New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Support WoodCentral when buying things you need

What stone unturned

Posts

What stone unturned

#1

What stone unturned

Gary Smyth

This was posted in messages section yesterday but it was suggested that Hand Tools might also turn up results.

I went to a house sale this week. I found this stone and paid much less than the gas it took to get there -- and the location was close. Anyway, the stone is very, very smooth, close to dead flat in the long direction with one corner low at the pictured end. (camera closeness exaggerates the curvature) It was semi-hard caked with clean gelled oil which I removed with solvent (the white haze). No name anywhere. The oil stain stayed, but I'm wondering if it might be a white Arkansas? It's almost as smooth as my black stone to the finger touch, but the pores seem bigger. It is not any where near as rough as any grit Norton stone I have, or for that matter, 1200 grit paper. I don't know how stones are graded and I haven't had success on the web identifying what stones are harder above the rougher grades. If it helps, the man was in his 90's and a farmer. Unless he went out of his way years ago, the stone would not be Japanese. Also, any recommendation as to what would be needed to touch up/flatten a very fine grained hard stone? Granite plate and diamond dust?


Re: What stone unturned

#2

Re: What stone unturned

Joe Rogers, Northern Virginia

By looking at the end photo it appears that you have a Soft Arkansas or possibly a Washita. The only way to be sure is to use the stone and compare it to known grit stones or...the manufacturers use the specific gravity test to tell how dense it is. There is a formula out there in Google land but I don't have a link at hand.

It is weight vs volume and the heavier the stone by volume equals a finer grit.

JR

Re: What stone unturned

#4

Re: SG  and grading of novaculite

joel moskowitz

The table however just relates to Dan's Whetstones (which make a fine stone). Other companies, such as norton have different colored material with different densities coming out of the quarry. Up until recently Norton for example didn't make a distinction of different grades of hard translucent stone. Then they discovered they could charge more for black arkansas - so they did.

I have beautiful material in just about every color of the rainbow in top quality stuff.

The big issue is the way arkansas stones are finished. In the old days they were sliced by abrasion and by the time the stone hit the market the surfaces were warn smooth. Now they are sliced with diamond saws which leaves a much sharper surface. Use the stone for a couple of months and the super fine quality appears.

F

Re: What stone unturned

#5

David Barnett

Re: SG  and grading of novaculite

David Barnett

Thanks for clarifying, Joel. I had no idea there was that much variation in SG. But to heck with the SG -- I like the pink ones.

Re: What stone unturned

#6

Flattening Oilstones

Steve Elliott

Unless you intend to use the stone as a substrate for diamond I wouldn't recommend using loose diamond to flatten it. (There are better substrates for diamond, by the way.)

I've flattened oilstones using wet/dry paper on a granite surface plate and it worked well. It's slow because oilstones themselves are so resistant to abrasion, but that's one of their advantages.

A coarse fixed diamond plate would also work well. I believe that's what Larry Williams uses.

Re: What stone unturned

#7

Re: SG  and grading of novaculite

joel moskowitz

This thread gave me the idea of a blog entry of pictures of pretty arkansas stones. For awhile I was saving some nice ones - no reason to - I have enough stones in a drawer that will last my heirs 14000 years.

Re: What stone unturned

#8

Re: SG  and grading of novaculite

Gary Smyth

Why not show them here? I for one, would like to see what's out there.

Re: What stone unturned

#9

Re: SG  and grading of novaculite

joel moskowitz

I'll post a link here where I post the blog.

I still have to dig out the stones and take the pictures so it's not happening this second.

Re: What stone unturned

#10

Re: Flattening Oilstones

John Aniano in Central NJ

Steve, Gary, et al,

I have flattened maybe 5 hard and soft Arkansas stones using my diagonally slotted, SiC Norton waterstone flattening "block". I use it dry and after a minute or two of hand grinding, rotate the stone 180 degrees and vacuum off the dust and repeat until all the low spots are gone and the stone is uniform. Works for me...

John