New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

200+ woodworking book reviews

On testing a titaniun nitride coated plane iron

Posts

On testing a titaniun nitride coated plane iron

#1

On testing a titaniun nitride coated plane iron

Bill Tindall

I have in hand a fully coated TiN plane iron for a Stanley #4 or 5. What testing would you like to see done on it to determine efficacy of the coating?

I can say right now that the iron is a thing of beauty. Lovely translucent gold color. If it doesn't cost much to coat and the coating provides any discernible benefit it would seem to be a at least a marketing success for eye appeal.

After discussions with Steve Elliot a bevel down plane may not be the best application of the coating for the primary wear of a plane iron is on the wood side of the blade and that side won't be coated after the first sharpening. Cutters such as those used in CNC routers are often TiN coated and here the tool is most like a bevel up plane iron, with the coating on the wood side of the cutting edge.

I will at least get pictures before and after sharpening to see what becomes of the coating at the edge.

Re: On testing a titaniun nitride coated plane iron

#2

Stephen Shepherd

Re: On testing a titaniun nitride coated plane iro

Stephen Shepherd

What does it look like, and how does that work, after you hone and strop?

Stephen

Re: On testing a titaniun nitride coated plane iron

#3

Low Angle Jack Plane?

Steve Elliott

Would the blade fit into a plane like the Lie-Nielsen low angle jack? I've never used one but I believe it takes a 2" blade.

Re: On testing a titaniun nitride coated plane iron

#4

Re: On testing a titaniun nitride coated plane iro

Bill Tindall

You asked, "What does it look like?

It is an iron for a Stanley 4 or 5. I don't understand the question.

After it is sharpened it will have a TiN coated back and a sharpened bevel, just like a sharpened TiN coated CNC router bit. As stated, it is less certain how the coating will perform in this orientation. More ideal for evaluation would be a coated blade for a bevel up plane.

Re: On testing a titaniun nitride coated plane iron

#5

Re: Low Angle Jack Plane?

Bill Tindall

I have a friend that has just this plane. I'll ask him. Or, other..... does a No5 iron fit this plane?

Re: On testing a titaniun nitride coated plane iron

#6

Re: Low Angle Jack Plane?

Frank D. in Montreal

It could fit if you take off the depth adjuster, or if the slot on the blade allows the depth adjuster to pass through it. The LA jack blade is a lot shorter than a standard blade and it has a slot for the depth adjuster wheel, so if the wheel doesn't interfere with the blade and it isn't too long (stabs you fingers on the rear handle) you'd be good to go.

Re: On testing a titaniun nitride coated plane iron

#7

Tried it, doesn't fit

Frank D. in Montreal

Blade's too long and the blade's slot doesn't go close enough to the mouth for the lever cap screw to pass through.

Re: On testing a titaniun nitride coated plane iron

#8

Re: On testing a titaniun nitride coated plane iro

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Bill

As we know, the bevel is worn on both sides when planing. However it more detrimental when on the back of the blade when used on a BU plane. The effects on performance will be more marked there - however the amount of back wear, per se, should still be validly measured by a BD plane (they are just not as intrusive).

You are not going to get a Stanley-type plane blade to fit any BU plane ... unless you build one. This may be easier than you think. In fact I reckon it should take you under 1 hour if you just build a wooden chisel plane: 20 degree bed made out of a piece of hardwood. Screw down the blade with a washer. And you could be good to go ... or build one like I did ..


Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: On testing a titaniun nitride coated plane iron

#9

thanks for the test

Bill Tindall

Re: On testing a titaniun nitride coated plane iron

#10

Moses Yoder

Re: On testing a titaniun nitride coated plane iro

Moses Yoder

I would like to see a hard maple board about 5/4 thick, 18" long, clamped in a vice with the edge up. Now set the plane to take shavings about .0015" - .002" thick, and see how many full length and width shavings you get until the shavings are so mangled from a dull iron that they don't look nice any more. Then do the same thing with a standard Hock iron, and see which cuts the most shavings.

Re: On testing a titaniun nitride coated plane iron

#11

Re: On testing a titaniun nitride coated plane iro

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Bill

Working with the principle that the edge is only as sharp as the coarser sideof the bevel, what is the micron rating of the TiN side? I also assume it was surface ground, then polished before the TiN coating was added?

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: On testing a titaniun nitride coated plane iron

#12

I can do that test

Bill Tindall

I am looking for a big improvement, or not. If the TiN coating extends life 25% it will be had to determine and harder still to sell at a premium(but it does look pretty). If the coating doesn't result in a 100% improvement I would consider it a failure.

Re: On testing a titaniun nitride coated plane iron

#13

Moses Yoder

Re: Polishing the back

Moses Yoder

Are you going to polish the back of the iron? If so, will this take the coating off? Seemes like if it was me I would grind and hone the bevel, then use the ruler trick to do a light polishing on the back so you are just honing the tip and not the whole back . Seems like this would conserve the coating while still providing a sharp iron.

Re: On testing a titaniun nitride coated plane iron

#14

Re: Polishing the back

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

If the coating would be removed by flattening/polishing the back, it would also be removed at the cutting edge by a partial flattening/polishing. Particularly if it's needed because of a raised burr. So while it may be prudent and amusing to save the remainder of the blade back, it doesn't do anything to save the cutting edge.

Pam

Re: On testing a titaniun nitride coated plane iron

#15

I don't find it essential to.......

Bill Tindall

do anything to the back of blades during sharpening. The diamond abrasive sequence I use grinds the initial burr away. I have seen it get ever thinner and then float away across the cast iron plate.

Someone argued that even at 1 micron abrasive a tiny burr remains. That is probably so but it isn't a burr under my saddle for the kind of planing I do. Such a burr would be frail and easily break off on the first stroke, no doubt leaving behind an edge somewhat less sharp than the ultimate edge obtainable. But given what an edge looks like when I give up and resharpen it is apparent that for my practical planing an edge of ultimate sharpness is not essential nor worth the effort to get it....... unless it leads to significantly longer edge life. If the TiN coated blade provides the same benefit as 50 strokes on a horses butt in sharpness longevity I'll forgo the horses butt.

Editorial: what is helpful when doing research are ideas for how to perform the experiments and what experiments to perform.

I hope some day that we have data that answers the question of whether an edge of ultimate refinement is significantly different from an initially "simply sharp" edge after each has planned 200'. If the sharpness of the ultimate edge rapidly converges with the "simply sharp" edge this ultimate edge if of no practical value in cases where a plane is used to simply remove material. I realize that some of you plane to achieve a particular surface quality but the rest of the world uses sandpaper before the finish goes on.

Re: On testing a titaniun nitride coated plane iron

#16

Re:on removing TiN coating......

George in mosquito filled Lowell, Mich.

My experience when asked to do any machining or grinding to a "coated" surface is "It's a hard row to hoe". As it was low techly explained to me the coating is like putting a microscopic layer of grinding wheel material on the steel that you are coating. You basically have to take a deep "cut" under the coating to remove it. You don't just grind it off. This coating should give a big improvement to the life of the plane blade compared to an identical uncoated blade

I once case hardened some low carbon steel to make a very narrow chisel. I used some 1/8" key stock as the steel. My feeling was that even when I sharpened it the chisel would behave like I had laminated a .050-.060" thick hard piece of steel to the back of the chisel body. It has performed well. I haven't chopped any dovetails with it though. It is more of a paring chisel.

Can't wait to hear the results of a test!!!!!

Work safe,

George

Re: On testing a titaniun nitride coated plane iron

#17

Moses Yoder

Re: I don't find it essential to.......

Moses Yoder

If the back is not flat and smooth, like mirror smooth, then your edge is not flat and smooth. It can't be. A sharp edge is the result of two flat smooth planes meeting. This is one of the basic premises of sharpening. To say otherwise would go against the grain of what a lot of sharpening gurus have written, such as Leonard Lee. Just wondering.

Re: On testing a titaniun nitride coated plane iron

#18

clarification

Bill Tindall

note I said "during sharpening". I regard back flattening/polishing as something one does once, when the blade is first purchased, or in this case before coating.

I will know more when I get into the experiment but diddling with the back of a coated blade during re-sharpening may be irrelevant to this case. It is most likely that no burr will, or can, form on the coated blade. I will have photomicrographs to answer the question when the time comes for that part of the experiment. (I got the good news yesterday that the lab has recently purchased an objective lens designed for imaging metal surfaces so I am anxious to see if getting good pictures is easier than before.) But to speculate, the back of the bevel will be supported by an exceptionally hard (much harder than carbide) layer of TiN. This backing may prevent any burr from the malleable steel from rolling over to form a burr. The cutting edge, at least initially, will be TiN. I am unsure what the cutting edge may look like after some wear. The coating company claimed a self sharpening effect, much like a beaver's front teeth, but this effect may only occur with bevel up condiguration.

Re: On testing a titaniun nitride coated plane iron

#19

Re: clarification

TomD

I sharpen both sides of the edge every time I sharpen. It isn't necesary to do so, but it is a best practices kind of thing, and one of the advantages of Japanese blades, and other approaches. What you say about burr formation and other maters is interesting though. Look forward to the result.