New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Veritas - Innovation in Tools

Evaluation of Woodworking Steels

Posts

Evaluation of Woodworking Steels

#1

Evaluation of Woodworking Steels

Bill Tindall

There have been numerous recent discussions of woodworking steels. I would like to take this opportunity to direct interested woodworkers to what I consider the most thorough evaluation of steels and sharpening, performed by our frequent, and overly modest, contributor Steve Elliott. (see web site at http://bladetest.infillplane.com/index.html)

This web site presents the results of Steve's years of work developing the ability to measure sharpness and using this tool to study sharpening and wear in plane irons. Anyone interested in the technical or practical details of sharpening or steel selection should visit this site. Form these results one can only wonder why A2 is used for anything.

His images are nothing short of stunning. I worked with a professional microscopy lab utilizing tens of thousands of dollars of imaging equipment and was not able to achieve the quality of images Steve has obtained (they weren't photoshopped were they Steve!) It's all in the lighting, and patience and perseverance.

Re: Evaluation of Woodworking Steels

#2

No image manipulation

Steve Elliott

Thanks for your generous praise, Bill.

The microscope images on my site have not been adjusted or sharpened using Photoshop or any other program. Some images have labels which were indeed added using PS. Other images of planes, the microscope, and sharpening equipment have been adjusted and resized for use on the site.

I think innate skepticism might be a better description than modesty. One of the pitfalls of research is the tendency to find what you want to find rather than what's actually there. I want to keep looking and follow the evidence wherever it leads.