New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Fast and affordable laser cutting – so you can make the parts you can’t find anywhere else

Ask two woodworkers...

Posts

Ask two woodworkers...

#1

Stephen Shepherd

Ask two woodworkers...

Stephen Shepherd

how they feel about a particular chisel or plane blade, and you will get three opinions.

Stephen

Re: Ask two woodworkers...

#2

Re: Ask two woodworkers...

wilbur

Only three? ;)

Re: Ask two woodworkers...

#3

Moses Yoder

Re: Ask two woodworkers...

Moses Yoder

And if you do it on a web forum, it is likely to start an argument about screwdrivers.

Re: Ask two woodworkers...

#4

Re: Ask two woodworkers...

TomD

The web is proof that nobody agrees with anyone about anything, except as required to make the point that nobody agrees about anything, including that. In other settings one gets the impression that there is occasional agreement, but the web sets it straight. It is somewhat liberating really.

Re: Ask two woodworkers...

#5

Re: Ask two woodworkers... *LINK*

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Just read "Reason Seen More as Weapon Than Path to Truth" in the NYTimes last week.

Pam


Reason Seen More as Weapon

Re: Ask two woodworkers...

#6

Re: Ask two woodworkers...

TomD

I guess that explains a lot of NYT content, :)

Not really what I was thinking. My thought is people really don't agree. If everyone wants to go to a theatre to see a movie there has to be some compromise if they are to all arrive in the same theatre, not to mention the same row. That doesn't mean they all felt the same about it. The internet is a place where we are all sitting in a different row, literally, to start with, and it gets closer to being a place where nobody has to agree. To my way of thinking the rational let me win thing is less pointfull on the internet since nobody really has to let you win, it is probably not going to happen.

I am tempted to say only the French could have missed the memo about the role of rationality in argument... My collection of French philosophy only goes up to about 1984, but I a pretty sure it is all a lot more complicated...

Re: Ask two woodworkers...

#7

Re: Ask two woodworkers...

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

I don't agree with the article in toto, but do see a lot of evidence for it in society in general and occasionally, very occasionally, in woodworking forums. Why are you (impersonal) really going to the trouble to make a rational argument? Often it's to explain something difficult to others, but often it's to convince that your way is right and the other's is wrong, and here's why.

Pam

Re: Ask two woodworkers...

#8

Re: Ask two woodworkers...

Frank D. in Montreal

That article was quite weak, a lot of contradictions and undefined concepts. The author made no difference between what's rational and reasonable. Actually French deconstruction (Derrida, Lyotard, Levinas) has been affirming the same main point about rationality and rhetoric (argument) since the sixties. Even the Ancient Greeks recognized this possible function of rational argument, thus sophistry became pejorative, although some were naive enough to believe in a pure reason that could exclude sophisms. They weren't totally wrong. And as to survival and evolution, false argument is an obvious defense mechanism that can help an individual to defend itself, like a poo cloud or a bad taste helps against a predator on the attack. The attacker does not necessarily have the upper hand in evolution, even though it seems better equipped (ask a jellyfish, who is on its way to ruling the world). These are just a few nuances that the article did not address.

Re: Ask two woodworkers...

#9

Re: Ask two woodworkers...

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Well, the author is a journalist, not a philosopher; and she did point out that there's much disagreement about this. I think the most rational thing a woodworker wields is a chisel.

Pam

Re: Ask two woodworkers...

#10

Re: Ask two woodworkers...

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

I guess that explains why you say that about the NYT :)

DC

Re: Ask two woodworkers...

#11

Re: Ask two woodworkers...

Frank D. in Montreal

True enough; I expect a little more from the NYT though.

I vote for the mallet, good for driving a point home.

Re: Ask two woodworkers...

#12

Re: Ask two woodworkers...

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

I think the NYTimes (and PBS, too, for that matter), outside of the opinion pages, see their mission as one of informing about issues; and they expect their readers to pursue an issue elsewhere if interested. After all, if they'd had a philosopher write that article, there'd more likely have been much more bias.

Pam