New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Urban Salvaged Hardwood Slabs, Milled In-House from Rare Trees. Shop Unique Walnut Stock.

making a Holtey plane *LINK*

Posts

making a Holtey plane *LINK*

#1

making a Holtey plane *LINK*

Dan Donaldson

An article about making a Holtey A13


mking an A13

Re: making a Holtey plane *LINK*

#2

Jim in Burlington Ont.

(Message Deleted by Poster)

Jim in River Oaks, Ont.

Re: making a Holtey plane *LINK*

#3

Re: making a Holtey plane

David Weaver

That's karl's intention, I think. To make a tool as perfectly as can be made, without regard to whether a lot of the work is by hand or by machine.

There are other guys who do more work by hand, but I'm not sure when the rubber hits the road if you'd see nearly as much hand work in any of the higher volume high-end planes vs. what you expect.

I think I recall Konrad Sauer mentioning on his blog that he farms out the machine work on his planes, and I don't know why, but I had assumed that he was doing a lot of it by hand.

But Karl does take the cake, of what I've seen, in designing a plane to be made by machine tools with as little distortion as possible on any part of the plane, but without making the plane look like it was designed entirely to be made limiting hand work.

Just a different flavor than the bill carter school of planes (I think bill does everything by hand).

Re: making a Holtey plane *LINK*

#4

If I`m not mistaken...

Bob Hackett

Wayne Anderson makes all his planes by hand with hand tools(files,saws etc) too.

Re: making a Holtey plane *LINK*

#5

Re: If I`m not mistaken...

David Weaver

I forgot about wayne!

Certainly nothing sloppy about any parts of his planes.

I started to lose track of what a lot of the makers do as soon as I figured my marriage will go better if I make my own than it would if I bought them.

There's another maker who makes very attractive planes, Brian something....

... anyone know how much machine work he does?

I know raney used to do his work by hand, and probably still does a lot of it by hand, but there's no way you can do it full time in volume and not start to have issues with your hand and wrists if you're using tool steel. It's a good hidden exercise program, though.

One thing I will give credit to karl for (as Karl gets a lot of abuse in the internet forums from various folks) is that I don't know of any point where he "lost interest and made subpar planes". The stamina to do work at his level is impressive, and there is a LOT of polishing, fitting and finish work done by hand that you don't get as good of a glimpse of in karls blog, but I'm sure the hours are measured well into double digits on a plane for the polish and clean up. Every single one of his planes is photo perfect, and if you ever make a plane and start taking close up pictures of it, you'll find a lot of hours of clean up to do so that the camera doesn't find scratches or dings, etc here or there.

Re: making a Holtey plane *LINK*

#6

craigd

Re: If I`m not mistaken...

craigd

>Wayne Anderson makes all his planes by hand with hand tools ...

I'm pretty sure Wayne uses a mill for some aspects of his [awesome] planes.

I find this hand-tools-only vs machines pretty silly - IMO Bill Carter's planes are just as desirable as Karl's digital ones (such as the 982). Both are superb craftsman, producing superb tools for similar purposes, just using very different methods. And Bill makes a plane faster than Karl (if I read the blogs correctly).

Re: making a Holtey plane *LINK*

#7

Re: making a Holtey plane

TD

"It is remarkable, how much of the process is about machining rather than being made by the skill of the hand."

2 things:

- Isn't that what planes are about? Many hand tools, possibly all of them, have automatic features. But a plane in particular has a fence/sole for alignment and a cutter set for a very accurate specific cut. Planes can be used freely to greater or lessor degrees as can machine tools.

- I didn't look at the Hotley build though I have seen others. I forget how CNC he is etc... Machinist work particularly at the level of manual (hands twiddling hand wheels) machine work is hand skill. Not to mention that some of it is actual hand work like scraping to a finish, or filing. To my way of thinking the most skilled aspect of hand woodworking isn't the actual cutting, it is the finding of tolerances. Almost anyone can run a saw down a line well enough to make dovetails, but what takes the skill is finding the nuance that allows them to fit together. Knowing where the positive and negative space needs to be and getting it there. That is there with machine work. The fine tolerances aren't automatic and accumulate from decisions like what geometry is on the tool, how well it was sharpened, rate of feed, interpreting cutting sounds, etc... Presumably there is some level of automation where everything is automatic, but that gets very expensive.

"As beautiful as these are, they are perfect copies of each other rather than unique tools made by hand. Am I alone in that thought?"

- Probably true except that there is a bit of the woodworker creeping in there, the idea than they are made to be like each other, which is important, but more likely they are made to a design within tolerance. That is where a lot of the impressive bulk of something like a milling machine comes into play. It's just a rotating bit, not more mechanical than plane iron referenced to a sole, but the need to position it in 3d space so a block can be cut to a referenced dimension is different from our practice of normally matching things up and making cuts that reference to the surface of the part. It is a bit like a plane used in conjunction with a bench. The accuracy of the bench top helps reference the cut of the plane and make results more consistent.

- I have always had an appreciation of how wood can make extraordinary machines; planes (both types), cameras, clocks, bows, fly rods, musical instruments, and of course boats. I get excited about wood's extraordinary structural capabilities, and it's ability to hold extreme accuracy. I do not see it as a less accurate or even mechanical material than metal. And I suppose a flip side romance of metal is how many forms and inconsistencies it has. I think the idea of wood as a largely idiosyncratic material that is suited only to crude or highly personal objects is some kind of 60s idea. Wood was pretty much everything at one time. So while there isn't anything wrong with liking the crude, or random uses, I don't really know why we have to somehow see only those as sincere uses of the material. Personally I would prefer to see wood and metal for what they are rather than as projections of some fashionable preference. So if a Hotley plane was a series copy of an identical object, why would that be bad?

- I think people who make a unique object, their style design etc... in series production should be cut a little slack by the legions who are making "unique" copies of someone else's design. Furniture as a field seems more impressed with a completely unique chair design by some architect, done to death in series, than the same old same old windsor with some unique tool marks on it. I am not taking sides. I am just saying there are creativities in different aspects of the job.

Re: making a Holtey plane *LINK*

#8

Thanks!

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond CA

That's a sweet description on the process. Man made or somewhat terminator, it's fascinating.

Thanks!

Re: making a Holtey plane *LINK*

#9

Re: If I`m not mistaken...

anotherBob

Every single one of his planes is photo perfect, and if you ever make a plane and start taking close up pictures of it, you'll find a lot of hours of clean up to do so that the camera doesn't find scratches or dings, etc here or there.

You are not kidding!...

One thing that I haven't been able to find out there ready-made/just use it... a honing guide. I wanted one specifically for use with diamond embedded cast iron, meaning it had to guide/carry the iron without making contact itself. I'm about 90% done with the parts, but the final polish... forget it. Half the idea was to get me a little more familiar with some bugs that I'll probably run into making an infill at some point, so it's been a good learning project on its own. That it ought to do the simple job that it was designed to do very well, I can only hope for now... that it would have a level of polish/precision of a Holtey... I could dream for the day. :)

Re: making a Holtey plane *LINK*

#10

Re: If I`m not mistaken...

Bruce, a MN Galoot

Wayne told me that he does use a mill for some of the work on his planes, mostly the dovetails. He said that part is getting hard on his hands.

Re: making a Holtey plane *LINK*

#11

Re: making a Holtey plane

Rob Lee

Hi Jim -

Karl is an absolute artist in what he does...but you're correct, the emphasis is different from hand work. Just because he uses machinery (and he uses a lot of manually operated machines) doesn't mean that there isn't a tremendous amount of experience, skill, and knowledge that goes into his work. The path he's chosen is no less difficult...

Cheers -

Rob

(pulling for the Habs now...)

Re: making a Holtey plane *LINK*

#12

Re: If I`m not mistaken...

Hank Knight

That would be Brian Buckner from Florida, Tallahassee I think. Much of his work is hand work. Don't forget about Ron Brese. His work is a combination of machine and hand work. Both makers are artists in the true sense of the word.

Re: making a Holtey plane *LINK*

#13

Re: If I`m not mistaken...

wayne anderson

Actually, I use a bandsaw and files for dovetails, but one needs to be very precise with the mouth and bed angle, etc. A mill is a great tool to square up parts and get the geometry right. 90+ percent of my time is spent doing hand work. Perhaps I am easily amused, but I love to file and sand...and I do for hours at a time. The only thing I "farm out" is heat treating and the patterned steel. -w

Re: making a Holtey plane *LINK*

#14

NOW how much would you pay?

Eric in Los Gatos

Re: making a Holtey plane *LINK*

#15

Oops!

Bruce, a MN Galoot

Thanks for clearing that up, Wayne.

Re: making a Holtey plane *LINK*

#16

Re: making a Holtey plane

James Watriss

It took me a few minutes to digest the comment and get to the heart of why it was eating at me. It feels like there's a statement being made that Holtey's maybe just an unskilled operator, and that his planes are somehow just very high end mass production. I could be wrong, and if I am, please forgive me.

Holtey started out his career, and learned about infills by repairing old ones. From there, he took what he learned and applied it to making better ones. I'm sure his skills are not lacking. And certainly his attention to design isn't either.

Sure there's a lot of machining. But it looks to me that it's just a process of bulk removal of waste. His machines do a better and more accurate job of the bulk removal, but the finished pieces are still finished up by hand. There's also a lot of hand work in finishing up the final pieces... piening, filing and polishing chamfers, sanding, polishing. Like so many others, he focuses his hand skills on the final fit and finish, and saves himself the abundant exercise and bodily wear and tear. The handles are roughed out by machine, but their final shape is made by hand. The chamfers are shaped by hand. The careful details are all done by hand, with plenty of skill. Maybe they all look the same to you. But I'd say that the level of attention to final fit and finish, and the attention to detail warrants labeling each piece as individually made.

Re: making a Holtey plane *LINK*

#17

If you build a perfect plane...

Bob Hackett

And then go on to make more perfect planes then I suppose they would all look the same now wouldn`t they? :D

This goes along with the art vs craft,workmanship of certainty vs workmanship of risk and which is more "noble" handwork or machine work discussions. In the end it`s all opinions that really have little impact on the end result.

Re: making a Holtey plane *LINK*

#18

Re: If you build a perfect plane...

TD

One can't entirely escape the discussion. Hotley planes depend on the

existence of a fairly rarified sensibility in the woodworking world: The willingness to buy

something of unparalleled worth by someone, with for the most part, little need and probably

also little skill. It is the woodworking equivalent of the most luxurious/hyper functional kitchen

ever conceived in the hands of the least likely to cook a home meal generation to ever live. So

the value proposition is fairly odd. It seems to be the case that it has

something to do with the perceived preciousness of the object in itself, and should it turn out

that the plane represents an achievement on par with an injection moulded pop bottle (the

incremental worth, the original tooling is probably pretty clever) then you can see how some

might balk.

I don't have a super kitchen, but when I see the current incarnations on TV, I am struck by

how they have huge investments in the most industrial/designer appliances in stainless, yet they

also have rather impractical granite counter tops. I suppose somewhere there is a group who wouldn't be caught dead with the bourgeois granite counter tops. In my case I think the Hotley planes are precious, but my particular preference sees higher value in wooden planes. Everyone has to have their little distinctions.

The workmanship of risk, and workmanship of certainty distinction, has theoretically no bias to

suggest that one is better than the other, though that is immediately disbelieved by most

readers, and they throw in on the side of risk, except possibly if they work for TSA. It isn't

relevant to the distinction either whether risk is more difficult than certainty, or vice versa.

There are many cases where the workmanship of certainty would be more difficult which

ought to fit into the perception of value also. Around our place I always get called on to ice the

cakes. I can make a very pretty end result by holding my hand over the centre point and

making a bunch of incrementally spaced arcs. Workmanship of risk: Go too deep and one

pulls up crumbs, stay too high and the pattern is weak. I am sure a handwriting type expert

could read your life's story out of a cake icing. But whatever it may be, it is not difficult to do.

Some set-ups for the machine are really fairly difficult. Interestingly some of them start with

workmanship of risk. A simple example would be finding dead centre by indicating in. Now

technically that could be dead rigid, and some insanely fancy machine could do it

automatically. But at the shop level with Chinese indicators, or even my mit. there is a lot of

flex and parallax, and backlash, and one has to read it. There is also risk to

the selective turn down of the fixture to get the part on centre and hold it there. So the process

which involves turning on centre and seems automatic, at least until the fitting and tolerances

come into it, can have some underlying finesse/risk.