New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A55 Smoothing Plane

Japanese Saw Handles

Posts

Japanese Saw Handles

#1

Japanese Saw Handles

glh17

I apologize if this has been discussed before, but I'm wondering why Japanese saw handles are straight with no hand grip. I suspect that it may be because they are pulled and have thin blades but don't know.

Re: Japanese Saw Handles

#2

Re: Japanese Saw Handles

TomD

I don't know what the answer is, and generally it is hard to get that kind of answer. One thing is the use of two hands, a bit like pulling on a rope. Another is the sword culture. Who can miss the comparison between our handles and pistol handles (though which came first...). There is the idea that Japanese tools were made by displaced sword makers after swords were banned. Though I think I have seen pictures of these handles from earlier times. Still cultural references. Many Japanese tools use simple wooden dowel like handles.

It is however the case that Japanese saws, pulled and used double handed, also come in version with a 45 degreeish pistol grip.

I think that a lot of the time, Japanese saws are not used correctly in the West. People tend to approach wood using out vises, our postures, and our initial points of contact. If you see someone sawing on a piece the are standing on with a rhythmic swing from the shoulder, the angle of the handle seems reasonably ergonomic.

Re: Japanese Saw Handles

#3

Re: Japanese Saw Handles

glh17

I think the approach/poster may be a part of it. I thought I'd read one time that Japanese saws were used in a more vertical position that western saws. If that's the case, the western style grip wouldn't make much sense.

Re: Japanese Saw Handles

#4

Re: Japanese Saw Handles

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

OTOH, the LN straight handled dovetail saw is superb.

Pam

Re: Japanese Saw Handles

#5

Re: Japanese Saw Handles *LINK*

wilbur

I think that the straight handle on a Japanese saw helps is ergonomic, whether you position the board on low horses and stand on in, or if you put it in a vise on a bench. Here's a picture of me with a Japanese saw sawing a board in a vise.


As you can see from the double-headed green arrow, the handle seems just about perfect if I am freely swinging my arm from the shoulder.

I have a more detailed explanation in a post on my blog, linked below.


Japanese and western saw handles

Re: Japanese Saw Handles

#6

Re: Japanese Saw Handles

Dan Donaldson

I have the straight handles saw and the independence style. I much prefer the straight handled one. Not sure exactly why, but I can cut to the line much better with the straight handle.

Re: Japanese Saw Handles

#7

Re: Japanese Saw Handles

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

I used the LN straight handled saw for an afternoon, and found it as fast and accurate as my Japanese saws. It honestly wasn't better, but as good as is a strong endorsement from me.

Pam

Re: Japanese Saw Handles

#8

Re: Japanese Saw Handles

TomD

Yeah, that's the way.

Re: Japanese Saw Handles

#9

Re: Japanese Saw Handles

TomD

There is a long tradition of that kind of thing also. But it's a push saw so to make the same cut the mechanics will be different. I have a Japanese push saw, backsaw, and it works great also. When you consider that archer who can hit the target bent over backwards, and using her feet to fire the bow, it is pretty clear you can do just about anything. Which is part of what makes the question why did they choose what they did interesting, if difficult to know.

I can think of quite a few people who have said they thought my Japanese saws were a frightening looking weapon, which probably has something to do with it.

Re: Japanese Saw Handles

#10

Re: Japanese Saw Handles

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Yes, it is a push saw and I knew it; which is one reason I was so surprised at its performance. And I agree that often we can not discern motivations, nor would the sphere of human activity be more enjoyable if we could. There's so much magic out there this way.

Pam

Re: Japanese Saw Handles

#11

Just think

Dan Donaldson

Just think of what a dull place the world would be if everyone was "normal" (whatever that means) and had exactly the same likes and dislikes. ;)

Re: Japanese Saw Handles

#12

Hold it right there!

Bob Hackett

You gotta stop now cause you`re REALLY scaring me. :O

Re: Japanese Saw Handles

#13

Re: Just think

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

It would certainly be chock full of financial bubbles. :)

Pam

Re: Japanese Saw Handles

#14

Get over it. 

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Re: Japanese Saw Handles

#15

Re: Japanese Saw Handles

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Oh, oh, I do sing the praises of the LN straight handled dovetail saw. I found it to be as fast and easy to use as my dozuki. This was an accident, was in another woodworker's shop when he received it and we had to try it out. I was amazed. Told Thomas LN, too. :)

Pam

Re: Japanese Saw Handles

#16

"...and we had to try it out."

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Powerless before the mighty attraction of a new tool; I sure recognize THAT state of mind.

Re: Japanese Saw Handles

#17

Jack Guzman from Maine

Re: Just think

Jack Guzman from Maine

I hate showin' my ignorance,but what is a financial bubble? Feeling dumber every day.---Jack

Re: Japanese Saw Handles

#18

Financial bubble

Paul M.

It's what happens in the bathtub after eating too many chocolate coins.

Re: Japanese Saw Handles

#19

Think of tulips *LINK*

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

The textbook (in my youth, anyhow) financial bubble was the tulip mania in Holland in the 1600s: insanely inflated prices for a commodity, followed by rapid collapse and serious hits to the economy.

There've been a few other bubbles since then.


http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tulip_mania

Re: Japanese Saw Handles

#20

And, you'll note

Bruce, a MN Galoot

neither of those have to do with bathtubs or chocolate coins :D

Re: Japanese Saw Handles

#21

Re: Just think

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Certainly it's not you showing ignorance, just some faulty assumptions on my part. The main financial bubble causing problems today is the recession resulting from outrageous home prices, aided and abetted by mortgage bankers of various sorts. Kind of like musical chairs in that while the prices keep rising the buyers keep buying until buyers realize the edge they're on and stop buying more. Almost all the chairs are quickly taken away, so when that music stops, a few profit hugely, and many more are toasted. We're living it.

So in the case of everyone having the same goals and motivations, they'd cause financial bubble after financial bubble pursuing the same goods and services that everyone else, all those other same people, want the minute they're informed of said good/service. Then they'd all try to divest at the same time, mostly unsuccessfully. I'd bet goals and motivation would start to split after 3 or 4 of these, or in about a month. :)

Pam