New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Compare cordless drills on the numbers that matter

Any 4-H Woodworking Leaders here?

Posts

Any 4-H Woodworking Leaders here?

#1

Any 4-H Woodworking Leaders here?

Ranbir Chawla

Hi everyone, I know it's been many moons since I've posted, I've spent the last few years lurking on and off. My 12 year old daughter has been working with me for a while now in the shop and has decided to do the 4-H woodworking project alongside her usual lamb and cake projects. We're trying to figure out if what type of projects are considered reasonable for the first 2 levels which are hand tools only.

She can cut nice dovetails by hand, but the state folks here said that it's 'impossible to do that without powertools' - sigh... She's thinking of a nice Krenov style plane, but we're wondering if that's enough to be hold the judges interest.

Anyway, comments and suggestions are welcome. Thanks in advance.

Ranbir

Re: Any 4-H Woodworking Leaders here?

#2

Re: Any 4-H Woodworking Leaders here?

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Figure out what else those ignorant, uneducated judges think. Or ignore them.

Pam

Re: Any 4-H Woodworking Leaders here?

#3

Now there's a challenge!

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

A dovetailed box containing a series of photos of her making it by hand?

On a more serious note, you might check out every woodworking book from your local library system (if you're lucky, your system has an online catalog, and you can figure out from home which books to request), and look through them for ideas. Most intro books have a project chapter. And there may be some juvenile woodworking books, which will no doubt focus heavily on hand tool projects.

A footstool might be neat, and useful. Or a sawbench with a shelf underneath to hold tools - kind of a combined toolbox and sawbench.

You could be having lots of fun ahead, deciding with her on what to build, working through the design and planning of the steps to construction, talking her through learning the skills. Sigh. Makes me wish my sons would hurry up and produce grandkids.

Re: Any 4-H Woodworking Leaders here?

#4

Re: Now there's a challenge!

Patrick Gibbons

A good project for her would be a side table. All mortise and tenon joints and looks good when finished.

Re: Any 4-H Woodworking Leaders here?

#5

Re: Any 4-H Woodworking Leaders here?

Dale Stansbery

Unless things have changed a lot over the years, I doubt that they are expecting anything beyond simple butt joinst in a small hand carried tool tray, or things like a 3 piece bench hook.

It doesn't seem like she would gain much by taking the project for a learning experience. In our community, the end goal was to learn, then display the projects at the county fair for judging. If that's her case, maybe she could build the project of her choice and enter it in the open adult competition and blow their socks off.

Re: Any 4-H Woodworking Leaders here?

#6

Re: Any 4-H Woodworking Leaders here?

Ranbir Chawla

Thanks everyone for your support :-).

First decision she made was to skip level one and start @ the next level, which was 'okay' by the extension agent. As Dale said, the project is about learning, so I asked her to find something that would be different than what she's done in the past. And explained that it should be something she can keep for herself long term.

So what we decided to do was to make the nice krenov type planes, she'll make 2-3 bodies and use one iron and then she's going to make a nice carrying box for them using simple rabbet joints made with a cross cut saw and cleaned up with a plane. For the slide off top she's going to make it a small shooting board/bench hook. She's not done alot of precision miter planing or filing, so doing the final angles and filing the mouth will be new, as well as learning to use a wood plane vs. the LN Bedrocks she uses now, so new skills there too.

She's also going to document the 4 dovetailed window boxes she's making for the barn out of poplar and include all the pictures in her record book before she paints them and installs them.

And I think there might be a cool little project for the 'Open' competition for State Fair where she goes all out, but that might depend on how other kids stuff goes.

Thanks again for the support. I'll post pictures as we go along.

Re: Any 4-H Woodworking Leaders here?

#7

Re: Any 4-H Woodworking Leaders here?

glh17

I'm not sure about those judges. I find it hard to believe that any woodworker or anyone who know anything about furniture would believe dovetails had to be cut with power tools.

Re: Any 4-H Woodworking Leaders here?

#8

Re: Any 4-H Woodworking Leaders here?

Ranbir Chawla

You know it's interesting, my lovely wife tried to push back a bit, and the final info she just got back today was the head guys said you couldn't cut the dovetails at all till you flatten the board with a Jointer - which is a power tool not allowed yet... She the took the time to explain the following:

#1 - Jointers only flatten one side

#2 - DT's really need 2 flattened sides to be cut easily - so in 'theory' she'd need the planner as well

#3 - HANDPLANES can flatten both sides just fine

To top it off she texted him a picture of our 3 plank dining room table all done with hand planes.

I only mention this to say that I'm am officially at this very moment the luckiest man on the planet! :-)

I've just made reservations @ her fav restaurant, I think a nice date is in order!

Re: Any 4-H Woodworking Leaders here?

#9

Re: Any 4-H Woodworking Leaders here?

glh17

I agree. Sounds like you have daughter to be proud of. I still don't understand the judge's reasoning. Arguably, hand-cut dovetails are the pinnacle of hand tool work.

Re: Any 4-H Woodworking Leaders here?

#10

Alas...

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

my father, whom I loved and respected, and who built an addition to our house as large as the original house (doubling the size, in other words) AND such intricate delights as a rack and pinion latchset with wooden spring for the house-to-basement door when he couldn't find a suitable commercial latchset, could not believe that I could fix the sticking door in the dining room with a handplane. Took me more time to adjust it than to do it, of course; and he was suitably impressed.

There's a whole world of power-tool users who have...no...idea. Where they think Hepplewhite and Sheraton bought their plunge routers and bandsaws, I'm not sure.

Re: Any 4-H Woodworking Leaders here?

#11

There were always water powered tools.

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX