New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Identify and use hundreds of woods

Gorilla Glue

Posts

Gorilla Glue

#1

Jack Guzman from Maine

Gorilla Glue

Jack Guzman from Maine

Unfortunately some people consider this stuff the best thing ever invented . One fool in particular caused me a bit of work.

My wife bought a "new" bed at a flea market. The headboard is walnut and it has some nice molding details. The only problem is that the previous owner decided to reglue it. Below the crown piece are four rails with floating panels between them. This unknown regluer was very generous with the glue. This person took the whole piece apart and glued every groove generously. When I got it the back was covered with foam from excessive amounts of glue. The panels were permanently attached to the rails. Obviously ,no clamps were used because the posts were pushed apart by the expanding adhesive. I tried using heat and a putty knife to separate the panels. I sliced into each groove to the bottom,but the panels still broke trying to get them out of the grooves. I finally decided to give up on trying to save the panels intact.

I cut each panel at the edge of the rails.Then I cleaned the glue and wood out of the groove with a chisel.To make up the loss of width I discarded one rail and built a new,wider one. Glued back up correctly the bed is ready for use and not too bad considering what it's been through. A little stain on the new rail it is a nice looking headboard. My wife is happy and I have another humorous story about what not to do.---Jack

Re: Gorilla Glue

#2

Qualifies as the 600-lb Gorilla in the room

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Re: Gorilla Glue

#3

I go ape over the stuff!

John in NM

Re: Gorilla Glue

#4

Stephen Shepherd

I have never had the need to glue a primate.

Stephen Shepherd

Re: Gorilla Glue

#5

Re: Gorilla Glue

TomD

And it is apparently carcinogenic if touching moist skin.

Re: Gorilla Glue

#7

another indirect testimony for hide glue

roninkokomo

I use hide glue for anything that I make that has any chance of needing repair in the future.

Takes a couple of extra minutes of prep time, but 50 years from now the guy will really appreciate it.

Re: Gorilla Glue

#8

Jack Guzman from Maine

Re: another indirect testimony for hide glue

Jack Guzman from Maine

Since I read Stephen Shepherd's book on hide glue I've been using hide glue for 99% of my glueing needs. I use Patrick's liquid version. It makes life alot simpler.---Jack

Re: Gorilla Glue

#9

Re: another indirect testimony for hide glue

TomD

I do hold out that same thought... Though, I have been in the position once of needing to repair a joint of my own creation, and not being 100% sure what the glue used 10 or more years previously was. Obviously easy for me to determine. But I wonder how much benefit there really will be for future repairers, or even to what extent anyone will attempt repairs. Can't hurt of course.

Re: Gorilla Glue

#10

Re: another indirect testimony for hide glue

wilbur

I've been using Titebond liquid hide glue non-stop since I first tried it out. Last weekend I was really glad that I did so. I had been gluing 1/8" veneers to an MDF substrate to make a chessboard, and messed up on the eighth row. An iron and a moistened rag reversed that piece, and I was able to make another veneer and finish off that step of the project.

What I don't understand is if liquid hide glue is available, why use PVA glue at all, assuming you don't need the water resistance of Titebond III. I really don't see any advantages of regular PVA glue over liquid hide glue.

Re: Gorilla Glue

#11

Re: another indirect testimony for hide glue

David Weaver

I could only think of two reasons, well maybe a third,..... and a fourth, too.

1) price

2) shelf life

3) a little more water and heat resistant

4) if you want a light colored glue joint

I don't really care about any of those, and I can get liquid hide up the street (if I couldn't, I would make it)..

so i have also been using liquid hide for everything with the exception of stuff that needs a gap filler.

Re: Gorilla Glue

#12

Except...

John in NM

I do have a couple uses for polyurethane glue, stuff that I never, ever want to have come apart - from that point of view, Jack's story is a good testimony for gorilla glue, when used properly of course :D

Re: Gorilla Glue

#13

Re: another indirect testimony for hide glue

TomD

"What I don't understand is if liquid hide glue is available, why use PVA glue at all, assuming you don't need the water resistance of Titebond III. I really don't see any advantages of regular PVA glue over liquid hide glue."

Liquid Hide glue is an oddity. In furniture circles, say Brian Boggs' setting in which he makes chairs, it is used. In other settings like lutherie, it is regarded as crap. Regular hide glue is currently occupying the top chair in lutherie, but it is overkill for certain aspects, and also requires skill very few people have for other aspects. For main structural joints it is highly regarded, and feasible. Next in line would be the original Titebond. For that kind of glue it has low creep, if not compared to hide glue. Liquid hide glues just blows up in applications like holding on bridges under string strain. So one reason not to use it is because it is failure prone, and has some reputation for going bad in joints.

I think people fail to realize how specific glues are, and how many of them someone deep into the subject might have need of. I couldn't tell you how many I have probably 25-50. I would have 10 epoxies, not including admixtures, just for starters.

Re: Gorilla Glue

#14

Moses Yoder

Re: Except...

Moses Yoder

I used gorilla glue once for some chairs I thought would never come apart. Wow, what a mistake. I am not sure if the glue just has no elasticity or what, but they sure do come apart. I figure now you're better off gluing a joint in such a way that it can be taken apart.

Re: Gorilla Glue

#15

Stephen Shepherd

Re: another indirect testimony for hide glue

Stephen Shepherd

"I could only think of two reasons, well maybe a third,..... and a fourth, too.

1) price

2) shelf life

3) a little more water and heat resistant

4) if you want a light colored glue joint

I don't really care about any of those, and I can get liquid hide up the street (if I couldn't, I would make it)..

so i have also been using liquid hide for everything with the exception of stuff that needs a gap filler."

No. 1 yes most other glues are cheaper, but I like high quality.

No. 2 you can extend that by refrigerating the liquid hide glue.

No. 3 there are easy things to do to make hide glue water and heat proof.

No. 4 you can add powdered zinc oxide or whiting to the glue to make a light color glue. You can get the Zinc oxide powder at pottery or ceramic supply stores. It is the same stuff they use to make white glue white.

Adding Whiting {calcium carbonate}, bone flour, wood flour will thicken hide glue up making it great for gap filling.

Stephen

Re: Gorilla Glue

#16

Re: Except...

David Weaver

Someone once told me it was a great gap filler.

That's true, I guess, if you don't care about the strength of the glue spanning the gap.

Adhere's really great to the surface of the wood on either side, but the gap is very weak.

I bought a bottle when I first started woodworking - still have 95% of it. I don't even remember the last time I used it. The first time I tried to use it to fill a gap, it was worthless, and if you have no gap, I can't see how it's remotely as good as hide or even pva - it's a nuisance compared to them the way it flows out everywhere.

Re: Gorilla Glue

#17

guitar question

Bruce, a MN Galoot

So what kind of glue would you use to attach a saddle?

Re: Gorilla Glue

#18

Re: guitar question

Paul M.

The bridge gets glued to the top with standard hide glue (not the liquid kind). As TomD said, most luthiers consider the additives put into hide glue to make it room temperature liquid as substances that weaken the glue. A hard crystalline glue with zero creep is the best one to stand up to years of string tension.

But you asked about the saddle. The saddle never gets glued to the bridge. String tension alone is all that's needed to hold the saddle in place. The saddle should be a very tight fit into the bridge slot. If string tension is not adequate (i.e. if the saddle falls out when you change strings), then either the bridge slot is worn or somebody made a poor fitting saddle. A new saddle is in order to properly fit the bridge slot. That's a 1-hour or less job that can be done at any instrument repair shop.

Re: Gorilla Glue

#19

Thanks!  Everything I asked and then some...

Bruce, a MN Galoot

Re: Gorilla Glue

#20

Not my application....

John in NM

I don't think I'd use it on any furniture, and certainly not chairs. I assume chairs will be re-worked, probably in my lifetime, and use hide glue. From what Bill T. tells us, PVA would be fine too.

Re: Gorilla Glue

#21

Gap filling?

John in NM

Good heavens! Totally wrong way to use the stuff! I hope the guy who told you that isn't selling real estate or cars too! :D

Re: Gorilla Glue

#22

Re: Gap filling?

David Weaver

Nah - he's an engineer :b

Someone told him that and that was in the days before FWW did the glue article on tight joint and gap filled joint strength.

In reality, I guess even with a gap, it's strong enough for how I used it, but I can't get on with the foaming stuff and the need to apply water to one or both sides of a joint all the time.

For woodworking, gorilla glue is a solution to a problem that doesn't exist.

Re: Gorilla Glue

#23

No need for water...

John in NM

That's just to speed things up. If you have time there's enough moisture in the wood to take care of it. Wetting one side of the joint changes the clamp time from 6-8 hours to maybe 3 hours. Might affect the bond strength but I kind of doubt it.

I agree there's no need for such glue in most furniture applications, but I don't think a woodworker should toss knowledge of this glue away any more than they should with epoxy, pva, or hide glue. It has it's uses, and is incredibly strong stuff when used correctly.

Ironically, I've never gotten the whole "gap filling glue" concept. If that's what one needs, they are doing something drastically wrong in construction :D

In my view, gap filler is wood putty or something similar, not structural at all. Any joint with a gap big enough to need filling is likely to fail regardless of the adhesive, yet we all seem to blame the glue rather than the joint (or more correctly, the maker of the joint :D ).