Re: I'm confused
David Weaver
Couple of things:
* planes are always bark side out for the sole. For the math inclined, if you look at the rings head on, the second derivative of the function drawing the growth ring would be positive (sorry, couldn't help it).
* One board is all sap (5-6 inches wide) with just a hint of heartwood at the one edge, one is all heart wood, and two are half and half such that a plane made out of them will have to have some of both in it
* This stuff was $6.50 a bd/foot. It's kiln dried, so it shouldn't move much unless I get it wet.
* you are correct, wear is the only thing I'm concerned about, but there's really no reason for a hobbyist to be concerned about wear in moulding planes, which is why I kind of hedged my statement above. With good treatment, the sole of the moulding plane will get a bit burnished, anyway. Cherry has worked fine so far, I don't see appreciable wear on the sole of my cherry moulders, and beech sap has to be at least as hard, because the cherry I got has wide growth rings and is not dense (dead quartersawn cherry wasn't that easy to find either).
* i have some hard maple. Good quartered (and I mean dead quartered) hard maple is about $10-12 a board foot delivered to me unless I drive to NY to get it. then it's $9 a board foot there, and effectively It's kind of tough and for some reason to me, stuff made out of maple has a manufactured look.
* beech is about the same hardness as hard maple (at least the heart from what I can tell) but yields to chisels, planes and floats a lot easier. Hard maple has a "waxy" feel on the end grain with floats, etc.
* the guy I got the beech from (woodnet post seller) did a good job with it, and picked widths that would work well for moulding planes per my request.
So far for moulding planes, I have amassed way more than I need (and used only cherry and hard maple for planes), including (all QS):
* euro pear
* cherry
* hard maple
* black birch
* beech
* some QS sycamore
* apple (that was a bear to find)
I'm not so sure what I have is black birch, though it was sold to me as such green. Once it dried, it's lighter than I thought it would be, but it doesn't look like white or yellow birch.
By the time I get through all of my planes (replacing them with house made planes), I will have just about used the above. I didn't really need the beech, I just got it because it popped up - after two or three years of looking for wood without having to take flatsawn stuff with the quartered, or dry it on my own, I finally ran into it when I really no longer need it.