New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Good Hope Hardwoods - Walnut Slabs & Specialty Hardwood Lumber

Larry, about your Sharpening Profiles dvd

Posts

Larry, about your Sharpening Profiles dvd

#1

Larry, about your Sharpening Profiles dvd

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Larry, just watched your Sharpening Profiled Hand Tools dvd last night and have a couple of questions. (Great dvd, btw, thank you.)

1. For the snipe bill blades you broke out a tiny grinder. Was there something special about the cone bit that required this? Or was it a speed issue?

2. For the ovolo blade, you went with files. Was this to get into tiny spaces that a cone couldn't? Would ceramic files work, too? And could you use files on the snipes, too, given that one is willing to anneal first? (Yeah, I really don't want to buy a Dremel or cousin.)

3. At one point you moved from a regular cone to a rubber impregnated with something cone. Why? And if I were to buy a Dremel, how do I know which cones to get with it? And could I use slips instead? You specify slips later in the sharpening cycle, but not during the "cone" phase.

4. It was really cool actually seeing you anneal the ovolo blade; but you said to be careful not to separate the laminations on old blades (I translated this to mean all laminated blades). How do you be careful? Is there a maximum temperature that should be applied? Maximum time? Or maybe it's all based on color alone? Was that a regular fire brick under it all? Was it broken into several pieces for a reason?

I guess these questions are more about when and why you chose the tools/methods you did.

Thanks,

Pam

Re: Larry, about your Sharpening Profiles dvd

#2

Re: Larry, about your Sharpening Profiles dvd

Larry Williams

Pam,

Let's see if I can be more clear than I evidently was in the DVD. It's been three years since that was filmed and I'm not sure, at this point, exactly what is in the DVD. I could look at the script but even it wouldn't be a good reflection of what's there because of the processes of shooting and editing.

"1. For the snipe bill blades you broke out a tiny grinder. Was there something special about the cone bit that required this? Or was it a speed issue?"

I used a flex shaft grinder. The one in the video is an inexpensive one from Grizzly and there are better ones on the market. The hand piece for the Grizzly doesn't accept 1/4" shank points so I have a Foredom 44T hand piece on the Grizzly. Foredom hand pieces fit the Grizzly flex shaft grinder. The nice part about these is their maneuverability and the variable speed with a foot control. This lets you be aggressive or to do incredibly detailed fine work.

Conical points are great because they give a whole range of radii without having to change anything.

If one is going to maintain profiled tools, I think a flex shaft grinder is more than worth the expense. It is a lot faster than working with slips.

"2. For the ovolo blade, you went with files. Was this to get into tiny spaces that a cone couldn't? Would ceramic files work, too? And could you use files on the snipes, too, given that one is willing to anneal first? (Yeah, I really don't want to buy a Dremel or cousin.)"

It is a cove/ovolo and the small fillet between the two profiles had been badly deformed in previous botched sharpening attempts. I don't know if I said anything on the video, but to correct the problem, I had to move the whole profile back up the iron almost a sixteenth of an inch.

Each time one anneals and re-hardens steel the grain size grows. You want to keep this to a minimum so only do it once. Fix all the problems in the process and then properly maintain it from that point on.

Files made reshaping that small fillet a lot easier. One of the things that helped is using small Swiss pattern files with safe edges or edges with no teeth. I'm thinking I used a small pillar file to refine the 90� angle of that fillet but it may have been an auger bit file. Both have safe edges.

The problem with ceramic files or even regular files is they have no safe edges. While trying to work one surface or direction it's more than likely you'll discover you've also fouled an adjoining surface that runs in a different direction. It's very fine work and safe edges give the control you'll find you need.

"3. At one point you moved from a regular cone to a rubber impregnated with something cone. Why? And if I were to buy a Dremel, how do I know which cones to get with it? And could I use slips instead? You specify slips later in the sharpening cycle, but not during the "cone" phase."

I use rubberized abrasives to refine the surface after the coarse cone. Think of these like you would your honing stones. The carborundum point is coarse, the rubberized abrasive is medium and the slips are the fine finishing abrasive.

I don't know anything about Dremel's flex shaft grinder. I think they make one but I've never used one. Foredom and Weecher are the two most common and we use Grizzly because we're kinda cheap. The Foredom hand piece will cost almost as much as the whole Grizzly grinder.

It's unlikely you'll get useful points in any kit. Buy them separately. I get ours from Enco for the carborundum and MSC for the rubberized abrasives. Don seems to prefer the Cratex rubberized abrasives over the MSC house brand I like. MSC's prices on the Cratex abrasives are quite a bit higher than other places.

"4. It was really cool actually seeing you anneal the ovolo blade; but you said to be careful not to separate the laminations on old blades (I translated this to mean all laminated blades). How do you be careful? Is there a maximum temperature that should be applied? Maximum time? Or maybe it's all based on color alone? Was that a regular fire brick under it all? Was it broken into several pieces for a reason?"

I hope I didn't indicate that I was concerned about the steel delaminating. My concern was about how the 300 year-old steel was going to show the phase change to austinite. There are a lot of things that can affect the visible indication of the change and lamination is just one of them.

Unfortunately that one shot had to be done in a single take with no second try. The steel didn't show the change as well as I wanted. It's a little ironic because it worked too well in the plane making DVD. While it was dramatic in the plane making DVD, I doubt most people will see the steel change that way when they do it themselves.

It's not color or time and yes you can overheat the steel. It's really frustrating to try and explain the visible changes in the steel at critical temperature when the phase change happens. I can move my cursor about 9" right now and click on some good video that's on my computer but that's no help to you. It's described in various ways in old texts, "when the steel opens," "when the flux rises," "when it sweats" but you have to create the right conditions for it to happen. That's what I was trying to show.

Those ceramic elements were salvaged from a backyard grill that was being thrown out by someone else. I got a number of them but don't remember the brand name. They don't hold up well to the heat and tend to break up over time. They are effective at collecting and releasing heat so that you can get uniform temperature on the front and back of the plane iron.

There's so much more I'd like to write about this but I've got a project I need to finish today.