New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

100+ Wood Species + Full-Shop Services: Lumber, Veneer, Tools & CNC. Everything in One Place.

Hand planing question - when am I done?

Posts

Hand planing question - when am I done?

#1

Hand planing question - when am I done?

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

Hello.

Hope this isn't too newbish of a question...

I am working on a small box made of (what I think is) some very nicely figured maple. I resawed the boards and have pieces that are about 3/8 thick.

I have been hand planing them using my LV BU smoothing plane. I recently bought a 50 degree blade for it and honed it with a very slight camber. It seems to be working exceptionally well. I am getting super thin see-through shaving with no tear out. I am very happy with it in that regard.

I noticed last night while looking at the pieces in raking light there are shiny areas and not so shiny areas. There are no ridges or planing marks though.

I think the shinier areas are areas that are burnished from the sole of the plane. Is that right? Is this normal? Am I done planing? It sure feels nice and smooth.

I guess I am wondering if the shiny vs. non-shiny areas will finish different and what the hand tool experts think. My hope is to go from the plane to finish.

Thank you.

Joe

Re: Hand planing question - when am I done?

#2

Re: Hand planing question - when am I done?

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

The areas might finish differently. I'd take some scraps, plane them trying to get the approximate differences, then finish. That will tell you.

Pam

Re: Hand planing question - when am I done?

#3

Re: Hand planing question - when am I done?

Patrick Gibbons

Sounds to me like you're done but it's done when you say it's done. If it's figured wood there will be grain change and give you the shiny/less shiny phenomenon.

Re: Hand planing question - when am I done?

#4

Re: Hand planing question - when am I done?

TD

Normally a piece will plane smoother when planed with the grain than against it. At a coarse cut the difference can be substantial, but when your plane is working great you may get the result you are currently getting, but a blotchy look at low angle light. You are essentially cutting more with the grain in certain areas than others.

If you had a piece of wood that had run out in one direction only, with a very finely set plane you might be able to plane it smooth in either direction, but it would be shinier with the grain. That is what is probably happening here. On maple you would see this result a lot in curly maple, since the curl effect is the different light properties of undulating grain that has been cut across flat, reveling a changing pattern of grain direction. The same thing happens around quilt, birdseye, knot, crotches, etc...

This is why to some extent the whole idea of a finish plane is a bit of an illusion. It is the plane you finish planing with, but not the plane that finishes the finish. There are relatively few situations where the best planed surface will not benefit from some sanding, but at it's bets it can be reduced to just a few wipes.

So here is the deal, if you figure you want to follow up with a little sandpaper, you may want to plane a little differently than you would if you thought the plane would be the last thing to touch the wood. For instance if you had some radiating grain, you might want to plane out from the center of radiation, because this will cause the smoothest result, but it will also look uneven. If you simply plane in one direction your planing will be more even, but the surface will have been unevenly cut relative to the grain, and that is usually a worse starting point for knocking back with very fine sandpaper. If you are taking gossamer shavings you can try it a number of ways as you approach your final dimension and see which effect gives you the best result.

Re: Hand planing question - when am I done?

#5

Finishing Maple

Steve Elliott

I agree that the difference in sheen on the planed surfaces is probably due to changes in grain direction in the wood itself. So it sounds like you're done planing.

I'd really suggest doing some finish samples to see what gives you the look you're after. Maple yellows with age so in a few years the look will be somewhat different if you just use a clear finish. If you're going to stain, you might want to sand lightly with very fine paper to give the surface some "tooth." Stain will either look blotchy or bring out the figure, which are two ways of describing the same effect. If you don't like it, it's blotchy. Aniline dye will color the wood more evenly but to my eye it looks sort of lifeless. Often dye is used first, then stain.

A glossy finish will bring out the look of depth that is part of the appeal of figured maple. For a good combination of gloss and color, shellac gives great results. There are different colors of it (amber, garnet, etc.) and the gloss it can give set the standard for glossy finishes for centuries.

Re: Hand planing question - when am I done?

#6

Moses Yoder

Re: Hand planing question - when am I done?

Moses Yoder

There are 2 methods to getting wood ready to finish by hand. One is to plane only and live with the consequences, which as you know are not perfect. The other method is to plane it nice and smooth then sand a little bit with something like 220 grit paper. As TD said, you are getting a lot of grain reversals. Chances are you will see this more after it's finished, as the light will reflect differently in one area than the other. If I have nice straight grained wood I usually do a plane only, but with grain reversals and slightly curly areas I usually sand a little before finishing.

Re: Hand planing question - when am I done?

#7

Re: Hand planing question - when am I done?

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Joe, even with your description it is hard to judge the quality of your surface. Like Pam, I think some experimental finishing on scrap would be helpful. Staining and finishing a hand planed surface is rather different from a sanded surface and experience is needed to really take advantage of the fine surface. And you need to find out if these less than shiny areas that you speak of will show as flaws when finished.

So when are you done? It is a well planed surface when it is so lovely that the thought of touching it with sand paper or a scraper makes you ill.

Re: Hand planing question - when am I done?

#8

Re: Hand planing question - when am I done?

TD

Absolutely, and when the client leaves I turn to my assistant and tell him to stroke sand and spray them. :)

Re: Hand planing question - when am I done?

#9

Re: Hand planing question - when am I done?

R.J.Whelan

Joe,

Try this:

Take a hand full of shavings and burnish the surface by rubbing with the shavings. This should even out the areas where you have grain reversal.

If you're going to stain the piece: apply a "spit coat" of blonde shellac before applying stain.

If you aren't going to stain I'd start with the shellac anyway and then sand or scotchbrite before applying the top finish coat(s) of your choice.

When in doubt - test on scrap first.

Good luck with your project ........ rj