New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Super Resolution Thermal Imaging Camera

How best to groove CI?

Posts

How best to groove CI?

#1

How best to groove CI?

anotherBob

I figured someone here might know... want to cut/grind grooves in my CI lapping discs on one side to hopefully eradicate the "stiction" when honing the backside of my irons. I have a pointed carbide marker (thought about mounting it on a metal arm that swings back and forth, creating arcs), dremel (not sure what would work best with that), file...

The 1 micron diamond paste works beautifully on the bevel side, but how do you folks handle the backs...? Made a honing guide for the bevels and it is working very nicely/fast/easy, but for the backs... I'm wondering if making some kind of rotary hone with my second disc might be worth the trouble.

Re: How best to groove CI?

#2

David Barnett

An easy way

David Barnett

From Cecil Pierce, Fifty Years a Planemaker and User, p. 50:

"These cast iron laps will need to be scored on their working surfaces. This is done with a scoring tool that can easily be made by grinding the hard end (not the tang end) of a three-corner file to a sharp point -- I have used various other things already made, such as an ice pick and a carbide scriber.

This scoring is done along a steel straightedge, held diagonally from corner to corner of the lap. Make scribes as deeply as possible, using only one pass; space them 3/8 inches apart over the entire surface. Then do the same in the opposite direction, which will give a diamond-shape grid effect.

The reason for one pass only is that the second pass will not likely follow the first in angle and will therefor e produce too wide a groove."

He adds: "All this scratching of lines will raise small burrs upon the surface which should be removed by rubbing the plate with a fine emory paper."

I'm sure you can compensate for round laps. I used layout fluid on my laps and lightly scribed the diaper pattern, but this was more from fastidiousness than necessity. I also used a different scriber to groove the lines, which I find more controllable (as it's a pull tool) than Cecil's method, although again, this isn't terribly important. As you're wanting somewhat wider (not too wide, though, surely nothing so wide as the LV lap) and deeper grooves, you might want to do the same. Grooves 1/2" apart or even more are fine for flattening backs. Although I have a couple laps with shallow grooves, I don't use those for everyday sharpening. Just a smooth lap.

My groover has a short 90� hook at the end (you can use a three-corner file for this, as well), ground to the shape I prefer, then hardened. I don't temper such tools unless more grinding needs to be done. The end is ground so that it will only cut to a fixed depth and so it will easily index and follow a straightedge. I wish I could simply draw a picture but I've never become comfortable with the drawing pad so loaned it out. It's a lot more obvious and easy to make than it probably sounds, though, I promise. [I should probably clarify, this is rather more a scraping tool than a scratching-scribing tool.]

Anyway, it's good to put a handle on it, especially if it's short. If you use a file, just epoxy a piece of tubing over most of the length.

There are other ways to scribe or groove, of course. I've used gravers, but most aren't likely to have these lying about. I've also used a Foredom with a guide and parting wheels. But as scrape-n-scratch works, it's probably the most straightforward and ready-to-go method.

Re: How best to groove CI?

#3

David Barnett

Addendum -- rounding the bottoms of grooves *LINK*

David Barnett

You can also use a Swiss pattern joint file to round the bottom of wider grooves -- that is, grooves for flattening and lapping the backs of chisels and planes irons. I have joint files in several thicknesses for hinge-making in jewelry, but these have become expensive. I've also rounded narrow grooves with round gravers, but you could also make a pull scraper to radius the grooves similar to the aforementioned pull scraper.

To make a round graver, you simply grind off the end of a small punch or watchmaker's staking punch -- anything conical -- at an angle. Use a light hammer to drive it toward you. Light lubrication may help.

http://www.igraver.com/roundgravers.shtml


Swiss round-edge joint files (bottom of page)

Re: How best to groove CI?

#4

Re: Addendum -- rounding the bottoms of grooves

anotherBob

Thanks a bazillion David! I know what I'm doing today...

Re: How best to groove CI?

#5

Arghh... another slope, whoda thunk...

anotherBob

it's lined with pneumatic engravers, specialized honing profile jigs, on and on...

...but I just want to cut some grooves in cast iron... back on task, focus...

quick googling for videos, maybe better to see...:

by hand - http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lbcYvLLHIhU

and "assisted" - http://www.youtube.com/user/Mixstuff?blend=10&ob=5

ok, burning electrons sounds and looks easier/quicker for now...

$35 later after picking up a cheapo Dremel electric engraver (it just has to do what I need (maybe it'll last that long...? shrug, who knows...)) and a spare carbide 1/8" grinder tip that is supposed to go on their regular Dremel. (figured it would be easy to re-profile then hone, we'll soon see)

Re: How best to groove CI?

#6

David Barnett

Scoring isn't always pretty *LINK*

David Barnett

Bob, those Dremel engravers vibrate rather than excavate to make marks, which I don't think will do you a whole lot of good for what you have in mind for the CI laps. Okay for marking tools, however. As for rotary engraving, the little carbide burrs can be pretty tough to control without jigging or practiced technique, so use a very light touch. I've seen people do amazing work on glass freehand.

The GRS and Lindsay gravers are reciprocating action and actually cut much more akin to the hammer and chisel method, albeit much finer. One thing, you don't have to worry about neatness, as many rotary laps used in faceting are scored helter skelter. They look like hell but work great.

When using gravers or files, I'd still score/groove first to help guide the graver or file. The gravers are more for deepening the channels without over-widening them, which is not actually necessary, although I prefer it.

Here's an article describing flattening with SiC on a Harris lap.

http://tinyurl.com/HarrisScoredLap

If you do intend to use diamond for flattening, try something in a finer range, such as the equivalent of 1200 grit. Diamond cuts fast and deep and too coarse a grit takes longer to polish out. 600 grit can be okay, though, especially for more challenging blades, if you follow up with 1200, 3000, then 8000, and 14000 if you want to. One thing, though, if you hone on one side and use the flip side for flattening, contamination can rear its ugly head. I usually advise going from a 600-grit diamond stone to lapping with 14,000 to avoid the contamination issue altogether.

These days, I tell people to use their new 600 grit diamond stone to flatten backs which helps to break it in for later honing. Most 600 grit stones cut way too aggresively at first. Of course, I consider them nicely broken-in when some think they've worn them out.


Not so pretty but effective

Re: How best to groove CI?

#7

Unnecessary

Bill Tindall

I have been using diamond on cast iron for years now and have encountered no reason to need to groove a plate. It may be easier to alter your technique so that grooving is unnecessary rather than groove a plate. If you will describe exactly what you are doing I may be able to offer suggestions for eliminating the problem. You may email be off line if you wish, or not......

My technique is to use a tiny amount of paste and either WD 40 or mineral spirits for lubricant. My plate sits on a piece of rubber "shelf liner"- the stuff that looks like expanded metal pattern. The plate never moves during sharpening bevel or back. If the plate is grabby I would suspect too much paste or too little or the wrong kind of lubricant. The tool should slide effortlessly on the plate.

Re: How best to groove CI?

#8

David Barnett

Actually, I agree with Bill

David Barnett

As I said, I don't bother with grooved laps for honing, but I have used then for flattening backs. Boy, it's really rare when I don't agree with Bill, these days.

Re: How best to groove CI?

#9

Re: Scoring isn't always pretty

anotherBob

David, I'm afraid you're right... didn't work as well as I'd hoped. Did a few things earlier, honed the carbide tip to 1 micron... looks great. Take a break, grab some lunch... went out like a light, darnit. :( Get some coffee and test it on a piece of brass - WOW it works great, easy-peasy. Dykem then mark the diamond grid, clamp down a guide bar and start... looked pretty good for the first inch or so, then not so much. Checked the tip, no, don't see any chips missing from the edge, held up pretty well. Discovered that I could make a line if I went backwards several times... nah, not worth the effort, need the real deal or a hammer and a longer cutter. Oh well, next time I need something named for the heat treat guy, I'll be in business.

Wasn't worried about grit contamination, planned on using the same 1 micron paste on both sides saving the gridded side for backs. Idea was to maybe try .25 micron on the other disc.

Hammer and pointed tool... kinda goes with the "man-cave" theme, sure my better half will have a giggle over this. :)

Re: How best to groove CI?

#10

Re: Unnecessary

anotherBob



I have been using diamond on cast iron for years now and have encountered no reason to need to groove a plate. It may be easier to alter your technique so that grooving is unnecessary rather than groove a plate. If you will describe exactly what you are doing I may be able to offer suggestions for eliminating the problem.


Thanks Bill, I'll try... I spread small dots of paste roughly every 3/4" then roll them in with a ~1/2" wide roller bearing mounted on the end of a piece of wood. Like I said before, on the bevel side I have no problem, but on the backs, the iron seems to kind of float around. Usually one side or corner will dig in to the plate at some point and it generally just dubbs the edges.



My technique is to use a tiny amount of paste and either WD 40 or mineral spirits for lubricant. My plate sits on a piece of rubber "shelf liner"- the stuff that looks like expanded metal pattern. The plate never moves during sharpening bevel or back. If the plate is grabby I would suspect too much paste or too little or the wrong kind of lubricant. The tool should slide effortlessly on the plate.


I've tried thinning the paste with WD 40, I've tried wiping most all of the paste off and using mostly WD... same problem. In my minds eye I can see the tool sliding effortlessly, in practice... no.

Wonder if my mixing ratios are off... going from memory:

roughly 1 tablespoon/5ml paste comprised of: Vaseline, Renaissance wax, kaolin china clay + 1 vial of 5ct/1 micron diamond powder.

Everything mixed well before adding the diamond powder, then crammed into one of those ~2 tablespoon/10ml medicine syringes picked up from the local pharmacy. The syringe was half full last time I filled it... am I using too little diamond? Although it's tough to really see the diamond, even when wiped clean with WD 40, it cut the bevel side pretty darned fast/well.

I figured that cutting grooves would give the swarf and whatever air pocket that must be developing under the blade... a means of escape. From what you're saying, you are not experiencing this. Should have mentioned that the cast iron I'm using are 6" wide x 1 1/8" thick which have been blanchard ground. Can't think of anything else to add... what am I doing wrong?

Thanks again,

Bob

Re: How best to groove CI?

#11

I'm confused

Bill Tindall

I suspect you are over thinking this technique. Been there myself.

If using diamond powder I add about the tiniest amount I can see (probably no more than 1 or 2 milligrams) to the end of a tiny spatula and dump it into a few drops of WD 40 on my 2 x 12" plate. I cover my finger with a piece of plastic grocery bag (grocery bag finger condom) and rub this diamond around the plate. And then I sharpen. I add additional diamond now and then after a few sharpening sessions. I probably use more than I need to, but its cheap.

If using paste, I use about 1/3 cm "worm" of paste and spread it around as described above or if I am feeling lazy I let the chisel do the spreading.

Do not expect to feel any abrasive action from 1 micron diamond. Indeed, the tool does seem to float easily around and it also is sucked to the plate by the surface tension of the lubricant(which is good). If black stuff is generated then its doing what it needs to do. There should be enough lubricant on the plate that the black stuff washes overboard. Only the diamonds stuck in the cast iron are doing any good so don't worry about washing the abrasive away. If the tool is sucked to the plate and hard to move, add more lubricant. If it is sucked to the plate and moves easily, all is well. Black particles of steel will soon appear(finely divided metals are always black)

Re: How best to groove CI?

#12

.25 waste of time unless you are ...

Bill Tindall

entering planing contests.

Re: How best to groove CI?

#13

My experience with grooving & lubricants

Steve Elliott

I bought a diamond sharpening kit from Harris Tools some years ago which came with one cast iron plate grooved in a diamond pattern and another plate with no grooves. After trying out the grooved plate and seeing how much stuff ended up caught in the grooves, I retired that plate. The ungrooved plate has worked pretty well for both bevels and backs.

Recently I did some major back-flattening on CPM 3V using a 5 x 24" cast iron plate and 60 micron diamond paste. Using my usual lubricant (mineral spirits) the blade was sort of grabby but still easier to move than on an 8000x Shapton stone. I tried WD-40 and its lubrication properties reduced the grabbiness considerably. I did use a block of wood attached to the blade with double-stick tape to give myself something easy to hold the blade with, but didn't have any problems that would lead me to groove the plate.

Before giving up on the Shapton I tried grooving one side and that solved the stiction problem. When honing a narrow blade on a grooved surface there are lots of corners that can catch the bevel edge of a narrow blade so I'd use grooves only for work on the back of a blade.

I agree with Bill that .25 micron diamond is finer than necessary, possibly even for planing contests. The main issue is decreased speed. I like 1 micron for most purposes and 1/2 micron for that extra bit of sharpness when I'm in a less-than-reasonable mood.

Re: How best to groove CI?

#14

sage advice

Bill Tindall

Steve has sharpened and studied sharpening more than the sum of us will do in a life time. He also has a practical inclination. What ever Steve does is the best place to start and few will have reason to ever deviate as they gain experience.

Re: How best to groove CI?

#15

My understanding ...

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

and note please that I am learning as well, so no expert here - is that you are confusing working with loose grit, such as silicon carbide, and captured diamond grit (in a paste).

The loose grit rolls around and, so doing, will wear both the substratum and the surface to be lapped. Trapping it in a groove prevents it from rolling around and wearing the substratum.

Diamond (whether in paste form or loose), unlike silicon carbide, will bed into the substratum and stop moving. Because it lies above the surface it will cut anything that runs over the top of its sharp edges. The substratum is not affected. Consequently (as I understand), the hardness of the substratum is not important - some report good use of copper and polycarbinate sheets (I think that jewellers use this) in place of cast iron. The ideal substratum is something that is soft enough to bed the diamonds but hard enough not to let them bed too deeply.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: How best to groove CI?

#16

Hi Steve ...

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

... what's your choice of grits?

I have plates with 40, 10 and .5 microns. My concern is the jump between these - seems OK to me, but I may be needing to fine tune it.

Incidentally, try the Shaptons with a little soapy water - no more stiction.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: How best to groove CI?

#17

Re: sage advice

anotherBob

Thanks for your patience and advice guys, I appreciate it.

Woke up this morning to a memory of reading something at one of the "machinist type forums" from when I was in "research mode". Technique... of physically honing on a lapping plate. They said to place the object on the plate, move it across the abrasive, lift the object, repeat till done. Up to now, I've moved the iron in circles, figure 8's, trying to avoid having the corners dig in. I'll try it tonight when I get back and if any success... will report.

Again, thanks all for your time...

Re: How best to groove CI?

#18

David Barnett

Scoring versus grooving  *LINK*

David Barnett

You're on track, Derek. One thing, sometimes loose grit is less messy than paste, sometimes far more, depending on use. For sharpening, though, paste is usually preferred.

One should perhaps draw a distinction between scoring and grooving. Although Cecil Pierce rightly refers to a single shallow pass with a pointed object as scoring, he spaces his scores at 3/8", which is not the scoring often seen on laps for finer diamond pastes in the 14,000 grit and above range. That scoring often resemble a badly and erratically scratch 78-rpm record, similar to the link in a previous reply to this thread.

Pierce used 8,000 grit, and while this may have offered an advantage, it's lost on me for sharpening bevels. On rotary laps, even slowly rotating horizontal laps, scoring has long been used for the finer abrasive grits used in gem polishing, especially on flat laps used for faceting.This does make a difference, although it's variable from gem species to species. I have not, however, detected an advantage for sharpening steel blade bevels.

The wider grooves as seen on diaper patterned laps are for swarf, stiction and particle control, especially when using larger particles, as you've mentioned. When lapping with loose diamond, the particles actually embed into the cast iron, which presents them for further fracturing and embedding. The wider grooves are intended to reduce stiction due to the greater surface area of chisel and plane blade backs and do little to benefit bevels, especially microbevels, and can be counterproductive when sharpening narrow chisels and instruments.

Scoring, that is, very fine cuts into the substrate are useful for for presentation and but less so for swarf removal when using either loose or paste diamond. Paste diamond is generally a convenience on flat laps used with hand technique. On rotary laps and points (shaped laps resembling burrs) the medium is more important to give the substrate time to accept and present the diamond (of course, one could look at it from the diamond's point of view). Captive diamond grit is a goal of substrate and medium for gem carvers and faceters alike. It is probably more useful to think of the scoring laps for fine mesh diamond as 'texturing'.

The deeply grooved laps are largely a holdout from the pre-diamond days of specimen preparation, mirror grinding (pitch laps), machine tuning, and so on.

"The ideal substratum is something that is soft enough to bed the diamonds but hard enough not to let them bed too deeply."

Also, not to disintegrate too rapidly, such as when wood, wax, pitch, and other softer substrates are employed, which can be a problem when pointy things (greater sectional density) are carved and cut with diamond.

I've never used the word 'captured' to mean diamond in media, although it makes sense, as there is a blending of substrate and medium when one is lapping with waxes, resins, and so on. Usually captured refers to the grit being held by the substrate.

Speaking of captured, I'm experimenting with a rather soft, I suppose one may say 'sticky' 45% lead crystal substrate and getting very promising results, especially with coarser diamond. The slabs are simply the glass ground flat -- no cast-in diamond grit -- and are used just a cast iron laps. Easy to make, far prettier colors than cast iron, by the way, and doesn't rust.


Veritas lapping plate (wide grooves, wide spacing)

Re: How best to groove CI?

#19

technique

Bill Tindall

For backs I use a push pull straight line motion. For bevels I only pull toward me-lift, move the tool forward, seat and pull.

Re: How best to groove CI?

#20

grit choice

Bill Tindall

Guiding principals: 1 micron diamond is sufficiently small for practical woodworking final edge refinement. 1 micron diamond will rapidly remove the scratch pattern of any abrasive that proceeds it if the edge is hollow ground.

Hence, the best strategy is to remove the "dead edge" from a dull tool by any efficient means available that will leave a straight edge for the final edge refinement on 1 micron. I use a "fine" or "extra fine" fixed diamond plate or a grinding wheel to remove the bulk of the metal followed by the fixed plate to ensure the edge is straight. If I have ground the edge sufficiently straight I can go to the 1 micron right off the wheel. In practice I mostly use the wheel to reestablish the hollow grind and the fixed plate to remove the bulk of the metal from the dull edge and thereby establish the wire edge.

Personally I regard loose diamonds on cast iron as a final edge refinement technique. For coarser grits I think fixed diamond plates are more advantageous.

Re: How best to groove CI?

#21

Re: Hi Steve ...

Steve Elliott

Hi Derek,

My sharpening kit consists of a 5/16" thick cast iron plate with one side dedicated to 3 micron diamond and the other side to 1 micron or finer. I've stamped a small "1" and "3" into the surfaces just to make sure I never confuse them.

If I've done an accurate job of grinding an edge I go straight to honing on 1 micron. To renew an edge without grinding I use 3 micron at a lower angle to remove the worn edge, then go to 1 micron at the usual angle.

For major back flattening I have the 5 x 24" Blanchard ground plate that I use with 60 micron. I found no problem going from 60 micron to 3 micron on the 3V back I flattened, after which I put a very small back bevel on the edge with one micron.

I haven't done a systematic study of grits for back flattening--just chose the coarsest grit I owned and went with it. I have some 30, 15 and 9 micron syringes that I haven't used for years.

My standard technique is to flatten the back of a new plane blade but not to polish it to a mirror shine. Right at the cutting edge I use a finely-honed 2-1/2 degree back bevel that I keep very narrow so that it can be removed easily by grinding the bevel in case I ever want to. This is for bevel-down planes. For a low angle bevel-up plane I probably wouldn't want to reduce the clearance angle by using a back bevel. That's one of the reasons I like bevel-down planes.

When it comes to grit choice I'm happy to report what I use but don't consider my experience to be great enough to make authoritative recommendations. The fact that I only use three grits is due to the three cast iron surfaces I mentioned.

Thanks for the recommendation on Shapton stones. I still like my 15,000x Shapton better for Japanese chisels and it doesn�t seem to have nearly the stiction problems the 8000x stone had.