New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Good Hope Hardwoods - Walnut Slabs & Specialty Hardwood Lumber

OT - Printer suggestions

Posts

OT - Printer suggestions

#1

OT - Printer suggestions

Joe Grittani

I don't like to rant but sometimes...

I had an Epson printer quit on me two years ago. I was told I had an ink problem so I bought color and black cartridges for $56 and guess what. It still didn't work and I was out another $56! I was tired of the high cost of ink and lack of dependability, so I went out and bought an HP Photosmart C4480 printer. Ink was reasonably priced and print quality was good, so I was happy. Today I started getting messages telling me I had "incompatible ink cartridge(s)" five minutes after I finished printing a document, although they're the same HP cartridges I've been printing with for months. I went to HPs Customer Support site and numerous people have had exactly the same issue with the same printer and get nothing but the run around from HP. None of the suggested fixes change anything. Still the same error message.

So I guess I'm looking for a new printer. I don't print a lot - mostly B&W text with an occasional color photo on plain paper (so I'm not looking for perfect photo reproduction). I'd like something reasonably priced, with ink I don't need a bank loan to replace, that's reliable. I don't print a ream of paper a year, so I'm a fairly light user.

I'd appreciate any suggestions anyone might have, although I'm beginning to suspect the printer of my dreams only exists in the same realm as unicorns and $20 Panther saws.

TIA.

Joe Grittani

Re: OT - Printer suggestions

#2

Re: OT - Printer suggestions

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

I'd go with a color laser printer. Although I'm very satisfied with my Canon Pixma, never could beat a Laserwriter for cost, quality, and speed. Think I still have one boxed up somewhere, but the old ones don't do color.

Pam

Re: OT - Printer suggestions

#3

Re: OT - Printer suggestions

Paul M.

I'm pretty sure this is planned obsolescence meeting the Polaroid business model.

Planned obsolescence: If these crappy printers die every 2 years (typical), then they have to sell lots of printers.

Polaroid business model: Sell the device really cheap. It's the medium (in this case ink) where they make all the money.

These two go together. As you have cartridge issues, you need to buy more cartridges which are the moneymakers. Then you get mad and have to buy a different printer. Surprise, you need to buy different cartridges because the old ones won't work on the new printer.

It truly isn't in HPs best interests that you are a happy customer, as you will be back with HP after you dump the next Epson/Cannon/whatever.

Good Luck! It doesn't matter what make or model you buy. You'll be back to this same happy place in 2-3 years!

Re: OT - Printer suggestions

#4

Re: OT - Printer suggestions

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Just because that's the model the vendors use doesn't mean you have to play the same way. For example, there are plenty of cartridges containing cheap ink.

However, I still say a laser printer is relatively cheap, reliable, and prints high quality documents very quickly. The only reason I use an inkjet is for photos, nothing else.

Pam

Re: OT - Printer suggestions

#5

Agree with Pam, with one caveat

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

Very happy with my color laser (Brother HL-4040CDN), but when it came time to replace the toner cartridges the best price I could find was $325 (and I shopped a lot). I paid $199 for the printer... Granted, it was on sale 50% off, still...

What to look for:

- price of consumables as mentioned above (even better, look for a model that has re-filled cartridges available)

- compatibility (make sure your operating system is supported). Windoze and MacOS should be no problem, but older versions of Windows, Linux and FreeBSD may not be supported. In the case of Linux, Brother and HP are supported.

Good luck!

DC

Re: OT - Printer suggestions

#6

Re: Agree with Pam, with one caveat

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Yeah, it may turn out to be more cost effective to stick with a B&W laser for all those plain old documents and have a color inkjet on hand for just the color stuff.

Pam

Re: OT - Printer suggestions

#7

Problem with that, IME...

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

If you don't use your inkjet regularly, the ink tends to "dry" (or the nozzles do), screwing up image quality. I know it's not as bad as it used to be, but still... My HP 5650 was pretty good for that, prior to that the Epson 400 and 640 were terrible, especially if left turned on (they were used as the home network printer, attached to the router). My new Brother inkjet multifunction has yet to be tested, but consumables are really inexpensive.

Also, inkjet ink is water-soluble (at least all the brands I've tried), so the printed pictures need to be protected from water. But they provide better quality photo prints.

If I play with the parameters of my color laser and use special paper, I get pretty close to the inkjet quality, which is good enough for me.

DC

Re: OT - Printer suggestions

#8

Re: Problem with that, IME...

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

With my Canon, it seems the ink actually does dry up with disuse, not just the nozzles. Weird.

Pam