New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A natural, durable finish with minimal coats and fuss popular among woodworkers, flooring professionals, and furniture makers

St. James Bay steel

Posts

St. James Bay steel

#1

St. James Bay steel

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

I'm getting ready to contact St. James Bay to see if he has replacement parts for some of my Stanley tool finds*, and wonder what experiences folks have had with his cutting irons - steel, heat treatment, etc.

*Someone on WoodNet had heard he's getting out of the replacement parts business. If, when I reach him, there's news, I'll report back.

Re: St. James Bay steel

#2

I went and talked to him years ago...

John in NM

I was taking my wife to the airport in Phoenix or something and had time to kill. I'd recently taken a knife making workshop at Pima Community College and was all fired up to make stuff from steel.

I asked what temp he used to draw the plane irons, just O1 steel as I recall. He said he didn't draw them, which explains the horrible review they had received not long before in a magazine. I can only hope he's learned from that review.

Even if not, that shouldn't discourage anyone from buying an iron from him, you'd just need to bake it for a while (though I still don't know what temp is good for a thin blade like a plane). I think I'd done the knife at 450 F, but was thinking one could do plane blades somewhat lower. One could always start low, evaluate performance, and then inch it higher 25 degrees at a time.

Re: St. James Bay steel

#3

Thanks

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

That's useful information. When I totaled up the items I was considering getting, the final price, while not gasp-inducing, was higher than was pleasant. So I may decide to whittle the (simple) irons myself, and get from him the stuff that would be harder to make.

As of so far, he hasn't answered his phone when I've called; I understand he can be hard to reach.

Re: St. James Bay steel

#4

Re: Thanks

David Weaver

He can be hard to get a hold of. Expect to talk for a while if you do get a hold of him.

I've heard too that the irons are hardened and not tempered. I kind of preferred that. You can get any starrett label and find out what hardness you want them to go to and temper them in the oven.

I have one in a plane kit that I'm only half done with, so i'm not sure how hard it is, but i'll probably throw it in the oven at 350 for an hour just as a precaution once I finish the plane.

Re: St. James Bay steel

#5

Re: St. James Bay steel

TomD

I have read reviews in the past where the blades were referred to as too soft. But if he isn't even tempering them, I guess it is up to you. When I ordered some kits the blades weren't heat treated at all, which wasn't what I had been expecting, but as he said, heat treating O1 is pretty easy.

Re: St. James Bay steel

#6

Re: St. James Bay steel

barryavbeach

I had the same experience as Tom, I bought a few plane kits, and IIRC the blades came unhardened. Pretty easy to harden and then temper since it was O-1.

Re: St. James Bay steel

#7

Re: Thanks

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

This is not going to be much help ..

I have an unfinished SJB thumb plane (just the ebony infill to complete now). I purchased the kit several years ago on eBay. It came without instructions, so I emailed SJB. I have purchased spares from them in the past, but I knew that communication was erratic (at best!), so did not expect a quick reply. But one not only came, but included much of the details I needed.

The other point of interest was that the blade for the plane is a Hock. It also appears to be tempered ... which is a problem since I have to drill a couple of holes through the blade for the Norris-type adjuster. Any suggesting for a drill bit?

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: St. James Bay steel

#8

Re: Thanks

David Weaver

I've never had any luck drilling anything harder than spring steel, and even that is a bear.

I'd be inclined to put the cutting end of the iron in water and put a small mapp torch to the spot where you want to drill the hole for the adjuster to run the temper out of it.

Re: St. James Bay steel

#9

Re: Thanks

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

On thinner stock, one of the methods to remove temper is to put a rod of appropriate diameter in the drill press (or post drill :) ) and run it at fairly high speed against the spot on which you want to remove temper until the friction heats up the steel. Whether that would work on something that thick - not sure.

Re: St. James Bay steel

#10

Re: Thanks

Bob Hackett

I have had some luck using this technique to start the drill as the soft area will be deep enough to spot and start the drill. I have a short throw brace(for rigidity) that I have modified for use in the drill press.The drill press holds considerable downward force and then I just use the brace to turn the bit.I have had good results with the slow rotation/heavy feed approach drilling difficult material when using sharp cobalt bits and water as a cutting fluid/coolant.Anything but hand power and you risk dulling and then burning up the bit.

I was shown this by an old hand in one of the boatyards up here who used a drill device for a brace that was held and clamped by a chain wrapped around the work and a collar that held pressure on the bit to drill into a hardened shaft on a boat in this case.He also had a joist brace he would use with the adapter for tight clearance work.

He told me "Keep heavy pressure in it and if it stops pulling a chip then stop,time to sharpen the bit".

Can`t remember what he called that adapter/device he used.Must be getting old.

Re: St. James Bay steel

#11

Re: Thanks

David Weaver

I would assume that's what's happening when i drill saw plates. It's rough on the HSS bits, but they're not high quality bits. I can do three holes on a saw, and then I have to resharpen the bit if I want to use it again the next time I make a saw.

Wouldn't be the preferred method if I were making a lot of them!

Suppose they were punched on old saws before the saw was hardened and brought to spring temper.

Re: St. James Bay steel

#12

Re: Carbide Drill

TomD

A carbide drill bit is capable of drilling hardened metal. But whether it would do a Hock I don't know. We use carbide tooling for stuff like cutting allen keys into screw drivers, rather than buying fitted screw drivers. But those are probably hardened into the 50s. Still small solid carbide twist drills are fairly cheap, so why not give it a try. It might also be worth using if you try one of the differential methods of drawing the temper, since you won't be guaranteed an annealed result.

Re: St. James Bay steel

#13

Re: St. James Bay steel

TomD

I'm not dissing SJB, I think their stuff is a good deal. The first stuff i bought was partially machined, which is a very good deal. The price is not that much higher, and they do all the machining for you. Those kits came with hardened and tempered blades. I later bought some raw casting, and "blades". Those are not as good a deal, and I was just a little surprised they came with raw steel blades. But it's no problem for me. I wouldn't order the raw ones again, even though I have all the tools, it takes a lot of time and special set-ups to get a plane machined.

Also to their credit, I asked for a custom sole on a block plane I ordered, and they did it for free, or near free.