New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Rare Exotic & Domestic Hardwoods, Milled In-House in Oregon. Browse Unique Stock.

Cast iron for diamond paste plate

Posts

Cast iron for diamond paste plate

#1

Cast iron for diamond paste plate

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

I got around to cutting up a couple of broken Stanley planes. They gave their soles ... or should that be souls ... for the cause! :)

Used a cut-off saw to get the pieces square, then an angle grinder to sever them at the waist. Built a box around the iron, and fixed it in place with car body filler. Sealed up the bottom and stuck on sand paper to act as non-slip.

Made two of these so far, one for 10 micron and the other for 0.5 micron oil-based paste. The one below is from a #4 and has dimensions of 60mm x 148mm (roughly 2 3/8" x 5 7/8"). This is easily large enough for freehanding both chisel and plane blades.


I took them along to the recent LN Hand Tool Event as my travelling sharpening kit. A few people came up to ask what I was doing with the shiny plates (the 0.5 plate came up like a mirror). It must have looked strange to onlookers as the plates simply look like shiny steel.

Gad they work well!

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Cast iron for diamond paste plate

#2

Re: Cast iron for diamond paste plate

TomD

That's taking an idea to the next level. For some reason nobody seems to have grabbed onto this idea since I suggested it a while back. People are still looking for that magic piece of Iron, when there are dead planes or cheap planes all over the place. But when you touch an idea it gets a very professional touch.

Re: Cast iron for diamond paste plate

#3

Re: Cast iron for diamond paste plate

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Tom, the problem is: how do you remove/cut off all the extraneous stuff?

Pam

Re: Cast iron for diamond paste plate

#4

Re: Cast iron for diamond paste plate

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Cast iron cuts very easily with a hacksaw or, if you want to use electrons and have a good way to hold the piece, a reciprocating saw.

Re: Cast iron for diamond paste plate

#5

Re: Cast iron for diamond paste plate

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Thanks, Bill, I was just pointing out to Tom why more people haven't taken up old plane destruction. I, otoh, don't have any old western planes to reuse. I suppose I could buy one for the purpose, but then there's all the flattening most likely required.

Pam

Re: Cast iron for diamond paste plate

#6

Re: Cast iron for diamond paste plate

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

I suppose I could buy one for the purpose, but then there's all the flattening most likely required.

Hi Pam

First cut the plane into the lengths you want/need. That way there is less to flatten.

A decrepid #7 could offer up three plates. I don't imagine one needs more than three plates (e.g. 40/10/.5 microns). Indeed, I am amazed that I can make do with two plates (10 and .5 microns). Perhaps others will comment on this aspect.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Cast iron for diamond paste plate

#7

Flattening

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

"...but then there's all the flattening most likely required."

Well. I recently measured the soles a couple of 1930s No. 5s in my shop. They're out (as best I can tell with what I have as a straightedge) 0.002" over their length - and most of that toward one end.

Whether this is true of the sorts of planes that would be candidates for this kind of reuse - for instance, postwar models - I don't know.

I'd be more concerned, in looking at decrepit examples, with pitting.

Anyway, there's a part of me that flinches at cutting up a usable plane. Not so bad, I guess, if the cheek is broken off or something. And there's so many dead table saws of makes that are not worth maintaining for future generations, and other sources of good cast iron.

Re: Cast iron for diamond paste plate

#8

Re: Cast iron for diamond paste plate

David Weaver

The more aggressive the abrasive, and the deeper it cuts relative to its grit size, the bigger spans you can skip. 10 micron is like what... 1500 grit on the JIS scale?

1/2 micron is somewhere around 20,000-30,000 depending on what era you're talking about.

A big jump, but having loose diamonds is like always having a brand new DMT plate around, and those always cut miles and miles faster new than they do once you wear the "smarts" off the diamonds.

Re: Cast iron for diamond paste plate

#9

Re: Cast iron for diamond paste plate

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi David

I also thought it would be a big jump - when one starts thinking of experiences with waterstones - but it clearly works, so there is a different mentality needed when working with diamond pastes.

As I had only two plates completed before the Event - I had aimed for three - it was necessary to allocate them to microns. I needed the .5 micron, so I decided to go for the 10 micron rather than the 40 micron, which is the third paste of my trio.

I was nicely surprised that the 10 micron could flatten the back of a M4 chisel, and do it so quickly. And then that the .5 micron could turn the matt surface into a mirror. This is what begs the question, "does one really need a third paste?". What do others use?

One more thing: the cast iron outperforms the steel (ex-saw) plates I used previously, and quite significantly so.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Cast iron for diamond paste plate

#10

WAY too much thinking going on here

Bob Hackett

Sometimes you have to just stop thinking and comparing what you think you know with what you think might be appropriate.

Just throw all that mental chatter out and do a search on Bill Tindal`s posts and you`ll get a firm grasp on what really is important.Bill and his circle of friends have made most of the mistakes and false starts for us.They have been more than generous about posting their findings here.

Just grab an old CI saw table and get after it! I cut mine with a Skillsaw.

If cutting it bothers you or freaks you out in any way drag it to the nearest machine shop and have them do it.I hit my piece of rusty old saw table with a wire wheel on an angle grinder,poured the loose diamond on it and it works fine.

Stop thinking and DO IT already!

BTW-for utility work (about 90% of what really needs to be done in my shop) I find I only need one grit of diamond,1 micron.I have a lot of others but the only other one I use to ny extent is 1/2 micron and that only comes out when I get bored and am looking for something to waste time on.

Re: Cast iron for diamond paste plate

#11

Re: Cast iron for diamond paste plate

David Weaver

I have a similar jump, and agree about the metals.

I haven't used cast yet, just mild steel and (unhardened) O1. Mild steel seems to have a much better result, and as you mention, it works HSS like other mediums work high carbon steel.

I have been resistant to buying an entire set of new stones to replace the shaptons for high speed steels purely because I think they are not necessary, and would be counterproductive for the O1s and A2s of the world (not to mention the flatness of the shaptons is a huge work saver for japanese irons sharpened traditionally). I'm so pleased with the shaptons for everything other than HSS that I intend to wear them out, and even for HSS they are fine in a pinch. But in general, I go elsewhere with the HSS. Between the diamonds and a leather disc on my disc sander (in part thanks to your tutorial a while ago about putting something on your disc), and a leather belt - both loaded with green stuff - I have had no problem getting edges initially as sharp with HSS as anything I have felt. It sure does wear a lot differently than plain carbon steel - after the loss of initially keenness, it stays in the "pretty sharp" category forever.

Re: Cast iron for diamond paste plate

#12

For some of us, thinking is part of the fun.

Chuck Nickerson

Re: Cast iron for diamond paste plate

#13

Re: Cast iron for diamond paste plate

TomD

Well in my case I have a bandsaw... Those things are cheap, as I think I mentioned in that abrasive cut-off wheels. The not cheap part is that they are nasty to trip over for the rest of time... :)

One doesn't have to cut that stuff off, one could just leave it, but then it wouldn't have that Derek touch.

Re: Cast iron for diamond paste plate

#14

Re: Cast iron for diamond paste plate

TomD

As far as plane destruction is concerned I didn't suggest that anyway.

I also think people are getting a little carried away on the accuracy thing. More accuracy is good obviously, but how flat are stones? Possibly more to the point, how flat are things hand sharpened on stones. I really doubt extreme flatness is necessary. Didn't Krenov say he hadn't flattened his stones in decades or something?

Re: Cast iron for diamond paste plate

#15

Re: Cast iron for diamond paste plate

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

I agree, there's way too much time spent in woodworking on some absolute flatness goal; but in the process of sawing up a plane for its sole, burrs would naturally be created that would have to be flattened a bit to get out of the way. You should see how incredibly unflat and cratered are some of my natural waterstones, which I hesitate to flatten because of the mountains of stone that would be wasted; so I tend to work in fairly cramped areas of these stones until they're worn down, naturally so to speak. :)

Also, please note once again that I'm all set with my old CI saw table for diamond paste.

Thanks,

Pam

Re: Cast iron for diamond paste plate

#16

Re: Cast iron for diamond paste plate

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

True and true, and if not cut off, you'd have to devote a vise to holding these puppies, and since it would be part of your sharpening regimen, it would be forever. :)

Pam

Re: Cast iron for diamond paste plate

#17

The upgrade cycle.

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

and if not cut off, you'd have to devote a vise to holding these puppies, and since it would be part of your sharpening regimen, it would be forever.

That's it - personally, building these plates is not about creating pretty equipment (hey, I can't help it is they look that way! :) ). It is about making something functional that is easy to use, easy to maintain, and easy to store.

Why use old planes? Because they are there and because old cast iron tablesaw tops are not. I wouldn't know where to find such a beast.

It strikes me that this sharpening thing is a lot like what happens when you upgrade one part of a machine, such as a motor car engine or a hifi system ... inevitably it shows up weaknesses in the older parts, and there you go upgrading again! :(

David posted earlier about being happy with his Shapton Pros on all but HSS. I totally agree. They do a great job on HCS and A2. Even HSS in the form of M2, although this can take a little more time. However, once I started evaluating the supersteels, such as 3V, M4, and 10V, then the game changed. The Shaptons were no longer able to play along.

And so it goes ...

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Cast iron for diamond paste plate

#18

Re: Cast iron for diamond paste plate

Aaron Rappaport

I'm confused. Wasn't the Prevailing Wisdom only a few weeks ago that using two grits of loose diamonds inevitably led to contaminating the plate holding the finer diamonds with some of the coarser ones? I seem to recall a poster saying he had photographs showing this.

Aaron

Re: Cast iron for diamond paste plate

#19

Re: The upgrade cycle.

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

It strikes me that this sharpening thing is a lot like what happens when you upgrade one part of a machine, such as a motor car engine or a hifi system ... inevitably it shows up weaknesses in the older parts, and there you go upgrading again!

Yes, a rugged landscape complexity problem. Will let you know something when I can figure it out. :)

And it's not so much the money involved, although that can be considerable; but it's all the space to store/use all the newfound (the hunt is very much fun) toys. How obnoxious to open a drawer and find all the discarded junk hanging about, taking up space, too valuable to trash, too cheap/used to resell.

Pam

Re: Cast iron for diamond paste plate

#20

Grit Contamination

Steve Elliott

I�ve used a 540x inspection microscope to examined quite a few edges sharpened using diamond and haven�t ever seen grit embedded in the steel. Most of the edges had been honed with 1 micron diamond (the same grit used in the recently posted images you mentioned) and even a better optical microscope than mine would have trouble resolving something that small. An electron microscope would probably make the 1 micron grit look like gravel--I�m not saying there isn�t any there, only that the recent reference to it was probably dust that was mistaken for diamond.

As a practical matter I don�t find grit contamination to be a problem. I recently used 60 micron diamond to lap the back of a CPM-3V blade that was slightly twisted, and tried to find embedded diamond under my microscope. I couldn�t find any even though a 60 micron chunk of anything would have been obvious. I went on to using 3 micron diamond on a different lapping plate and the surface produced didn�t show any rogue scratches.

As when using any other kind of abrasive, I clean off the blade when going to a finer grit size. For diamond I use mineral spirits on a little piece of paper towel and the towel leaves lots of small white bits that show up under magnification. For imaging purposes I remove them using blue masking tape.

If a 3 micron grit got embedded in a plate dedicated to 1 micron diamond, it might leave somewhat deeper scratches for a while but contrary to advertising claims, a diamond is not forever. Think of a DMT diamond plate and how much slower it cuts after a while. Adding new diamond grit is like getting a brand new plate and the fresh diamond cuts very aggressively for a while. My method is to use fine enough diamond that the aggressive cut gives a pretty good edge, and if I want an especially fine edge I can wash off the plate and use the somewhat worn grit to further refine the edge. Think of leaving the slurry on a fine waterstone and letting it dry to get a better edge.

Re: Cast iron for diamond paste plate

#22

Re: Grit Contamination

David Weaver

I agree with this. I didn't use any magnification, but in going from a 1500 grit mix to something around half a micron, I examined my irons under a dissection microscope.

Evidence of grit contamination would've easily showed itself as deep scratches that wouldn't resolve on the end of a chisel. I didn't have any of those. The diamond grooves are definitely different, but I did just as you say - wipe the chisel off after the 1500 grit, and didn't have any problems.

I did not use a honing guide. There might be more issue if you use a honing guide with a soft steel wheel, or a brass wheel, but having not done it, I don't know if there is - I didn't think it worth trying. If it is perceived to be a possible problem, them it's easily solved by making a quick wooden jig that works off the end of the hone.

Re: Cast iron for diamond paste plate

#23

Re: The upgrade cycle.

David Weaver

While it's still my opinion that they work well with the M2 types of HSS, I agree that they are at their limit. the surface will clog a little if you're too quick with the M2, a quick swipe of the diamond hone rids it, though, and I always lap mine with a couple of swipes after sharpening a couple of things, anyway.

What got me into diamonds, though, is portability, perceived low maintenance and the draw of the ability to get a very small particle size for the final hone (which I now think is a waste of time for practical use, but it was worth a try).

No system itself is perfect, but I think having a set of low maintenance stones and compromising on the diamonds for HSS instead of an entire other set of stones that make sharpening the carbon steels and the A2s more of a nuisance is my chosen way to go. But my diamonds haven't gotten a lot of use since I got several powered leather hones around (the disc and a small belt grinder with a leather belt).

I will keep the diamond stuff around just in case i ever get into the exotic steels, but at this point, i would guess that's never going to happen. I would say "i've spent my money on what I want already".

About the only thing I want more of is good carving tools, but waiting to find them for "deal price" means they show up slowly.

Saying that you're done buying in general is making a dangerous statement, though.

Re: Cast iron for diamond paste plate

#24

so what is a good source for diamonds?

les winter

Where do you buy your diamonds?