New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

200+ woodworking book reviews

Chisel hoop material opinions?

Posts

Chisel hoop material opinions?

#1

Chisel hoop material opinions?

Paul Erickson

I have some chisel handles to make, and while most of them are for paring chisels, some of them, such as my corner chisel will be pounded with mallets (not hammers obviously) and I am wondering what material I should use for the hoops. I have seen copper, brass and steel used. I understand that steel would be more durable, but copper and brass would be easier to work. I don't expect to be abusing them, so wonder if copper would be strong enough, or will coppers elasticity cause me problems in the long run. Anyone have any experience with different materials, good or bad which might help with my choice?

Thanks in advance.

cheers, Paul

Re: Chisel hoop material opinions?

#2

Stephen Shepherd

Re: Chisel hoop material opinions?

Stephen Shepherd

'I have some chisel handles to make, and while most of them are for paring chisels, some of them, such as my corner chisel will be pounded with mallets (not hammers obviously) and I am wondering what material I should use for the hoops. I have seen copper, brass and steel used. I understand that steel would be more durable, but copper and brass would be easier to work. I don't expect to be abusing them, so wonder if copper would be strong enough, or will coppers elasticity cause me problems in the long run. Anyone have any experience with different materials, good or bad which might help with my choice? '

You can use anything for a ferrule/hoop, the high end is cow horn/bone/ivory, but I have an old drawknife that has two brass female fittings from a garden hose as its ferrules and a chisel that has one as a hoop on the business end.

If the copper becomes a problem in the future by mushrooming then just throw it in the fire and the spent handle will burn right out.

I like using iron pipe if I can get it, holds up well. The spun sheet brass fittings for air hoses works on light duty applications.

Stephen

Re: Chisel hoop material opinions?

#3

Re: Chisel hoop material opinions?

Paul Erickson

Thanks for the reply. Just to be clear, I an not referring to the ferrule at the chisel end of the handle, but the hoop at the far end away from the chisel.

cheers, Paul

Re: Chisel hoop material opinions?

#4

Re: Chisel hoop material opinions?

Bruce, a MN Galoot

I have to make a new handle for a Berg chisel that got abused big time, and it needs a hoop on the striking end. I'd thought to find a piece of iron pipe, mostly because I can't think of anything else that would do the trick. I'd considered the hoops that belong on Japanese chisels (although they don't look the same) and I guess I'll just have to be creative - that's a stretch for me :) .

Please post whatever you decide.as well as a pic. My project isn't far enough along to consider hoops yet. First, I have to find some Masur birch in dimensions big enough for a 1.5" Berg handle, maybe 1-1/4".

Re: Chisel hoop material opinions?

#5

Re: Chisel hoop material opinions?

TomD

It took some rearrangement of my identity, but I have gone over to using the rubber mallets. Didn't feel right to me, but what sealed it for me was the lower impact on hearing. people don't realize that hammering is in the .22 LR noise range, but much shorter in duration. Still can damage hearing. Also, if you work in a house with other people it is less disruptive to them, though I don't work in the house myself. With these mallets, one doesn't need hoops on chisels, maybe mortise chisels for very heavy work. I just turn my handles out of maple.

Another option if you don't have metal working gear is to bind the end of the handle with some carbon fiber, kevlar, glass, spectra, etc... Look on ebay for 3k or 6k carbon. Then just coat in epoxy.

I use stainless tubing for my hoops, when I make them, but I have all the toys. Copper would certainly work, if you can find the size you want.

Re: Chisel hoop material opinions?

#6

Re: Chisel hoop material opinions?

Bob Hackett

I use slices of brass or bronze pipe,they`re far more kind to the hammer face than iron if you mis-strike and make metal to metal contact when using one of those high dollar steel faced hammers. :)

Re: Chisel hoop material opinions?

#7

Re: Chisel hoop material opinions?

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

people don't realize that hammering is in the .22 LR noise range, but much shorter in duration. Still can damage hearing.

Hi Tom

So true. I am acutely aware of noise damage and sometimes wear hearing protection when I use a steel gennou with my steel hooped Japanese chisels.

The question I ask is "why add hoops to chisels at all?" Just choose the wood for the handle carefully - something hard (of course) but not brittle. Then use a wooden mallet. This is definitely quieter.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Chisel hoop material opinions?

#8

How about one of these? *LINK*

Dan Donaldson

I use one of these and it is nice. Quiet and it does a good job of controlling impact.


mallet

Re: Chisel hoop material opinions?

#9

Got one,love it.

Bob Hackett

Re: Chisel hoop material opinions?

#10

EMT?

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

No, I'm not suggesting you cut up an Emergency Medical Technician.

You might contact local electricians - especially those doing commercial work - and see if they have any scraps of conduit, properly known as Electrical Metallic Tubing (thus the name). This is a thinwall tubing that you could score for cutting with a tubing cutter and then hacksaw to shape (you might even be able to cut it with a tubing cutter, but tubing cutters tend to crimp the tubing, so you'd then have to spend time filing out the crimp and could wind up with a sharp edge). Might be easier to work than pipe. And you could probably pick up remnants for free from their dumpster.

Re: Chisel hoop material opinions?

#11

Re: How about one of these? Bingo

TomD

That's my rubber mallet also, though I guess it is poly. I have a 20 ouncer from LV, and after years of trying to avoid ordering one from outside of the country, Busy Bee started selling the 30 ouncers. I like these carver style mallets so much, I got sucked into buying one of the bronze ones. First hit split off a large hunk of wood from a hooped handle. That was the end of that. As I say, they work great, they aren't noisy and you can use any handle material. Problem solved.

Re: Chisel hoop material opinions?

#12

Re: How about one of these? Bingo

TomD

Another thing I like about those poly mallets is that I can use them on Japanese chisels as they come from the supplier. I don't bother with the hoop setting, which I find sorta uglyfies the chisels. The poly mallets are perfectly happy to hit right on the hoops. This is particularly worthwhile if one fell for something stupid like a set of 15 Macassar ebony handles that don't really set properly anyway. Thank goodness I don't know any boneheads that would do that...

Re: Chisel hoop material opinions?

#13

David Barnett

Or DOM *LINK*

David Barnett

Cheap. A couple feet of 3/4" or 7/8" is less than ten dollars. Hacksaw will do it.


Drawn Over Mandrel steel tubing

Re: Chisel hoop material opinions?

#14

Unfortunately

Bob Hackett

It has been my experience that thin wall hoops can be driven into the end grain of the handle just like a circular splitting wedge.I`ve had the best luck with thicker walls.They`re harder to drive into the wood.

My sons do manage to overcome the added resistance given enough unsupervised time though.

Another Texas saying comes to mind,"Them boys could ruin and anvil with a tack hammer". :(

Re: Chisel hoop material opinions?

#15

  I like this LV mallet, too.

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Re: Chisel hoop material opinions?

#16

Re: How about one of these?

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

I have a similar mallet from GoodWood, and find it too bouncy. Currently, my chisel use is limited to Stanley No. 60s (plastic handle, steel cap, used with a hammer on construction work), but I know I'm going to need to explore mallet choices when I get back to shop work (oh, please, can I?) and wood-handled socket chisels.

Re: Chisel hoop material opinions?

#17

Re: Chisel hoop material opinions?

Paul Erickson

Hi Bruce,

Here is what I ended up doing this time. The handle on the left is the one I made, but I thought the other three (none of which I made) might be of interest to you. The two berg's appear to have steel pipe for the hoops and the one on the far right uses brass. No points for originality on the one I made, but it seems to fit the chisel and my hand well. The size is reminiscent of the Hirsch mortising chisels, but is in fact a bit smaller in diameter than the Hirsch's. I am thinking of making a set of handles for my Berg's similar to Derek's, so if you are interested in a original handle contact me off line, and we might be able to make a deal.


I went with the copper because I had ready access to some, and could easily cut it with tools I have available. Cutting mild steel pipe square was a challenge I didn't want to tackle right now. One other thing, as I'm sure you know, what is pounded on is easily pounded off. When I was banging on the end of the handle to seat it in the chisel socket, the hoop came lose. Others have discussed the issues for setting hoops for Japanese chisels etc. but in this case I cheated and used some CA glue. Will see over time how it holds up. Will be interested in seeing your Berg replacement when you get it done.

cheers, Paul

Re: Chisel hoop material opinions?

#18

Re: Chisel hoop material opinions?

Bruce, a MN Galoot

Can you send me a pic of that handle? My Bergs are tanged chisels, and I'm not sure how that would work, but if it's close, I'd be interested.

Bruce

Re: Chisel hoop material opinions?

#19

Re: Chisel hoop material opinions?

Paul Erickson

Sorry about that, I thought you had a socket version. These would not be of use to you.

cheers, Paul

Re: Chisel hoop material opinions?

#20

Hoop retention

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Some of the thinwall hoops I've seen are encouraged to stay on by being "staked" with a center punch on the side in a couple of places (three would be optimal, roughly evenly spaced around the circumference). The resulting tooth sticking in catches on the wood.

Re: Chisel hoop material opinions?

#21

Re: Chisel hoop material opinions?

TomD

Nice piece of turning there. Good flow. I prefer a handle that tapers in the opposite direction, but you sure did a nice piece of work on that.

Re: Chisel hoop material opinions?

#23

Re: Hoop retention

Bruce, a MN Galoot

And on the Bergs, they take that "punch" one step further and nail it on. E.A. must not have trusted those hoops very much.

Re: Chisel hoop material opinions?

#24

On mallets, hammers and gennou ...

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Dan

The sorbothane (I think that is what it is) face is quite popular. I have not used one, so perhaps you can enlighten me here ...

I do have a hammer that is softish, made by Thor, and used for disciplining the parts of joints until they behave:


I have tried this on chisels, but I really do not like the feel - it lacks the feedback of an unyielding face.

Similarly, I built this hammer for setting planes and blades. One face is brass and the other is ebony:


It also gets used on unhooped chisels and is a delight with regards balance and feedback. However before the ebony was epoxied on it had a layer of polyester (from a cutting board). I really did not like the effect this had, and that is when I replaced it with the ebony.

For Japanese hooped chisels (and a few hooped Woodcock firmers I use for rough work) I turn to a gennou. I have a couple in different weights, but the one I am most likely to use is 375 gm ...


And for OB Mortice chisels I use a round mallet. For years I made my own, but now I have one of Dave's delights:


This, too, has just the right balance, feedback and heft for me.

So, who has compared mallet and hammer types for feedback?

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Chisel hoop material opinions?

#25

Who? ME?

Dominic in Buck's County Pa

:D :D :D