New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Fast and affordable laser cutting – so you can make the parts you can’t find anywhere else

Beech for Planes - Sapwood matter?

Posts

Beech for Planes - Sapwood matter?

#1

Beech for Planes - Sapwood matter?

David Weaver

Finally got some beech last week.

It's a mix of heart and sap, dead quartersawn.

Question for folks who have made moulding planes out of beech - does it matter if the plane is a mix of heartwood and sapwood (inevitably, the sapwood will be on the sole of the moulding plane).

Given that I've made planes with cherry and have been fairly happy with the cherry planes, I can't imagine if the beech sapwood is any softer than the heartwood, that it would be any softer than cherry, so I'm going to use it as it is anyway, but just curious.

I'm not going to get an idea of how much softer the heartwood is until I work it or weigh a board of it. One of the boards that I have is about 95% sapwood, so I should be able to get a good idea of density. It does feel a little lighter than the hardwood, but it's not exactly lightweight like pine or anything.

Re: Beech for Planes - Sapwood matter?

#2

Re: Beech for Planes - Sapwood matter?

David Weaver

Well, I've gotten one answer already, not from here, though.

That answer was from someone who has made a lot of planes, that they only used the sap and not the heart when he was making planes.

Re: Beech for Planes - Sapwood matter?

#3

Re: Beech for Planes - Sapwood matter?

Bob Hackett

I would think any problems would come from mixing both sap and heart wood in the same piece. I don`t have a ton of experience with Beech but all my problems with other woods have been when I mixed sap and heart,then distortion or cracking became a problem. All the beech tools I`ve made were of heart wood.

Re: Beech for Planes - Sapwood matter?

#4

Re: Beech for Planes - Sapwood matter?

TomD

I am planing on using mostly heartwood, myself. I found the sapwood cracked easily, though that may just be that it was the outermost layer when I cut the wood, or split it. Also my beech tree was pretty big, but it did not have a thick layer of sapwood. Beech planes always seem to me to be slightly brown, but most of what I have to base it on are pretty old and dirty planes. Also a lot of planes came from Europe, and were made of European beech. I'd love to hear the straight dope from Larry, both on the best part of the log to use, and the differences between the beeches.

I checked my German planes and they look to be all heartwood.

Re: Beech for Planes - Sapwood matter?

#5

I'm confused

Bill Tindall

If the wood is indeed quartered it would have had to have been a huge and exceptionally fast growing tree to not have heartwood on one edge. If hardness, I presume it is wear resistance you are really concerned with, is the issue then just make the heartwood edge the sole. It would matter not the rest of the wood.

However, american beech is not a stable wood and the concern I would have is whether the heart wood and sap wood would respond to moisture changes equally and if not, would the plane be stable. I have read that plane makers of the day boiled the beech. I have no idea of this practice was indeed practiced, but it would have the effect of rendering the beech more stable by removing lignin.

It seems to me that for the amount of planing most people do now days that a maple plane would be equivalent and the wood more readily available.

Re: Beech for Planes - Sapwood matter?

#6

Re: I'm confused

Bob Hackett

Birch was also used as a plane wood on this side of the pond before beech took over completely.

Re: Beech for Planes - Sapwood matter?

#7

Re: I'm confused

David Weaver

Couple of things:

* planes are always bark side out for the sole. For the math inclined, if you look at the rings head on, the second derivative of the function drawing the growth ring would be positive (sorry, couldn't help it).

* One board is all sap (5-6 inches wide) with just a hint of heartwood at the one edge, one is all heart wood, and two are half and half such that a plane made out of them will have to have some of both in it

* This stuff was $6.50 a bd/foot. It's kiln dried, so it shouldn't move much unless I get it wet.

* you are correct, wear is the only thing I'm concerned about, but there's really no reason for a hobbyist to be concerned about wear in moulding planes, which is why I kind of hedged my statement above. With good treatment, the sole of the moulding plane will get a bit burnished, anyway. Cherry has worked fine so far, I don't see appreciable wear on the sole of my cherry moulders, and beech sap has to be at least as hard, because the cherry I got has wide growth rings and is not dense (dead quartersawn cherry wasn't that easy to find either).

* i have some hard maple. Good quartered (and I mean dead quartered) hard maple is about $10-12 a board foot delivered to me unless I drive to NY to get it. then it's $9 a board foot there, and effectively It's kind of tough and for some reason to me, stuff made out of maple has a manufactured look.

* beech is about the same hardness as hard maple (at least the heart from what I can tell) but yields to chisels, planes and floats a lot easier. Hard maple has a "waxy" feel on the end grain with floats, etc.

* the guy I got the beech from (woodnet post seller) did a good job with it, and picked widths that would work well for moulding planes per my request.

So far for moulding planes, I have amassed way more than I need (and used only cherry and hard maple for planes), including (all QS):

* euro pear

* cherry

* hard maple

* black birch

* beech

* some QS sycamore

* apple (that was a bear to find)

I'm not so sure what I have is black birch, though it was sold to me as such green. Once it dried, it's lighter than I thought it would be, but it doesn't look like white or yellow birch.

By the time I get through all of my planes (replacing them with house made planes), I will have just about used the above. I didn't really need the beech, I just got it because it popped up - after two or three years of looking for wood without having to take flatsawn stuff with the quartered, or dry it on my own, I finally ran into it when I really no longer need it.

Re: Beech for Planes - Sapwood matter?

#8

Re: I'm confused

TomD

That is what I am saying in part. My stuff comes from a good sized tree, and you couldn't get a plane out of the sap wood.

I have made planes out of beech and maple, and I prefer the maple, but it isn't all that significant either way. I trust that the early reason for using beech is correct, even if I can't tell in use, not yet anyway. I do prefer beech for Japanese planes (as between it an maple). The beech is both more plastic, and less prone to splitting across the grain, or at least as a percentage of properties. Maple is a nicer wood and harder.

But here is an article that makes the case for beech over other woods:

http://www.planemaker.com/articles_beech.html

Re: Beech for Planes - Sapwood matter?

#9

Re: I'm confused

David Weaver

All of the lit that I've seen said stuff like "thin band of sapwood", too. No clue how large the trees were, and don't know much about beech in terms of how it grows differently in open areas vs whatever else. I have no live edge, so in the bigger boards that are all sap, the tree in question definitely had 5 inches of sap at least, plus whatever else was on the outside.

One of the WPINCA books, or maybe it was another NY plane maker book had some verbiage in it that said to choose wood close to the bark for hardness.

For japanese planes, did you orient the beech dead quartered? If so, how has the mouth of the plane held up?

Re: Beech for Planes - Sapwood matter?

#10

Stephen Shepherd

Re: I'm confused

Stephen Shepherd

The beech was boiled to change the color, turns it pink. Lignin is not water soluble, but has fatty acids that permanently harden when heated above 185� F.

Stephen

Re: Beech for Planes - Sapwood matter?

#11

I would imagine

John in NM

That those changes to the lignin also tend to change the reaction to moisture?

I wonder if the oft cited figures for radial vs. tangential changes are pre or post heating, boiling, steaming, etc.

Re: Beech for Planes - Sapwood matter?

#12

I suspect...

John in NM

Beech was traditionally used for tools because it was relatively cheap compared to other hardwoods.

I've also heard that it was always used sap side-down because of some hocus pocus, harder that way mumbo jumbo. My theory is that it is a matter of practicality. Large molders are wider at the sole, and of course a riven blank is wider at the outside of the tree. Personally, I'd put the sap at the top as in most species it tends to be softer than heartwood.

I would not be especially concerned about movement, for a couple reasons. First, there is no shortage whatever of items made of beech, including planes. The stuff appears to work fine. I would not build a large table top or paneled case out of the stuff, but small items are fine. Second, as I alluded to in my response to Stephen's post, I suspect strongly that those shrinkage figures are for green, un-treated wood. I've never seen any wood shrink on a scale so often quoted on the internet, not when it's going from 15% to >5%. When going from green to >20%, yes, then I've seen those huge changes.

Re: Beech for Planes - Sapwood matter?

#13

Re: I'm confused

TomD

I didn't. I oriented it so that it was riffed diagonal, with the outside on the sole, which is traditional Japanese practice. I think grain orientation is one of those things where there may well be a best way, but i built a lot of planes without the proper grain orientation, due to using boards, and I have probably done just about everything wrong or right. Also, the mouth of a Japanese plane is closed parallel to either the blade or the breaker, in either case the chance of breaking out is reduced.

Re: Beech for Planes - Sapwood matter?

#14

Re: I'm confused

David Weaver

I agree that orientation doesn't matter that much, especially for a plane that is going to be used at least a couple of times each year. Even if it did move, it won't get that far out.

I have a user-made plane that has the wood in it upside down, and several planes that are rift sawn (and that's how I oriented my first "big" infill). None of them have caused me trouble, just curious because all of my beech is 8/4, and I was thinking maybe I'd use hard maple instead (i have two irons that need a dai), which is also dead quartersawn. I don't have anything thicker rift on hand.

I only have a minor concern of mouth wear since the quartered side will be the fastest wearing orientation, but it's about as minor as it gets because if it wears a little faster, I can just make another one.

Re: Beech for Planes - Sapwood matter?

#15

Re: I'm confused

TomD

I haven't liked the maple dais I made, it semed brittle in blade retention. But they were also earlier planes that were not as well made. I prefer white oak, and beech. I hear live oak would be suitable. I would buy Japanese blocks if I could get them. I only ever wore down one dai, and I just laminated the sole with about 4mm of the same wood in the block, white oak. It took outright abuse to put that wear on.

Do you not want to use the 8/4" wood so as not to waste such nice thick blocks?

Re: Beech for Planes - Sapwood matter?

#16

Re: I would imagine

TomD

I don't think heating affects the moisture change. Almost all kiln dried wood will have been fixed, and yet it gives all the problems with stuff like sticky drawers etc... that one hears about in the literature.

Re: Beech for Planes - Sapwood matter?

#17

Re: I suspect...

TomD

"Beech was traditionally used for tools because it was relatively cheap compared to other hardwoods."

I doubt that except that at some level one can always reduce things to price. In america they were presumably burning continents of wood just to clear the land. Also there is that whole thing about how virgin growth timbers were often polar opposites of what they are today. There were woods assigned for war production. So as you say economics are part of it, but then there were also criteria and a depth of knowledge we don't have. If ebony were the best wood, it would presumably have been very expensive to bring to the US by sail. But a lot of the other stuff was called "lumber", kinda along the same run of country as "garbage".

"I've also heard that it was always used sap side-down because of some hocus pocus, harder thatway mumbo jumbo. My theory is that it is a matter of practicality. Large molders are wider at the sole, and of course a riven blank is wider at the outside of the tree. Personally, I'd put the sap at the top as in most species it tends to be softer than heartwood."

The rings are also straighter in the outer wood. which means that area is more stable.

Re: Beech for Planes - Sapwood matter?

#18

Adding heat

Bob Hackett

I can tell you that boiling bowl blanks both makes them dry faster and reduces loss due to checking. I noticed the boiled blanks didn`t show as much seasonal change due to distortion either.Boiling did change the color though.

Anyone who has built boats that have enough shape to them that steaming was required to get the planks in place will also tell you it changes how the wood reacts to moisture. Old hands used to say "The steam calms the wood down".

All the wood I`m talking about here has been air dried,try any of this with kiln dried and all bets are off. There`s no tellin` what that stuff will do. :)