New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

THE WOODRAT IS BACK!

Killing bugs in ash lumber...

Posts

Killing bugs in ash lumber...

#1

Killing bugs in ash lumber...

John Aniano in central NJ

Hello All,

My Rubo-style bench is slowly moving along. I recently milled the two 8-foot long ash stretchers and found slight evidence of still active small boring insects.

Question - if I made a leak-free tent of plastic and strongly ammonia fumed the pieces for, say, a month, would this get rid of the bugs? I don't care much about the resulting color - this is a workbench! Alternatively, I have a 8'x12' firewood shed that I can put the pieces into and set off a few commercial "bug bombs" (after closing up the shed vents). Will get the bugs in the firewood as well...

Would either of these two methods work, or will I have to resort to the 130 degrees temperature for 3 hours treatment advocated on most of the websites I've found?

Over and out,

John

Re: Killing bugs in ash lumber...

#2

Dale Lenz

Re: Killing bugs in ash lumber...

Dale Lenz

Check out Tim-Bor or Bora-Care. Should do the trick.

Re: Killing bugs in ash lumber...

#3

I doubt the effectiveness of this approach

Bill Tindall

We sold, dried, stored and otherwise were involved with hardwood lumber for many years. Indeed, ash seems to be the favored food of these critters. It is the only lumber we ever had serious damage in. In one unfortunate case we had most of a 500 bdft pack of ash destroyed before I knew what was happening. After that all ash was teated.

Should you ever face an ash problem in the future I have found that a pretreatment with insecticide eliminates future concerns for at least 20 years, the length of my experience. Personally I use Lindane, a product no longer readily available. I suspect that any persistent insecticide will do. In days gone by commercial operations dipped in a variant of pentachlorophenol which took care of bugs and mold stain.

Your problem is to get killing conditions to where the bugs are at, inside the lumber. Surface treatment with non-volatile poisons will do nothing useful. A variety of other treatments can be effective. Pick your convenience:

Flood surface of lumber with toxic(to the bugs) solvent. Ethyl acetate is preferred by butterfly collectors but it may be hard to find. However, any solvent will do if the dose is high- toluene, acetone, lacquer solvent. Obviously this approach has flammability concerns.

Tent and fumigate with something toxic to bugs. While I have not tried it I would presume the "bug bombs" would work well. I don't know if ammonia is toxic to these bugs. It would not be my choice.

Put a solvent based finish on the lumber. The fumes will kill what lies below.

Hope for the best. Sometimes a few will invade, munch a bit and leave. Other times the internal portions of the lumber will be totally destroyed, with only a few exit holes visible on the outside.

Re: Killing bugs in ash lumber...

#4

Dale Lenz

Research it!

Dale Lenz

Re: Killing bugs in ash lumber...

#5

correction

Bill Tindall

I am sure if you can get this nonvolatile material (active ingredient is common borax) to the ends of the tunnels within the lumber where these guys are eating it will work effectively. The chances of diffusing a toxic vapor to the ends of these active tunnels could be greater. I have stopped them with the vapor approach.

Re: Killing bugs in ash lumber...

#6

Re: correction

David Weaver

I have and use tim-bor, but not for woodworking. My understanding is that it is intended to be a pre-treatment for lumber that is not damaged, to create a toxic layer for bugs (especially boring bugs) to chew through.

It's too hard to tell if I've had any success with powder post beetles that were on my porch, they may have just gone elsewhere or deeper into the wood, but I splattered the stuff on posts and exposed ends, anyway.

I'd vote for the cooking method - you know they're dead with it, and you don't have to try to guess at how you're going to get the borate in their path in non-permeable wood.

Re: Killing bugs in ash lumber...

#7

If you pursue the heating route.....

Bill Tindall

A handy way to heat lumber cheaply is with the kind of portable heater that sits above a tank and has a fan the blows hot air out of the horizontal combustion chamber. No doubt these things, widely used by contractors, have a name, but I don't know it. I have always borrowed or rented them. With even a crude enclosure you can get a stack of lumber hot enough to thoroughly "kiln dry" it, or roast bugs. We have dried thousands of bdft of easy to dry species by just erecting a frame over a stack and covering the frame with inexpensive sheeting of any kind. One large unit is adequate to heat and dry 2000-3000 bdft of lumber with temperatures upwards of 150F.

However, there is a risk. If you just rocket up the temperature, focusing just on bug roasting, you may in turn dry the lumber too fast and it will crack, especially the ends. Chemical warfare is safer on the lumber, but other concerns are to be considered.

Re: Killing bugs in ash lumber...

#8

Torpedo Heater

David Weaver

They call them torpedo heaters here.

very popular (for drying out a basement) with people who live near creeks.

Re: Killing bugs in ash lumber...

#9

Oh......

Bill Tindall

"very popular (for drying out a basement) with people who live near creeks."

It sounds like there is a lot more to this story! Maybe this is why I was always able to borrow one or two in mid summer to dry wood.

Re: Killing bugs in ash lumber...

#10

Dale Lenz

Bug Bombs?? *LINK*

Dale Lenz

Below is a link to a google search page about how bug bombs work. Out of the few links I read, does not sound like BB will work well for critters in lumber. The vapor is mainly for current flying and exposed critters. The residual chemical will work for a time when other critters come in contact with the muck. As explained in some of the links BB will not generally reach into the deep crevices of the room, seems that would leave wood tunnels out of the pictures.

As I understand Bora-Care is for dry lumber and will penetrate deep into the wood fibers and take out critters, assuming you follow label direction.

Lindane treatment like what Bill and I use is a chemical shield that is applied Before critters tries to infest the wood. The superficial chemical dries as a crystal on the surface of the wood ,after the sprayed of Lindane dries, will take out most critters when they come in contact with it. An entomologist once told me to spray Lindane on an infested board then set the board out in the sun. The sun heats the lumber up, speeds up the bug life's cycle, critter comes out and zap! Personally, if I find evidence of PPB in my lumber, once in a Bright Blue Moon, that board gets cut up in 18" pieces and is burned in the wood heater, come winter. I've cut up two boards in 25+ years for firewood, since I've started using Lindane. I pick up a few boards here and there from sawmillers and maybe that�s where the buggy lumber came from.

As mentioned in an earlier post heating bug infested lumber to 130*F, at the lumber's core, for a few hours will kill any present bugs and their eggs. As will fumigation properly done with Methyl Bromide, Some Kind of Nasty stuff...Can take the operator out if they are careless.

The reason that I recommended Tim-Bore or Bora-Care in an earlier post is, it seems like to me it would be the easiest thing to do, as the other methods to control wood critters may not be within easy reach of most woodworks, myself included.

Anyway, hope the above information helps. I'm a full time professional forester and advise folks on this question once or twice a year. My main job is forest management. But obviously, since I visit this board, I'm interested in wood.


How bug bombs work

Re: Killing bugs in ash lumber...

#11

It is all about vapor pressure

Bill Tindall

Most of the common insecticides stink, which means they are volatilizing and it is the vapors one smells. A bug bomb spews out an aerosol of insecticide and because the insecticide is in tiny droplets it will vaporize readily, saturating the area with vapor.

To "kill within" this vapor will need to diffuse into the tunnels. I can kill the bugs that invade my corn barrels by putting this same insecticide in a dish and sealing it in the barrel. It will kill to the bottom of the barrel, eventually. The challenge of using a bug bomb will be to expose the lumber to the vapor for a sufficiently long time to allow diffusion of vapor into the tunnels. I agree that in an airy shed a bug bomb may not stay around long enough. Sealed in a plastic bag or tent, it may.

My preferred way to deal with this problem is to flood the board with solvent and wrap in plastic.

Re: Killing bugs in ash lumber...

#12

Stephen Shepherd

Re: Killing bugs in ash lumber...

Stephen Shepherd

You might try gassing the little buggers. Place the pieces in a large plastic bag and put in a piece of dry ice and seal up the bag. Allow for expansion as the CO2 is released.

Stephen

Re: Killing bugs in ash lumber...

#13

Re: Killing bugs in ash lumber...

StephanieSuesanSmith

The emerald ash borer is an invasive insect in ash trees. Many parts of NJ and other states are under quarantine for it. There is no non-professional strength treatment that kills this bug. Wood is placed in a big fumigator and brought up to high pressure to drive the poison in. I just had an article in Scroll Saw Magazine on tree killing insects and did research on this one for it.