New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Urban Salvaged Hardwood Slabs, Milled In-House from Rare Trees. Shop Unique Walnut Stock.

Diamond sharpening question

Posts

Diamond sharpening question

#1

Diamond sharpening question

TD

Does anyone have information as to whether it is safe to use diamond for sharpening kitchen knives. I am concerned about contamination of food with loose diamonds. Not toxic, but then neither is sand or glass powder but they can make you sick. Worst case I am not expecting much harm, but other than convenience it wouldn't be necesarry to go this route. But if it is approved I can think of a couple of useful applications I would like to try.

Re: Diamond sharpening question

#2

Re: Diamond sharpening question

woodenleg

As long as you wash them, I don't think there would be a problem. They make diamond "steel" for putting a edge on knifes. Dave

Re: Diamond sharpening question

#3

Re: Diamond sharpening question

John Payne

I have no definitive answer but I've been doing it for over 20 years. If you do ingest any, it will be such a minute amount I can't see it causing any problems. I do wash them pretty well after sharpening.

John

Re: Diamond sharpening question

#4

Re: Diamond sharpening question

David Weaver

I wouldn't worry about it unless the knives are exceptionally soft, and in that case, you wouldn't need to use diamonds to sharpen them.

Just wipe them off when you're done and all or nearly all of the diamonds should end up in whatever you used to do the wiping.

Re: Diamond sharpening question

#5

what grit do you use

Bruce, a MN Galoot

for kitchen knives? I would assume something as small as 1 micron would be just too fine, but what would be an good, general purpose grit for knives?

Thanks.

Re: Diamond sharpening question

#6

recommendation

Bill Tindall

The company that makes diamond hones for knives recommends fine or extra fine. Personally , I like extra fine for maintenance of edge. For kitchen use it is beneficial to have a less refined edge.

Re: Diamond sharpening question

#7

Re: recommendation

Bruce, a MN Galoot

Thanks, Bill. I have a diamond "steel" for my own kitchen use, and it's great. I should have been more clear.

Specifically, I have a young friend at work who has been reading up on the diamond/cast iron method and he wants to be able to make very keen edges on his hunting knives. What micron size should he use? He has access to a lot of cast iron.

Re: Diamond sharpening question

#8

suggestion

Bill Tindall

What little I know about knife blade technology suggests that it is a whole different world than wood working edges. The preferred means of sharpening seems to be a "slack belt" which results in a convex edge which is very durable. My imprecise hand sharpening on a flat surface leads to something similar. In any case, I think he should consult the knife enthusiasts for an answer. I suspect it will depend on what he is cutting. I'll bet something around 15 micron will be a good place to begin an optimization of what is best for his needs.

Re: Diamond sharpening question

#9

Re: Diamond sharpening question

TD

I've probably been using diamond stones for 30 years, I am askng here about the loose diamonds. I suppose part one is is there anything to worry about. I assume there isn't, but sometimes there are surprises. I came across this awful thing a year or so back about a guy who had pretty nearly maimed his brain by tig welding a part he had cleaned with brake cleaner, which is comonly enough used by some to degrease. Apparently really horrible things happen when heat, brake cleaner, and argon gas are played with.

I guess point two would be has anyone actually gone the distance and offered the product, you know tooth whitening paste with diamond powder in it would get my confidence up. :)

Most knives are ground with a microbevel, but flat grinds and convex edges are ever more popular, and some high end factory knives now come with the option of either. As to which edge is actually tougher the issues are very similar to planes and chisels, and depend mostly on analysing the specifics rather than just throwing around claims. So for instance a 20 degree primary with a 25 degree micro might be less tough than a 25 degree single bevel. But a 25 degree primary with a 30 degree micro would be different again. Woodworking tools like the axe, and some drawknives, and slicks, etc... have convex bevels.

Re: Diamond sharpening question

#10

Re: Diamond sharpening question

Dan Donaldson

I would not even want to think about tooth whitening powdered diamonds. It would easily erode away the enamel and the teeth would go away. ;)

Re: Diamond sharpening question

#11

Re: Diamond sharpening question

David Weaver

Don't know of the health consequences, but I would bet the same issue exists as does with any other small dust. If you get them small enough, you could ingest some. Do they break down in the body?

My bigger issue with loose diamonds and knives is that you have to use a lubricant with loose diamonds and I don't like the feel of steel on steel with knives, and I don't like the mess of the lubricant and the obligation to get all of it off the knife.

I do like what was mentioned earlier on this thread - a slack belt for a rounded bevel. I only have two knives that warrant hand sharpening (japanese) and I do hand sharpen them. Everything else gets a 1200 grit trizact belt followed by a chase of the burr. My knives are the cheap ginsu full tang brand that you can get on amazon for about $80. I'd be surprised if they're harder than 50, but if you saw how my wife uses knives, you'd understand why I go with both:

* cheap knives that aren't too hard

* fast and not so fine sharpening (though you can still shave hair with the knives, they're not sharp like a hand sharpened japanese knife)

I keep my deba and santoku in the drawer for when I am going to use knives. My wife doesn't like them, she is afraid of very sharp knives and even the above slack belt sharpening method elicits negative comments.

Re: Diamond sharpening question

#12

I will take a crack at your request

Bill Tindall

1. Look up a MSDS sheet for diamonds and judge for yourself based on the most reliable information available. MSDA sheets for any common chemical can be found with a Google search. Focus on the ingestion section for I presume ingestion is the exposure you are concerned about. Evaluate the data in the context that "risk" depends on concentration and time of exposure, both infinitesimal in your case. Diamonds are one of the most chemically inert materials I can imagine.

2. Soap Box in place......When I see a question like yours I wonder, where do these concerns come from. In this case you provided the answer and your concern is a logical result of the exposure you have had to published data on other seemingly harmless stuff.

Unfortunately it has become possible through the many means of rapid communication we have, and trendy, to disseminate alarming stories of this or that adverse effect from exposure to some chemical- brake cleaner, lacquer thinner, mineral spirits, non-organic food etc. The rare instances where exposure does indeed result in an adverse health effect- asbestos, lead, etc- lends credence to these other tales. The result is a public skeptical about the safety of everything, in spite of the obvious fact that everybody except the person described on the internet or in the nightly entertainment that passes for news has never had an adverse effect.

For a number of reasons I don't believe the cause and effect in the brake cleaner tale. None of it makes any toxicological sense. Ditto for most of the other hysterical claims of exposure to this or that. While I don't necessarily doubt the health effect claimed, the claimed cause, this or that exposure, rarely had been substantiated by any sort of investigation by someone with the skills to evaluate the situation. But it makes great "news".