diamond honing - first impressions
Tom Sontag - St. Louis
I have evolved over the years to using Shaptons (1000, 3000, 8000) for my honing. They work fine for me. I read the posts here about diamond honing and said to myself "I don't need it, but I wish I knew about this way back when."
Meanwhile, a nephew approaches me with an interest in woodworking. We spend a day in my shop and I figure sharpening and honing is one of the first demos. I show him how I approach a number of tasks, but add that if I were him I would look into diamond honing, since it is allegedly cheaper and faster. I help him select 3 grits (sorry, "meshes") and figure that for $18, I might as well try it too. So I got some 3000, 14,000 and 50,000 mesh stuff, roughly equal to my Shapton grits. I made up some hard maple flats and gave it a go.
First day did not go too well. Globs of paste stuck to the chisel sides and got moved all over. I tried over and over to push it into the wood, but of course you cannot see those tiny bits. Perhaps I slathered on a bit too much; I used a thin 3" line to spread over the 12" flat and had rubbed it around with a finger first, but it seemed that very little actually stayed in place to color the wood. I also managed to slice the tip of the chisel into the wood once or twice when using the sideways stroke that works so well on stones. I guess this would not be an issue on cast iron.
A few days later I tried again. The paste still built up on edges - okay, I put down too much - but it was drier and easier to work around. Close examination shows regular grooves, so clearly there are diamonds in the wood and they are cutting my steel. I took a freshly ground chisel through all three grits. I spent more time on each step than I would with the Shaptons - I am learning a new skill here - and came away with a very nice mirror finish. My first cut was a real aha! moment: I do not know if I have ever had such an edge before. This could be good!
One last comment: I might prefer the 1000 grit Shapton for the first step. It cut through a small rust deposit in two swipes whereas the 3000 mesh diamond did not. The diamond acted like a finer grit would. Maybe it is.
I have more to learn here. So far, I think I have a new last step at least.



