New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A55 Smoothing Plane

Posted on messages too

Posts

Posted on messages too

#1

Posted on messages too

Gary Smyth

Square, square WT?

I don't often get really, really ticked off but this email alert sent me off the edge this AM. A square for $169. Now, I get quality, and I get profit, and I get that I DON'T have to purchase it, but I wouldn't mind a good square, or two, if I knew what I had was dead on. Maybe $10 - $15 is too little for quality, but $169.00? Why can't companies who make squares make one that does what it's supposed to do. I'm talking to you Stanley, Empire, Miller's Falls, Mayes, Harbor Freight, et al. Yea, I know all about squaring up a square drawing lines. flipping the square, hitting it with a punch etc. But why should I do that when we buy the square to begin with BECAUSE IT IS A SQUARE. Isn't there someway to stop this madness? Why must I or any of us pay a premium for something that is supposed to be something but is not? This is a travesty.

And while I'm ranting why doesn't every hardware store in the country have a registered jig that will tell you if a square is square? Every tool counter ought to have something that is dead on to let the buyer know that a square purchased is correct.


Re: Posted on messages too

#2

Re: Posted on messages too

David Weaver

Is that made of aluminum?

About 4 years ago, I got a 24" starrett engineer's square/try square on ebay for $19 (but it did cost $32 to ship). It's a nice piece of gear to have for making jigs and shooting boards, but I can't imagine having a daily use large square like that to chase around and hope it never hit anything.

Re: Posted on messages too

#3

AMEN and AMEN again !@!

roninkokomo

Re: Posted on messages too

#4

Re: Posted on messages too

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

I generally agree with what you said; but to give the manufacturers a bit of a break, a lot of squareness is lost to shipping and customer handling, things over which they have only partial control.

Pam

Re: Posted on messages too

#5

Re: Posted on messages too

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

I wonder how you re-square this when it goes out of square? If they made the extrusion added to the stock (short) side of the square adjustable by making the holes larger, it will need re-squaring more frequently; but if that extrusion is not adjustable, that's a lot of metal on the beam (long) leg to have to file/scrape back to square.

Re: Posted on messages too

#6

Re: Posted on messages too

David Weaver

I think I would rather just have a square that was detachable, two straight pieces, and could be adjusted.

The 24" starrett is too heavy to use for anything woodworking, you have to use two hands.

But I agree with you - when it's not square, if it's all one piece, you have a mess on your hands.

Last thing you want to do is pay a lot for something and then have it be less user friendly than something you could make cheaply.

Re: Posted on messages too

#7

David Barnett

If it IS square...

David Barnett

...I can't see how $169 is overpriced -- not for 16" x 26". I'd sure want to test it and return it if is wasn't, though. Good optics and good measuring tools are no place to scrimp, but they absolutely have to stand up to scrutiny and verification. BTW, Woodpeckers has been steadily earning a well-deserved reputation for their precision tools and quality control, and this from a confirmed Starrett fan.

Re: Posted on messages too

#8

Man, looks like that really hit a nerve

John in NM

Funny how all the marketing stuff just seems like background noise until one thing pushes it over the edge and it becomes a major irritant...

I don't get the huge square paradigm any more than mammoth straight edges or the whole "gripper" business (yes, I know it's got more "r's" in the TM version, but I can never remember how to spell it right... or wrong in this case... so I'll default to the Websters approved version - to each their own pet peeve :D ).

Re: Posted on messages too

#9

David Barnett

Not extrusions...

David Barnett

...but rather cast as 1/4" aluminum tool plate. Although extrusions in 6061, 6063, and so on can yield highly precise products, stresses are virtually eliminated when cut and machined from cast plate. CNC machining produces amazingly precise instruments nowadays that meet stringent metrological standards.

Don't take me wrong. I'm not saying one must have such tools to do good work -- not at all -- but for doing certain things to very high standards, these tools and tools like them can justify their purchase. I can't begrudge anyone owning and using a decent square at a decent price (yes, it's a fair price for a precision tool of this length and method of manufacture). Price any certified engineer's squares lately? How about cylindrical squares? Overkill? For woodworking, yes. Which is why this square seems so reasonably priced.

Re: Posted on messages too

#10

A few things bug me here...

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

The ad tells us that the square is precise, but there is no benchmark provided. Call me difficult, but even British Standard 939 Grade B (less than 0.001" deviation over the entire length of the blade) allows close to 1/32" deviation from square. I'd like to know the tolerance (and not the weight of the CNC machine milling the blanks...) before pulling out the credit card.

(note: I'm no expert whatsoever in engineering standards, I just happen to know the one I mention here because it's mentioned fairly often).

Another thing that bugs me are the "cheeks" (fence, ledge, whatever). The ad doesn't state if it's made of one piece or two, and whether it is adjustable. There is potential here for the tool to be out of square, yet this could go undetected if the cheeks are not parallel to each other.

Finally (and people here might not have an answer for this), a fitted case is available separately. This begs the question of how the square is shipped if the case is not purchased. Seems to me there's potential for the square to be damaged during shipping... I guess that the packaging will be sturdy enough, but the ad says nothing about this.

If the square is precise as it is suggested, then I agree that $169 is not expensive. But I would like more information before pulling the trigger...

DC

Re: Posted on messages too

#11

David Barnett

All good concerns *LINK*

David Barnett

Denis, I don't understand where you're getting "even British Standard 939 Grade B (less than 0.001" deviation over the entire length of the blade) allows close to 1/32" deviation from square."


This doesn't mean much unless it's expressed as 1/32" over a given length. Also, as I understand it, from my copy of BS 939:1977 (since replaced by BS 939:2007), there's nothing even close to that in even a long blade run such as 640mm.

Compliance with the standard so specifies that a 150mm blade Grade B machinist's square requires "the squareness of the blade edges and the stock working face falls within �0.016mm/0.00064" tolerance." As you've pointed out, this does not specify the angular deviation from perpendicular allowed per length of blade (usually stated as seconds decimal of arc, by the way).

Again, if and only if runout on the One-Time 2616 square is consistent with tool room Grade B, would I consider purchasing it, which is why I'll talk to someone at Woodpeckers who can assure me that it will. Your point on packaging and shipping is no less important and will also be addressed.

Right now, I'm leaning to ordering the 1281 square, another rule stop for my 24" Starrett blade, and either the 24" or 32" T-square. I've long been vexed with inaccurate yet considerably costly T-squares for art and drawing and after seeing how these are working out for a friend at Ringling, think I'll give one a try.

My other concern is lining. I'll stick with machinist's tools for scribing on metal, and I do have very fine mechanical pencils and drafting pens, but want to know relief and parallax specs, and especially, wear characteristics, as this is aluminum rather than steel. If one can only scribe with non-jacketed pencils, and so on, this would be a drawback and would make me question why one would need such precision in a tool that can't support lining of unvarying thickness.

Adjustability of registration surfaces or ledges seems unlikely, as the square is apparently machined from a single plate.


B. SQUARENESS TO DIN 875/I OR BS939B

Re: Posted on messages too

#12

Construction of that square

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

"Adjustability of registration surfaces or ledges seems unlikely, as the square is apparently machined from a single plate."

True, if you're using the inner edge of the machined plate as your registration surface; but Woodpeckers has added what it calls "cheeks" to the short leg, making a stock (as in the stock on a try square). The marketing picture clearly shows the mechanic registering against these cheeks/the stock. If these are not adjustable, there must have been considerable precision involved in the hole layout, or some kind of scraping/grinding done to bring them to final square; and, if they are, there's potential for getting knocked out of adjustment.

I'm backing away from my earlier disdain for this square, as I look at it more. It's not meeting any needs I myself have; but I can see its utility for folks doing certain kinds of casework.

Still, their advertising fails to specify the level of precision to which the square has been produced - nothing is ever perfect, just a defined approximation of perfect. And I can't find anything on their website about warranty.

Re: Posted on messages too

#13

Sorry, my mistake...

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

The quote should have read "less than 0.001" per inch over the entire length of the blade", therefore over 26 inches there is potential for 0.026" deviation, close to 1/32" or 0.03125".

Or am I doing the math wrong?

DC

Re: Posted on messages too

#14

Since I paid a lot for a 12" Starrett

Bruce, a MN Galoot

I guess I can't really complain about a bigger price for a bigger square. I just don't have need for that level of accuracy in anything I do.

All I have for a framing square is an old hardware store square. I learned to do the adjustment trick to it, and now it is as accurate as it's possible for me to make it - about 1/64" in 24" - and I don't need much more than that. My cabinets don't end up that good anyhow, but they're getting closer :) That's why there are block planes to make up the difference.