Scoring versus grooving *LINK*
David Barnett
You're on track, Derek. One thing, sometimes loose grit is less messy than paste, sometimes far more, depending on use. For sharpening, though, paste is usually preferred.
One should perhaps draw a distinction between scoring and grooving. Although Cecil Pierce rightly refers to a single shallow pass with a pointed object as scoring, he spaces his scores at 3/8", which is not the scoring often seen on laps for finer diamond pastes in the 14,000 grit and above range. That scoring often resemble a badly and erratically scratch 78-rpm record, similar to the link in a previous reply to this thread.
Pierce used 8,000 grit, and while this may have offered an advantage, it's lost on me for sharpening bevels. On rotary laps, even slowly rotating horizontal laps, scoring has long been used for the finer abrasive grits used in gem polishing, especially on flat laps used for faceting.This does make a difference, although it's variable from gem species to species. I have not, however, detected an advantage for sharpening steel blade bevels.
The wider grooves as seen on diaper patterned laps are for swarf, stiction and particle control, especially when using larger particles, as you've mentioned. When lapping with loose diamond, the particles actually embed into the cast iron, which presents them for further fracturing and embedding. The wider grooves are intended to reduce stiction due to the greater surface area of chisel and plane blade backs and do little to benefit bevels, especially microbevels, and can be counterproductive when sharpening narrow chisels and instruments.
Scoring, that is, very fine cuts into the substrate are useful for for presentation and but less so for swarf removal when using either loose or paste diamond. Paste diamond is generally a convenience on flat laps used with hand technique. On rotary laps and points (shaped laps resembling burrs) the medium is more important to give the substrate time to accept and present the diamond (of course, one could look at it from the diamond's point of view). Captive diamond grit is a goal of substrate and medium for gem carvers and faceters alike. It is probably more useful to think of the scoring laps for fine mesh diamond as 'texturing'.
The deeply grooved laps are largely a holdout from the pre-diamond days of specimen preparation, mirror grinding (pitch laps), machine tuning, and so on.
"The ideal substratum is something that is soft enough to bed the diamonds but hard enough not to let them bed too deeply."
Also, not to disintegrate too rapidly, such as when wood, wax, pitch, and other softer substrates are employed, which can be a problem when pointy things (greater sectional density) are carved and cut with diamond.
I've never used the word 'captured' to mean diamond in media, although it makes sense, as there is a blending of substrate and medium when one is lapping with waxes, resins, and so on. Usually captured refers to the grit being held by the substrate.
Speaking of captured, I'm experimenting with a rather soft, I suppose one may say 'sticky' 45% lead crystal substrate and getting very promising results, especially with coarser diamond. The slabs are simply the glass ground flat -- no cast-in diamond grit -- and are used just a cast iron laps. Easy to make, far prettier colors than cast iron, by the way, and doesn't rust.
Veritas lapping plate (wide grooves, wide spacing)