New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Precision you can feel — woodworking perfected with Lee Valley

Wide tenons

Posts

Wide tenons

#1

Wide tenons

markb

How wide does a tenon need to be before it is split into two? I can't seem to find any guidelines for this in any of the books I have.

I will be making a door with a 9" or so bottom rail. Considering the 1" for the haunch and 1/2" for the groove, I will have up to 7.5" for a tenon. Is this too wide? If so, how should it be split up?

And what exactly is the problem with a wide tenon? I recall reading, although I may be wrong, that too wide of a mortise will weaken the piece. But why would that be so, if the tenon is properly fitted to the mortise?

Thanks very much.

Re: Wide tenons

#2

Re: Wide tenons

Mark Salomon

As you probably know, wood shrinks/expands across its width more than across its length. So, a mortise traps a tenon and doesn't allow it move as much as it needs to and can cause the tenon to split. I doubt if there is a specific "rule" because the problem depends to some extent on the species of wood that is used and the extremes of climate changes that the joint is subjected to. I don't think you need to split the tenon up to 2 inches or so. A tenon as wide as you describes though needs to be split; usually it needs to be no more than a kerf width. If you are interested there are wood shrinkage tables that will tell you exactly how much a given width of the species of wood that you are using will shrink/expand. I typically put a tablesaw blade width kerf in the middle of the tenon and it seems to be enough. I also only glue the top half of the tenon and allow the bottom to expand and contract as it will.

Re: Wide tenons

#3

Re: Wide tenons

Warren in Lancaster, PA

A typical 18th century door with a 9 inch rail would have two tenons separated by a gap of 1 1/2 or 2 inches. So in your case, 2 3/4 or 3 inch tenons. Generally there are through mortises with the tenons wedged from the outside and not glued or pinned. Cabinet doors are sometimes wedged like this, but much more likely to be pinned or glued.

I think a through mortise 7 1/2 inches long would weaken the stile. If the rail got kicked at the bottom, there would be a lot of leverage from large rail tenon and only a little connection at the bottom holding the stile together. Even with the double tenons, I would be inclined to leave a little more solid at the bottom than the one inch you suggest. Just 1/4 more would make me feel more comfortable.

Re: Wide tenons

#4

Thanks guys 

markb

Re: Wide tenons

#5

I should have said double tenons

markb

Thanks Mark, but I wasn't clear. I was referring to what seem to be called double tenons, as described in the link below that I just found.

http://www.geoffswoodwork.co.uk/mortise01.htm

He seems to be saying that no matter how wide the rail, the combined width of the double tenons should be no greater than 5". In my case, the arithmetic would work out nicely, with two 2.5" tenons and a 2.5" tongue between them, but I'm not totally convinced yet. I can understand keeping each tenon section to a maximum of 5" to reduce the possibility of cupping, warping, etc., but I'm not sure why the combined width should be that same maximum, especially if you have a door rail that is 11" or 12" wide, which I don't think would be that extreme. It seems that would yield a rather wimpy tenon.

Thanks again.

Re: Wide tenons

#6

Wide tenons

R.J.Whelan

This is how my granddad taught me:

1. Calculate the square root of the tennon width. This is back in the day before $10 calculators that could do every thing - granddad had a little book (written in German) with a table.

2. If the number is a fraction of a whole number round down for .5 or up for .51

3. For two tennons drill a 3/8" hole in the middle of the tennon about 1/8" from the shoulder and saw out the waste. For three tennons drill a 3/8" hole approximately 1/3 of the distance from either side of the tennon about 1/8" from the shoulder and saw out the waste. And so on ...........

4. Drawbore the tennon at the end you want to be fixed

5. Drawbore the remaining tennons using elongated holes to allow expansion

6. Glue the fixed tennon only.

About 25 years ago I built 28 interior and exterior door for a friends home and they are all still in great shape.

I don't know if this is the ultimate method for door building - I've tended to accept granddads teachings on faith.

Good luck with your door(s) .........

RJ

Re: Wide tenons

#7

Re: Wide tenons

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

I'm not clear how steps 1 and 2 apply to the following steps.

Re: Wide tenons

#8

Yeah, me neither...

markb

and, if I am reading this correctly, you only have a 3/8" gap between the double or triple tenons.

Can I assume that you only have one mortise, and don't have two or three mortises separated by 3/8"?

How do you, or how did your grandfather, decide if a single tenon is too wide and whether it needs to be split into two or three? And the purpose of this is to allow for expansion of the tenon, right?

Re: Wide tenons

#9

Re: Wide tenons

R.J.Whelan

Sorry guys.

Step 1 & 2 establish the number of tennon that the wide tennon should be divided into. For a 9" tennon, the square root is 3 - 3 tennons. The following steps determine where they should be divided - 9/3=3". Drill the holes 3" in from each edge and remove the waste.

I assume my granddad learned this as an apprentice - I've never seen it illustrated anywhere else.

But, it has always worked for me.

RJ