Re: ATTN David Weaver: durability testing?
David Weaver
I got two irons, i won't say which brands.
But, i sharpened them exactly as charlesworth sharpens in his videos, except no camber. On a shapton 15k, examined them with a loupe to make sure they started out the same.
And then I set up a LN 4 1/2 to take 2 thousandth thickness on a hard maple board 1 inch wide and counted strokes. I stopped periodically to rest my arthritic feeling fingers, and to check shaving thickness with calipers and advance the irons to keep them around 2 thousandths.
I did it twice, because one of the irons chipped out badly as new, and I figured that grinding some of the iron off, maybe an eighth or so (can't find my notes), I would get a better representation.
So, I did that, and then i started counting strokes again. Any time the plane felt dull, I applied paraffin. And until they had almost stopped cutting, I noticed that a lot of the times when I'm working on something, I would've stopped and sharpened the plane, but paraffin made the plane easy to push again, even as the resulting surface got worse and worse.
I noted when each iron chipped out, and when I would've stopped to sharpen a smoother in general work just because the lines from the chipout were too much for me to tolerate.
One iron went 770 or something strokes on a hard maple edge about 20 inches long, and the other was still cutting at 1050 or 1100 (again, lost my notes), but the surface was something otherworldy - on hard maple, it was hairy sort of like suede. I thought that second iron was going to give up the ghost somewhere around 600 or 700, but it kept going. The surface it left was so bad, but maybe it would've cut a little longer past 1100 - it was just getting too difficult to use even though it was still cutting.
I think a test like that is a lot more useful than getting a piece of cocobolo and bashing a chisel into the side grain, or getting a plane and planing a concrete block. I say that, because I notice that HSS will last much much longer in cocobolo on my planes than does A2, but with less difficult woods, I don't get nearly the difference in ratio.
Abuse tests may or may not identify which is better in normal use, but I think they tend to overstate difference in performance under regular use.
So where joel mentioned that an edge will feel sharper, even off a 10 chosera, I wonder what would happen if you did a stroke test like that in maple. I can't see improvement in finishes beyond a shapton 15k, and while people who sell the 30k stone tout the increase in durability, I wonder just how much there really is. I'd like to see someone else do the test.
Given my background, I'd really like to see a sample set of a few thousand tests
I don't think that's going to happen.
It'd be great if someone even did 5 tests per method, maybe call it off at 3 if the results are almost identical for each of the first three, in nominal strokes and difference in strop or no strop.
Initial sharpness above and beyond what you'll get off a cho-10K is nice to know, but if the difference is 50 strokes on 1100, i'm not inclined to do it unless somehow 200 more of those 1100 strokes leave an acceptable smoother finish.
(when I was looking at the two irons I was comparing, I think those were my two noted items - count of strokes when finish was no longer acceptable for final smoothing (i.e., when i'd sharpen a plane that was still cutting) and count when the iron stopped cutting).
I have done less controlled comparisons of other irons (I think the only one i've never gotten my dirty fingers on is a RI D2 iron), and to my knowledge, there is more variation within brands of A2 irons than there is between brands, regardless of the specs touted. The biggest determinant of how good an iron will be is whether or not it lets go of its carbides too easily. If it does, it will dull earlier and leave an unacceptable finish much earlier.
I did notice, though, in comparing a hock A2 to a Hock HCS iron in cherry that for everything other than final smoothing, the A2 lasts significantly longer. But the odd thing about it is I never really noticed the difference until I specifically measured how much work was done by my fore plane before it stopped cutting. A good A2 iron (one that doesn't chip out at all) will outlast high carbon smoothing, too. A bad one (one that releases a bunch of carbides) won't.