English trades, eventually became the mentor for apprentices, and then ran his own shop turning furniture and architecture parts. Most recently he teaches turning classes around the world. I met him at a class. He is an entertaining teacher and that is a considerable understatement. I think he was having furniture parts withdrawal when I took the class for I asked a spindle question and the rest of the class became a tutorial on the elements of spindle turning, to the dismay of the bowl folks. I never learned so much in so short a time. In this class he mentioned once working for a furniture factory making drawers. He also spoke of the factory log yard with mahogany logs taller than he was. I was able to track him down with the aid of the Turning Forum and I asked him about how drawers were made in the factory he worked. His response may be an interesting insight to the practice of his day:

Hi Bill,

You have transported me back years, I am going on memory here, I will try to answer your questions in order

[1] we always cut one side at a time, to my knowledge no one ever sawed as a pair, this was in case of error

[2], we always cut the pins first and marked the dove tails off the pins, the pins varied as to the century, in the regency period for example I believe the pins were very slender, I have seen every combination over the years from cogged dovetails [I thought these were hansome] to were the pin and dovetail were of almost equal size. just a point of interest when we cut the dovetails we made the dovetails slightly thicker on the outside,[[this was only a slight taper hardly perceptable.] when you tapped dovetails together they tightened up without splitting.As I say we always cut the pins first, I have heard auguments for the opersite, just a point all tradesmen I know always worked, cutting the pins first.

[3] I do not understand what you mean by slips, on the bottom of the drawer we put a wearing piece, which ran on the runner for the drawer it ran the full lenght of drawer at on 2 sides, this was only a rubbed glue joint fixing in place, this wearing piece was tenon sawed all most thro but no quite, it was cut every 21/2 to 3 inches at approximately at a 30 degree angle, it was important the saw cut did NOT go all the way through, I was given to understand by doing this the wear was less, never did understand how this was supposed to wear better, but we always did it anyway

[4] The bottom of the drawer was a 1/4 to 5/16th thick, made in planks depending on the tradesman 4"to 7" wide and edges were rubbed glue joints until final width was achieved, this then fitted into a slot that was cut around the drawer, the slot was worked out so as to fall on a dovetail not a pin, as it would weaken a pin

[5] 6 sets a day were required. [ the expectation was to produce 6 drawers per day, Bill]

Re: English slip question

#13

Re: But.....

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I thought of a method you might like, Bill. Cut the drawer slip oversize so that it overlaps the area where you are going to plough the groove. Then glue it to the drawer side. When it is dry, flush the bottom of the slip with the bottom of the drawer side, then plough the groove right through the edge of the slip and into the drawer side. That way the top of the slip is nicely aligned with the groove, actually a part of the same groove.

Re: English slip question

#14

English slips 

Ian (in Sydney, Australia)

some pictures taken tonight of the slips in my drawers

(if you're into English comedy, that will bring a smile to your dial ...)

This drawer is either the 2nd or third I've made, the drawer front is New Guinea Rosewood (Pterocarpus indicus), I'm not sure what the sides, back, bottom and slips are, possibly Silver Ash (Flindersia spp) or an East Asian rain forest hardwood.

but to the photos

the slips are glued on over depth and flushed even with the sides once the glue has dried

the drawer front corner - drawer slip join -- you can see how the groove in the drawer front extends past the slip


back of drawer -- you can see how the slip extends past the drawer back to the end of the side (these drawer sides are 10mm thick (a smidge over 3/8")


drawer 3/4 view shows how the bottom pin on the drawer back is straight to align with the top of the drawer bottom


inside front corner -- shows how the slip marries with sides and drawer front


the groove in the slip is cut before the slip is attached to the drawer

the style of slip varies -- these drawers have a 1/4 round upper profile which would normally be found in a drawe intended for linen. This drawer is for a desk so should have flat topped slips.

In my limited experience, very top quality work would use narrow drawer sides and slips, less expensive work would use a thicker drawer side say 1/2" to 5/8" and grooves to capture a plywood bottom

Re: English slip question

#15

Or plow/plough plane

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Re: English slip question

#16

Re: But.....

Ian (in Sydney, Australia)

Bill, you commented this complicated alternative involves making a complicated slip rather than a simple strip of wood attached to the drawer bottom

It's not so complicated, a drawer slip is really a simple strip of wood with a groove down one side which is cut to length and glued to the inside of the drawer.

Derek's sketch shows a stub tenon about 3/16" long (= the depth of the groove in the front drawer) used to align the slip to the drawer front. On reflection this method would be as fast or faster than the spacer method I adopted. In straight grained stuff, stub tenons can be created easily with two saw cuts (to establish the shoulders), followed by two taps with a chisel to cleave down the grain and create the tenon. For production work, you might even set up a vertical blade on the bench for the cleaving rather than use a chisel.

Re: English slip question

#17

Re: The response from Allan Batty

James Watriss

Interesting response.

The notching the wear strip makes sense to me: the notches provide a place for dust/ finish crumbles/ other detritus to collect, rather than have this particulate junk roll or scrape back and forth under the weight of the drawer, and doing so much damage. I'll have to think about this...

Re: 'complicated construction' with slips, earlier on in the conversation...

I've taken it into my mind recently to just make a pile of drawer slips, to keep around as shop supplies. I see them as something that makes more sense when made in bulk, to be trimmed to fit when putting drawers together. I could see how making slips individually as more drawer parts would feel more involved. I'm picturing something akin to a stock molding profile that you can cut long, glue/ tack in, and trim to fit. I don't know that it's easier or not than the sort of work you're describing though.

Re: English slip question

#18

Now there is a good idea

Bill Tindall

I like the idea of settling in an making 100' of slip (for example) so that when it was needed it would be at hand. One could even accumulate cut-offs over time and turn them into slips when there were enough to make an efficient run of them

Re: English slip question

#19

PS

Bill Tindall

Imagine how experienced one needed to be to crank out 6 drawers per day.