New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

If you sell to woodworkers, your customers are already here

ATTN David Weaver: durability testing?

Posts

ATTN David Weaver: durability testing?

#1

ATTN David Weaver: durability testing?

wilbur

"A real durability test, not "planing in MDF" or some such thing. Last time I did one, I ran two irons against each other in hard maple - one went 750 swipes and the other one just short of 1100. It took a LONG time."

Hi Dave,

Can you give any more details on your durability test? What planes/irons, how you sharpened them, etc.?

I meant to ask you when you first posted this, but it got past me, and work has been cah-ray-zee recently.

Re: ATTN David Weaver: durability testing?

#2

Re: ATTN David Weaver: durability testing?

David Weaver

I got two irons, i won't say which brands.

But, i sharpened them exactly as charlesworth sharpens in his videos, except no camber. On a shapton 15k, examined them with a loupe to make sure they started out the same.

And then I set up a LN 4 1/2 to take 2 thousandth thickness on a hard maple board 1 inch wide and counted strokes. I stopped periodically to rest my arthritic feeling fingers, and to check shaving thickness with calipers and advance the irons to keep them around 2 thousandths.

I did it twice, because one of the irons chipped out badly as new, and I figured that grinding some of the iron off, maybe an eighth or so (can't find my notes), I would get a better representation.

So, I did that, and then i started counting strokes again. Any time the plane felt dull, I applied paraffin. And until they had almost stopped cutting, I noticed that a lot of the times when I'm working on something, I would've stopped and sharpened the plane, but paraffin made the plane easy to push again, even as the resulting surface got worse and worse.

I noted when each iron chipped out, and when I would've stopped to sharpen a smoother in general work just because the lines from the chipout were too much for me to tolerate.

One iron went 770 or something strokes on a hard maple edge about 20 inches long, and the other was still cutting at 1050 or 1100 (again, lost my notes), but the surface was something otherworldy - on hard maple, it was hairy sort of like suede. I thought that second iron was going to give up the ghost somewhere around 600 or 700, but it kept going. The surface it left was so bad, but maybe it would've cut a little longer past 1100 - it was just getting too difficult to use even though it was still cutting.

I think a test like that is a lot more useful than getting a piece of cocobolo and bashing a chisel into the side grain, or getting a plane and planing a concrete block. I say that, because I notice that HSS will last much much longer in cocobolo on my planes than does A2, but with less difficult woods, I don't get nearly the difference in ratio.

Abuse tests may or may not identify which is better in normal use, but I think they tend to overstate difference in performance under regular use.

So where joel mentioned that an edge will feel sharper, even off a 10 chosera, I wonder what would happen if you did a stroke test like that in maple. I can't see improvement in finishes beyond a shapton 15k, and while people who sell the 30k stone tout the increase in durability, I wonder just how much there really is. I'd like to see someone else do the test.

Given my background, I'd really like to see a sample set of a few thousand tests :\ I don't think that's going to happen.

It'd be great if someone even did 5 tests per method, maybe call it off at 3 if the results are almost identical for each of the first three, in nominal strokes and difference in strop or no strop.

Initial sharpness above and beyond what you'll get off a cho-10K is nice to know, but if the difference is 50 strokes on 1100, i'm not inclined to do it unless somehow 200 more of those 1100 strokes leave an acceptable smoother finish.

(when I was looking at the two irons I was comparing, I think those were my two noted items - count of strokes when finish was no longer acceptable for final smoothing (i.e., when i'd sharpen a plane that was still cutting) and count when the iron stopped cutting).

I have done less controlled comparisons of other irons (I think the only one i've never gotten my dirty fingers on is a RI D2 iron), and to my knowledge, there is more variation within brands of A2 irons than there is between brands, regardless of the specs touted. The biggest determinant of how good an iron will be is whether or not it lets go of its carbides too easily. If it does, it will dull earlier and leave an unacceptable finish much earlier.

I did notice, though, in comparing a hock A2 to a Hock HCS iron in cherry that for everything other than final smoothing, the A2 lasts significantly longer. But the odd thing about it is I never really noticed the difference until I specifically measured how much work was done by my fore plane before it stopped cutting. A good A2 iron (one that doesn't chip out at all) will outlast high carbon smoothing, too. A bad one (one that releases a bunch of carbides) won't.

Re: ATTN David Weaver: durability testing?

#3

You raise THE important question for practical pla

Bill Tindall

For some, the finish the plane leaves is important for they will not be further refining this finish. However, for most, a plane is a means of removing wood shavings and the more the better between sharpenings. For practical planing does the edge last significantly longer if it is sharpened to the nth degree?

To take a recent example, does 50 strokes on leather beyond what ever preceded it provide an additional second of practical planing or a time significantly greater than the time it took to do the 50 strokes? (Or choose some other example with the question of whether the benefit of further edge refinement merits the "cost" in time to achieve it) The answer will be determined by the shape of what I will call the "wear curve", a plot of dullness vs amount of planing. If the ultimate edge is frail and wears rapidly then the wear curve for such an edge is going to soon join the shape of the curve for a less refined edge and there will be no significant increase in edge life. But this may not be the case.

Re: ATTN David Weaver: durability testing?

#4

Re: The chisel test I was referring to

David Weaver

...i think was the one that FWW did, or maybe PWW did.

Just wanted to make sure it was clear that I'm not referring to the chisel test derek did. I thought that was well done and I learned a lot from it.

Re: ATTN David Weaver: durability testing?

#5

practical plan

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Sharpening is part of the fabric of woodworking. It is not something to be avoided. It is an art. It takes sensitivity and experience to know when to sharpen, how much time to spend on each stone, the strop, et cetera. The idea is not to find how many strokes can be gotten from a sharpening, but to do the work in an efficient manner, with the least number of strokes, the least toll on the body, and with the least damage to the edge. We want tools designed for sensitive hands not brutal hands.

When I was a boy I read an article that said that in the 21st century people would just take pills and would not have to bother eating real food. Perhaps some think it an awful waste of time to stop working for drinks and snacks. They would have us work straight through with no lunch, saving nearly an hour a day. Perhaps they could accomplish this by developing horrid breakfast foods, designed to last all day. And special teeth to help eat this nasty food.

Re: ATTN David Weaver: durability testing?

#6

Re: practical plan

David Weaver

Warren, if you dimension by hand, you will already learn/default to doing whatever takes the least number of strokes and is easiest on the body and tool edges.

But that doesn't mean that you should waste time stropping if it doesn't do anything to help. that's what we're trying to figure out - is any part of our sharpening routine a waste of time.

If I get oil stones out and use them, i strop. The edge isn't good enough off of a surgical black for a smoother, at least I don't think it is, even if the surgical black has been allowed to wear and get much finer than a newly dressed stone would be. But I don't think it provides much after a 1 micron ceramic stone, and if it doesn't provide anything, why do it?

I don't think anyone on here is buying disposable plane blades and trying to avoid sharpening, but what is it about planing that deserves such examination to efficiency and effectiveness if sharpening doesn't deserve the same?

Re: ATTN David Weaver: durability testing?

#7

Moses Yoder

Re: practical plan

Moses Yoder

Our life is actually very short. While some people might find it very interesting to investigate sharpening to the n'th degree, I think most people prefer to simply find something that works then use it. In most restaurants I go to, I know what they have that I like. When I go to the Town Fryer in Constantine I order a water, a Falcon Burger, and curly fries with nacho cheese. This is not healthy food but I like it. Why take the risk of ordering something different and then not liking it? Someday I might feel like trying some thing different. I suppose I could set up a test and have 100 people try various things on the menu and rate them, then buy my next meal based on their opinions of the food. But the truth is, none of those people would be me and they don't know what I like. For sharpening, I like using 1000 grit, 4000 grit, and 8000 grit water stones. I have a number of reasons for liking this method, plus it works really good for me. I can't think of a single reason to spend a bunch of time comparing it to other methods to see if they might be better, because I like the method I am using now. SO far as different steels go, 0-1 is my favorite for a number of reasons. People have come out with steels they claim are better, but the actual difference is so slight as to be hardly measurable. When someone comes out with a tool steel that stays sharp for 10 times as long as 0-1 does, I think it might be worth my time to take a look at it. Even then, I would not replace all my 0-1 irons right away because they work just fine for me.

Re: ATTN David Weaver: durability testing?

#8

Re: practical plan

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I think you already know the answer to this, David. If you are sharpening a traditional chisel made in Europe or America, use oil stones and strop. That is what these tools were designed for. Likewise if you are using a traditional Japanese chisel, use water stones and don't strop. Why assume that generations of skilled craftsmen did not know what they were doing? If you are trying for better performance, that is a noble thing, but do not expect results without many years collaboration between sensitive craftsmen and obliging toolmakers and steel makers.

I think stropping would be particularly hard to test. We depend on intuition when stropping and technique is very important, so it would be hard for various people to get identical results. I recently watched six videos of guys stropping razors. They each thought they were good enough that they should be teaching others how to strop. But to someone who has had good training and has stropped a razor for more than 40 years, all but one of these fellows looked rather sorry.

Re: ATTN David Weaver: durability testing?

#9

Re: practical plan

David Weaver

I don't buy it that because guys had something available regionally (like oil stones) that something else couldn't come along better to sharpen the steel. The one things oil stones did was limit how hard a toolmaker could make his tools, but by no means does that mean that when a stone comes along that can sharpen much harder steels, that it will somehow be inferior on softer steels.

A ceramic stone makes a finer edge faster than an oil stone, even on carbon steel. I only use oil stones on carving tools and on edge tools if I'm using them, it's just to play.

Re: ATTN David Weaver: durability testing?

#10

Re: practical plan

David Weaver

Still, this is not a discussion of choosing a whole different medium, or making drastic changes. It's a discussion about dropping a step, not adding one on. (actually, in my case, i usually use a ceramic finishing stone and I usually don't strop. Sometimes I do, but usually not).

I wouldn't like to test the theory, it would be too much work. I wouldn't mind if someone else did, though. I doubt it would make me strop all the time after a ceramic stone, but it doesn't mean I want to squash my curiosity.

I also doubt that I wouldn't strop after a surgical arkansas stone, even if someone proved that the edge was similar durability either way - I just don't like the edge off the arkansas stone for a smoothing plane or a chisel. I'd say it would be suitable for a mortise chisel, but an arkansas stone won't touch my mortise chisels.

Re: ATTN David Weaver: durability testing?

#11

Re: ATTN David Weaver: durability testing?

wilbur

"I got two irons, i won't say which brands."

If you don't want to say which brands, can you at least say what kind of steel, such as "One O-1 blade and one A-2 blade," or "Two A-2 blades from different makers"?

Re: ATTN David Weaver: durability testing?

#12

Re: ATTN David Weaver: durability testing?

David Weaver

Both were A2. Same thickness, same hardness spec, tested in the same plane, etc.

In my follow-up experience roughing boards, and just using several HCS planes and several with A2 irons, I don't think comparing an HCS iron to A2 would be much of a contest unless the A2 iron was faulty.

But, of course, there are always subjective issues, like when to sharpen a finish plane iron that hasn't stopped cutting, and an HCS iron may do well in that contest.

Just A2s checking those irons, though, wanted to take subjectivity and rationalization out as much as possible (i.e., no discussion about what might've been a better bevel angle for one or the other).

I did think that running through almost 2000 feet of hard maple was a pretty impressive display, it was more than I expected, and that 600 or 700 of that was surface-flaw free for one of the irons was also very impressive.

That surface-flaw free depends on chipping in A2s, even on uniform surfaces that you wouldn't expect chipping, and of the brand that did better (because it didn't chip out, really at all for the whole test), I couldn't conclude anything other than that was a very good iron, even for the brand. I say that because I have had other irons from the same brand that chipped out like the second iron in this test.

I can really only conclude from all of this combined with personal experience that all of the A2 irons from mainline manufacturers are about the same, and that you hope to get a good one no matter the brand - good defined as one that doesn't release carbides (i would assume that's what the very small chipping is) very frequently.

Re: ATTN David Weaver: durability testing?

#13

Re: ATTN David Weaver: durability testing?

Bill Tindall

It would be interesting to get hardness measured on the two irons. I will bet that the one that was prone to chipping was heat treated to a greater hardness. There is a trade off between toughness and hardness. An edge that chips is failing because of lack of toughness. A2 is not particularly tough to begin with (compared to about any other tool steel one could have chosen, especially O1) which has always puzzled me as to why it became popular for wood working tools.

Re: ATTN David Weaver: durability testing?

#14

Re: ATTN David Weaver: durability testing?

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

A2 is not particularly tough to begin with (compared to about any other tool steel one could have chosen, especially O1) which has always puzzled me as to why it became popular for wood working tools.

Hi Bill

Well A2 is tougher. However one of the reasons for using it over O1 could be that it is more reliable/predictable in production: less warping = lower rejection rates = lower costs.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: ATTN David Weaver: durability testing?

#15

Re: ATTN David Weaver: durability testing?

David Weaver

It is my opinion, with some experience, that all of the mainline A2 iron makers are getting their hardness on spec (which is pretty much universally 60-62, somewhere around there).

My experience is that one of the irons that I had was a lie-nielsen (this is not at all with respect to the test I mentioned, not one of those irons), and I thought it was a little soft. I sent it to LN and they tested it at 61.5 hardness.

I've had several other tools tested when I was able to barter hardness testing with a buddy, and have a pretty good idea from behavior on ceramic stones when something is a bit soft.

I think it is something other than hardness that determines how the carbides are let free from the A2 in the two irons I tested.

From the standpoint of why use A2? I think it is actually a very good iron for plane irons compared to O1 for a lot of tasks. It outlasts O1 irons in use for me on planes strictly on how fast it is abrasive/adhesive wear occurs. When I dull an O1 iron, it is often not chipped out much if it isn't over-hardened, but the wear bevel is *very* visible, longer and more pronounced. With A2, the wear bevel is never as long or as large for the same amount of use.

I have no qualms about a 10 or 15 degree relief angle, which bothers some people. The irons i tested on hard maple only had a 10 degree relief angle off of a very fine tertiary bevel.

Anyway, where I think the use of A2 is misguided is in bench chisels and paring chisels, but that is my opinion mostly because i like bench chisels to be around 25 degrees for all around use (I am guilty of arguing with other people about that when someone doesn't mind steeper angles, but I do like the shallower angles). There are A2 chisels that are done properly that people have said they have no issue with chipout, etc at angles lower than 30 degrees.

The other benefit to A2, aside from being cheap and easier to harden commercially than older carbon steels, is that any decent waterstone can sharpen it very nicely, and on ceramic stones, there is no perceptible sharpness difference between it and O1 as long as the wire edge is removed.

Maybe someone could also substantiate this, but it is also my opinion of the irons that I've had, based on the spec given, that A2 is better at holding its toughness near the top of its hardness range. O1 can be a bit brittle when you get to the 62 range.

Re: ATTN David Weaver: durability testing?

#16

you are correct

Bill Tindall

I did not remember the data correctly. Hardened for optimum performance (hardness/toughness) A2 is indeed the tougher steel.

Re: ATTN David Weaver: durability testing?

#17

question

Bill Tindall

Why do you think that carbide particle shedding is the source of chipping you observed, and not simply chipping as defined by pieces of edge fracturing? Would not the carbide particles be too small to see and hence the vacancies they left be too small to see as a chip?

Re: ATTN David Weaver: durability testing?

#18

Microchipping at the cutting edge

Steve Elliott

When I was testing blades I found that small chips in the cutting edge were sometimes located right where a rogue scratch intersected the edge. (This is the sort of scratch that I could only see under a microscope, and eliminating all the rogue scratches was something I could never find a way to do.) This wasn't a rigorous scientific test, just an observation that made me think that a more finely honed edge would resist degradation by chipping better than a more coarsely honed one.

This also suggests that small chips in the edge are not due to loss of large carbide particles, they're just places where the forces of planing exceeded the ability of the steel to resist breakage.

Re: ATTN David Weaver: durability testing?

#19

Re: question

David Weaver

steve's explanation may be more accurate than mine, the issue being chips that aren't necessarily large enough to see looking at the edge of the iron, but they leave visible evidence on the surface of a board.

I don't know exactly what's causing the small chips, but they are not large chips like you would get in a chisel if you banged a chunk out of it on something you shouldn't strike.

Crucible's content states that carbides in non-PM alloys may be as large as 50 microns. I don't know if such things are present in high quality tool steels, but if they are, or if they're even a fifth of that size, there wouldn't be a lot of difference between that and microchipping due to a structural collapse around a deformed spot.

Bottom line, a good A2 iron will outlast an HCS iron when the issue at hand is planing until the plane stops cutting or becomes too ungainly to use (which is generally how I work my plane irons other than final smoothing). I think the too-ungainly to use criteria occurs probably 3/4ths of the way to absolutely won't cut anything at all.

Re: ATTN David Weaver: durability testing?

#20

maybe not

Bill Tindall

I have reviewed all the data I have on toughness and find that the toughness of A-2 falls off rapidly above Rc60.

Re: ATTN David Weaver: durability testing?

#22

Re: Well, I am an amateur!!

David Weaver

And really just trying to figure out what works best for a cheap price, and whose claims about this or that are more than just claims.

I did convince myself what was spending good money, and what was spending bad or "indifferent" money - with that fairly quick study and with keeping track of how much wood I could dimension with A2 vs. HCS hocks. Comparing the hocks was separate, but I had mistakenly, subjectively, said that I never really noticed much difference in actual use of the HSS and A2. I guess that was an accurate statement, I hadn't noticed much difference.

But when the rubber hit the road and I quantified it, keeping track while flattening panels, I noticed that I could do quite a bit more face jointing with the A2 irons before they needed to go to the belt sharpener and disc strop.

Those two items were all I wanted to know, so they're the only things I tested. Simply put, I can come up with:

* it likely doesn't matter which brand of A2 iron you get if edge retention is the issue

* A2 irons will let you do more roughing and semi-finish work than HCS irons if neither iron is defective

If nobody has done the strop thing in five years, maybe I could get enough interest to do it, but for now I just want to do woodwork, make tools and read forums.