Taper grinding a dovetail saw - a grand failure
Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)
I've had this on my mind for about a year, ever since I removed the set from a LN dovetail saw and used it sans set. I had filed off a little to reduce the rough kerf .. and just couldn't get the saw to cut in a straight line no matter how much I tweeked the remaining set. So I filed it all all .. and the saw cut straight as a die, and cleanly as one could wish. However ... there is always a "however" ... the saw was hard to push. It would bind in the kerf (are we surprised?). This was easily fixed with a little wax to lubricate the steel, which is how I used it. What I find so appealing about this saw is that it will create a kerf just where the saw is placed .. you do not also have to account for the extra amount of wood removed by the set.
So I began to wonder about a dovetail saw that did not need any set. In other words a saw plate that was taper ground to avoid binding. A few months ago I read about Mike Wenzloff producing a tenon saw that was taper ground. Chris Schwarz was raving about it. Still, I have not read about a dovetail saw created this way.
The problem is that I am not a sawmaker. I have made a few saws, but that does not qualify me. Making a handle is the easy part. I can do a reasonable job of filing teeth (although you wouldn't believe this when you see the teeth that I filed in the saw to come!). The tough part is preparing a saw plate that is tapered. I do not have machining equipment. All I have is a beltsander!
Now I must warn all in advance that this was a failure. It was an experiment. I am hoping that we get some discussion going with the aim of improving the method. There is enough success here to see the benefits that may be gained.
First some "before" pictures. The Guinea Pig was a Crown Gent Saw with an 8" long plate that was filed 18 tpi rip. I have had this saw about 10 years. It has not been used in half a dozen, but the teeth were reasonable. So I sawed these lines in 3/4" thick Tasmanian Oak ...

I sliced off a section at the end to reveal the kerf ..

Next I carefully flattened the teeth with a gennou. Carefully tapped them down on the sawtable...

And then cut some more lines in the Tassie Oak ..


The kerfs are noticeably straighter and the kerf face is a little smoother.
The next stage was to taper grind the saw plate. What I did was to tape up a 1/4" from the teeth, then use my belt sander to grind back the steel for about 2". The belts I had are Zirconion Oxide in 120 grit and then 3M trizact belts to 600 grit. The plates were painted blue to monitor the grinding, cooled with a wet sponge if they became warm, and checked for thickness as we proceeded.

In the first picture (left) if the original thickness. On the right I am checking for progress - .001� is barely a start ..

I ended up with a taper of .005� that started �� in from the teeth.
Promise not to wince at the teeth (I did warn you). I did them fast. There is a 10 degree rake. 18 tpi is hard on the eyes ...

But they worked. Jointed, sharpened .. they cut well ..
At first it was a struggle. I thought that the wood was too thick. I resawed it to 3/8", which would be more typical for a saw with this configuration.
It cut really straight and with so much control that I was taking slices 1mm and under ...

And the kerf was as smooth as a baby's watsit .. at least as good as a tablesaw with it high toothed blade ...

I sawed a practice dovetail. The kerf was like from a japanese dozuki ..

At the end of time I had to say it was a failure - the saw just did not cut smoothly. It felt like it was binding on the 1/4" around the tooth area. The effort started immediately and did not increase or decrease as the blade bit deeper. I will have to find a way to taper grind to the end of the plate.
Any ideas? Comments?
Regards from Perth
Derek








