New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Rare Exotic & Domestic Hardwoods, Milled In-House in Oregon. Browse Unique Stock.

*** SURVEY: THE IDES OF MARCH *** *LINK*

Posts

*** SURVEY: THE IDES OF MARCH *** *LINK*

#1

Ellis Walentine

*** SURVEY:  THE IDES OF MARCH *** *LINK*

Ellis Walentine

Hi Folks,

Welcome to the 69th (!) bi-monthly "Ides" survey here on WoodCentral.com. Hmm, that would be about 11 1/2 years worth of surveys. Whew! I'm amazed that there are any questions left to ask, but sure enough....

This month's survey question is about a side of our craft that nobody wants to think about: Workshop accidents. I'm interested to know if you have had one (or more) accidents in your woodworking past and what you learned, generally or specifically, that might help other woodworkers to avoid similar mishaps.

As always, your responses will be sensitively edited and transmitted to Woodworker West magazine and will appear in their next issue, due out in April.

Thanks in advance for participating!

Ellis Walentine, Host


Woodworker West Magazine

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF MARCH *** *LINK*

#2

Re: *** SURVEY:  THE IDES OF MARCH ***

R.J. Whelan

The worst accident I ever had was running my right thumb (yes, I'm right handed) into spinning TS blade (about 3/4" blade exposure above the plate).

This happened over 20 years ago and I still have absolutely no feeling from the second knuckle to the tip. Took a while to get used to having to look when I wanted to pick something up (using my thumb) because I can't tell (by feel) if I actually have ahold of the object.

What I learned:

1. I'm convinced that the Zero clearance plate made the damage much less than it might have been if there had been a gaping gap around the leading edge of the blade.

2. Use a push stick. I don't let my fingers get much closer that 4" from a spinning blade. I must have 6 or 7 different push sticks for different tasks.

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF MARCH *** *LINK*

#3

I wonder if it's significant...

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

that, as of the time I checked just now, there are eleven responses over on the main board, six on the whirly board, and one here; or if we neanderthals are (a) in denial or (b) slow?

I've been lucky, to date; or maybe just cautious. Nothing of value to report.

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF MARCH *** *LINK*

#4

I'm a slow learner

Bruce, a MN Galoot

Three times - count 'em, three times - I've cut myself doing exactly the same thing with the same chisel. On three separate occasions, holding the chisel with my right hand, I've driven that chisel into my left wrist, left thumb and left index finger while holding the workpiece with the left hand. You'd think I'd learn. The last time, the ER doc remarked that he'd never seen such a clean cut. Well, it should be, I'd just sharpened it. As it was, I was lucky enough to have just barely missed the artery, tendon and nerve feeding that hand.

What I learned is that wood needs to clamped firmly to the bench, not in the hand.

I don't know the author of this pic, but I think it's appropriate:


Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF MARCH *** *LINK*

#5

Re: *** SURVEY:  THE IDES OF MARCH ***

TomD

I've had a lot of pretty minor accidents. I've had three that probably could have ended up at the emerge, but we have "free" health care up here so one doesn't like to be a bother.

1) Dropped heavy just sharpened 70mm Japanese plane blade on the floor, except not wanting to see it chipped I caught it with my sandalled foot. Luckily I was wearing heavy wood socks so most of the blood got soaked up in them, and in the footbed of my Birkenstocks. Mostly learned that it doesn't hurt to drop a heavy sharp blade on you foot, but that doesn't mean you got away with it.

2) Kicked back a couple of bricks worth of cherry into my belt buckle, and it took off as much of my thumb as you can take without it even showing much of a scar. I also spent about 2 days in bed from the blow. Minor caliber level of foot pounds of energy. Learned that minor changes in the thickness width and length of a piece can make all the difference as to whether it is controllable. Other things

a) The real potential of power tools is in the horsepower rating. they made feel effortless to use, but when they turn on you meet the x horses.

b) Most old school table saws are too deep and the accessory fence makes maters worse. Spoken as a guy who is 6'3" on top.

3) Was cutting a centered slot on a stile, when it shot out from under my hand at a high rate of speed, and my middle finger pressed down on the router bit, chewing the end up. 99% recovery. Learned that that when using an aux fence, there is one position where the first cut is safe, and the second is a climb cut, and where the first cut is safe and the second is also safe. Times 2 for the fact the situation has a right and left of the fence component. I learned that, but I would also say that I learned that while I do a ton of very dangerous things that aren't in the manual with power tools, I have only been hurt when I was doing something different than I thought I was doing. As in this case. I though I was geometrically onside, but I hadn't seen the peril. There are a lot of dangerous things one can do. Buffing. grinding knives, unsupported cuts on bandsaws, plunge cuts with the nose of chainsaws, etc... Never even been scratched. It is the stuff that sneaks up on you.

Also never commit weight in the direction of the cutter. I knew that, but this cut was safe and guarded by the workpiece, or so I thought. One moment you have something in your hand, and the next it is you and the cutters. The jointer is a big risk with this kind of thing you could re-enact that last scene from Fargo with a jointer.

On hand tools, I have been pretty lucky but had my scrapes also. We live in a gun culture, not a blade culture. People are totally unprepared for what a blade can do. Read Borges, or take in some cold steel videos. Edged tools are very dangerous, even though they seem less troublesome. Most of the accidents seem to happen when one is tired. Resist that little voice that tells you to do just one more thing. I haven't had an accident in a long time, and while experience is some part of it, I think it is also that I am retired, and no longer do my hobby as a "second job", after 9 PM.

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF MARCH *** *LINK*

#6

Re: I'm a slow learner

TomD

I know what you mean, a vise is key, but there are also lots of ways of doing free cuts where you can't cut yourself. The deadly thing is to cut where an overshot will just keep on going, link your hands or get a stop on the workpiece so the movement is cut short and controlled.

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF MARCH *** *LINK*

#7

Re: The dull tool thing.

TomD

The only time I ended up getting stitches in a hand tool accident, I was cutting something with a knife and it gave way, and I cut myself deeply in the fork of the hand. It was one of those dull tool accident. The tool wasn't very dull, but it did take more force to cut than I had planed on, and I lost control. That said, as true as that observation is, sharp tools are more dangerous still. Basically, once you know that a dull tool is risky, in the way that it is, why would you have an accident with it (even if I did). You know what you are facing and exactly how to avoid the dangers. But a sharp tool is many times more capable, that is why we sharpen them, really, really, sharp. If you ever have a problem a sharp tool is going to be a bigger problem. So maybe one should keep in mind that both sharp and dull tools are the "most dangerous". Or to paraphrase, the tool you are cutting yourself with, is the tool to fear the most.

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF MARCH *** *LINK*

#8

I've learned techniques to limit blade travel

Bruce, a MN Galoot

I neglected to add an anecdote that Steve Lamantia told way back in the rec.ww days. He was planing on a piece of wood and his jointer slipped and went flying out the window of his shop. His takeaway lesson on that event was "where is it going to go when it slips?"

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF MARCH *** *LINK*

#9

Ellis Walentine

Different kinds of mistakes

Ellis Walentine

Maybe it has to do with the fact that tailless tools are safer. I know that when I've cut myself with chisels, the cut was so clean that it healed practically overnight, with appropriate antiseptic and bandage of course. Having spread my woodworking pretty evenly across all three universes of tools and activities, I have managed to have accidents in all three areas, I'm not proud to say.

Hand tool accidents have fallen into a few distinct types for me; see if any of these resonate: Cuts from chisel edges, where the back meets the side edges; errant hammer blows; and pinches when hand planing with my trailing fingers under the plane getting impaled on sharp corners. Once I managed to plunge a whittling knife right into the palm of my left hand, practically slicing the tendon and sheath that controls my middle finger. Like Rahm Emmanuel, I couldn't talk for six months. :)

Ellis

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF MARCH *** *LINK*

#10

Re: Different kinds of mistakes

Bruce, a MN Galoot

I once grabbed for an Xacto knife that was falling off my bench and shoved the blade all the way into the palm of my hand. Uffda! Since it was sharp, it didn't hurt that much. For a hurt that was off the Richter scale, I smacked my thumb with a framing hammer when the temp was -20F. I nearly blacked out.

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF MARCH *** *LINK*

#11

Guess I'm lucky...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond CA

Besides the occasional nick or cut with a chisel, I'm good.

As Bill said I've bashed a finger or two with a hammer to the point of passing out.

Here's the scary one I had one of those multi-function table saw push sticks. I didn't replace my zero clearance TS insert before cutting a narrow strip of oak.

Then BAM! the strip of oak and about a 1/4 of the push stick was gone into the TS before I knew what was happening. Had to go into the house and change the BVD's after that one... >(

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF MARCH *** *LINK*

#12

Jack Guzman from Maine

Re: *** SURVEY:  THE IDES OF MARCH ***

Jack Guzman from Maine

I have had a few fairly serious injuries over the years from power tools. Usually because of haste or fatigue. Since I started using more non-powered tools,the only injuries I get are minor cuts from various sharp blades. It's fairly common with me. I keep bandaids close by. I'll always be a clutz but this way I won't lose any body parts I want to keep.When I do have to use the powered monsters I am alot more careful.

I guess to answer your question then,injuries have taught me to be more cautious.---Jack

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF MARCH *** *LINK*

#13

Re: *** SURVEY:  THE IDES OF MARCH ***

Hank Knight

I recently had a pretty severe kickbak on my Unisaw. I was making an angled rip and had taken the splitter off because it was interfering with my overhead blade guard/dust collector. I felt uneasy about the cut before I made it, but I figured what the heck - I made this cut a hundred times before I added the splitter to my saw. Sure enough the blade caught the workpiece and in a heartbeat I got a 2X4 in the gut - deep bruise. Actually, I was lucky. It could have been much worse.

I learned two things: (1) Rely on your instincts. If your muse is whispering in your ear, "This feels bad," the muse is probably right. Don't do it, or at least stop and think it over carefully before you charge into it. (2) Accidents are going to happen, even to those of us who try hard to work safe. I just finished installing my new Sawstop. This isn't a Sawstop promotion, it's just my response to the realization that I could indeed lose a hand or part of one in the blink of an eye, even though I consider myself a safe woodworker.

Hank

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF MARCH *** *LINK*

#14

Darrell in Oakville

Re: *** SURVEY:  THE IDES OF MARCH ***

Darrell in Oakville

Ellis,

Sure, I've had some small accidents in the shop. Nothing major, a few stitches from a chisel wound. But I have formulated three primary rules for the shop:

1. Where will it go when it slips?

2. Never use your hand as a hammer.

3. Never use your hand as a vise.

I review these Rules with my kids all the time, and also with the Cubs and Scouts when we are working with tools at our meetings. So far so good, no incidents, no paper work!

Darrell

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF MARCH *** *LINK*

#15

Re: *** SURVEY:  THE IDES OF MARCH ***

roninkokomo

In using hand tools ALWAYS keep parts of your body that are important to you behind the cutting edge. NO EXCEPTIONS>

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF MARCH *** *LINK*

#16

Ellis That is funny !!

roninkokomo

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF MARCH *** *LINK*

#17

Re: *** SURVEY:  THE IDES OF MARCH ***

Bob Hackett

I find my metalworking accidents outnumber my woodworking accidents by roughly 10 to 1.Burns are far less common when dealing with wood and cuts are infrequent as you KNOW the edge is sharp or has a burr on it because you purposely put it there.

My main accidents with hand tools seem to revolve around splinters and I can scare up some world class splinters let me tell you .I tend to do far more damage digging them out than they do going in.

I have yet to have any WWing accidents involving arterial bleeding (knock on wood).Unfortunately I have had several metalworking accidents where that type of bleeding was the case.I never would have guessed we had so many arteries and that they would be so easy to hit. :(

After a car wreck that broke my back I was laying strapped to a backboard in the ER when a woman came in with a piece of wood sticking out of her forehead.She kept apologizing for cutting the line on me and told me she had been working with her tablesaw when she had a kickback, saw a flash,felt the impact,reached up and felt the wood in her forehead then immediately drove to the ER.I told her I had no problems with her getting seen first and just tried to act calm and keep her talking till the helicopter got there to life flight her to Maine Med.Suddenly the pain in my back and even arterial bleeding didn`t seem bad by comparison.

I see her every once in a while.We compare scars and I ask if she gets any headaches or other repercussions from her accident.She always smiles and says " Nope, apparently there was nothing important up there to hit".

Re: *** SURVEY: THE IDES OF MARCH *** *LINK*

#18

Re: *** SURVEY:  THE IDES OF MARCH ***

Paul M.

I've learned that longevity is assisted not only by learning from my own mistakes, but also learning from other's mistakes. As such, I've not been bitten by a tablesaw, because I have what can only be called beyond a healthy fear of those beasts.

After a second friend lost digits trying to use a tablesaw to save a bit of time (resulting in about 6 months of downtime to heal before he could get back to working with hand tools), I sold my tablesaw. I was dancing a merry jig as I saw it drive away in the back of someone else's truck. I haven't missed it a bit.

I may not be the fastest woodworker out there. But I've built lots of cabinets and guitars since then without missing the tablesaw. I'll stick with safer tools like bandsaws and drill presses. All other operations are performed by hand tools. I like keeping all my fingers right where they are.