New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A55 Smoothing Plane

LV BU Smoother blade question

Posts

LV BU Smoother blade question

#1

LV BU Smoother blade question

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

Hello,

I am getting ready to use some curly maple with lots of curl.

I was thinking about getting a 50 degree A2 blade for it to smooth this maple opposed to the stock 38 degree blade.

Not being huge hand tool guy, and not having a lot of plane knowledge, I am wondering if this would be good or just stick with the 38?

Thank you.

Re: LV BU Smoother blade question

#2

Re: LV BU Smoother blade question

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Joe

In my experience planing woods with interlocked grain, there is a WORLD of difference in the minimising of tearout using high cutting angles of 60 degrees and above in comparison to a york pitch (50 degrees). In the BUS the extra angle makes hardly any difference with pushing as the shaving is fine. Also, wax the sole of the plane and it will just glide through the wood.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: LV BU Smoother blade question

#3

Re: LV BU Smoother blade question

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

Thanks Derek.

I just ordered one. It's on back order but I won't need it for a few days anyway.

Joe

Re: LV BU Smoother blade question

#4

Re: LV BU Smoother blade question

Brian Greene

Joe,

The 38 degree blade may be able to handle the curley maple, but the 50 degree blade is good insurance, along the lines of Derek Cohen's suggestions.

Having said that, I have planed bird's eye maple very successfully with the 38 degree blade in the BU smoother. The 50 more or less guarantees success but it is more difficult to sharpen and to push!

I note that you are a beginner with hand tools. My experience is that sharpening makes the difference. On a recent sample piece of BE Maple about 5 x 24" I can recall that I touched up the blade for each side of the board, say after a dozen strokes. You will need to be able to make your blades exceptionally sharp to handle highly figured woods with confidence.

I hope this helps. Good luck.

Re: LV BU Smoother blade question

#5

Re: LV BU Smoother blade question

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

Thanks for the info Brian.

Although not an expert at sharpening, I've gotten better at it. This will be my first experience with this angle of blade though.

Any tips anybody wants to offer regarding touching up this blade when I receive it will be gladly excepted.

Thanks again,

Joe

Re: LV BU Smoother blade question

#6

Re: LV BU Smoother blade question

Brian Greene

Joe,

The blade as you receive it will have the appearance of being sharp but it isn't as good as it could be or needs to be for figured wood. I would polish the back some on an 8000 water stone, and hone the bevel, also at 8000. When setting up a new blade, I will sometimes go back to 4000 as the starting point.

Re: LV BU Smoother blade question

#7

Can and will do.  Thanks!

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

Re: LV BU Smoother blade question

#8

Re: LV BU Smoother blade question

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

The 50 more or less guarantees success but it is more difficult to sharpen and to push!

Hi Brian

Actually there is no different in difficulty when honing a BU blade at any angle ... if you are using a honing guide. The rule I recommended some years ago was to only use a primary bevel of 25 degrees plus a secondary microbevel (of the desired bevel angle) if you plan to add a camber to the blade. While I freehand BD plane blades, I use a honing guide for BU blades.

The fact is that you will struggle to camber a BU blade with a high primary bevel angle. A link to my article on this:

http://www.inthewoodshop.com/WoodworkTechniques/TheSecretToCamberinBUPlaneBlades.html

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: LV BU Smoother blade question

#9

Re: LV BU Smoother blade question

Brian Greene

Thanks Derek,

I was actually referring to honing freehand, which I do for all blades. It is difficult to hold the blade at such a steep angle largely because we do it so infrequently that there is no developed 'muscle memory'. You have introduced an additional problem, that of the camber. I typically only camber my smoothing blades enough to lift the corners off the work and that is bloody hard at 50 degrees!! I will read your article with great interest!

Cheers from Ottawa,

Brian

Re: LV BU Smoother blade question

#10

Question...

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

I just received notice this blade shipped. Not sure I need it though because for kicks I touched up the 38 degree blade on my 8000 stone and was getting whisper fine shaving off the curly maple with it. It was cutting like butter. That was fun.

Anyway, when I get the 50 I will touch it up on my 6000 then 8000 stones. My question is, should I tip the blade an additional degree or two so I'm not trying to polish the entire bevel surface? Hope I'm saying that right.

Also, if I understand Derek's article, I should put more pressure on the corners, because I do want a slight crown to it, right?

Thanks for the help everybody.

Joe

Re: LV BU Smoother blade question

#11

Re: Question...

Brian Greene

Joe,

Most people put a micro bevel on blades to make re-sharpening easier. However, the primary bevel on a 50 degree blade is small enough that I'm not sure its worth the extra bother. As Derek suggested, you should put some camber on the relieve the corners.

Good luck and don't hesitate to ask more questions.