Re: Assistance with choice of replacement irons...
David Weaver
I wouldn't spend the extra money on the IBC stuff, it's money thrown away. That's my opinion, and I have used them (as well as the hocks, LV, shepherds, LN ...) . I like the WC organization OK, i just don't think there's a need for a "premium price" replacement iron that's not made out of exotic steel. For the same reason, there's no great reason to buy LN's.
Until you get into the more exotic stuff, I would buy based on price with A2 and for stanley planes, I would stick with the standard thickness replacement irons.
LV irons are nice, they take the least amount of time to prepare because of their fantastic lapping - you can go right to a polish stone on the back of the new iron, or skip it all if you're doing a ruler trick type of back. Hock irons can usually be found cheaply at craftsmanstudio.
Some of these recommendations you're talking about come from folks who lead classes and probably have scads of beginners coming in, and would like the easiest to prepare thing they can find so they don't have to deal with students preparing an iron. LV's irons are still the fastest to prepare, to me. The WC irons are not flat to my polish stones, so inasmuch as you can use the iron right out of the box, you will still be flattnening the back some when the iron first dulls if yours come like mine - the lapping is not of the same sort of perfection in flatness that exists on the LV irons (which, if your stone is not flat to them, your stone is not flat).
The cosman recommendation...definitely not uncompensated. I'd take any cosman recommendation with a grain of salt, especially anything in competition with LN or promoting something with his name on. Not that he's selling junk, just that he's selling generally the same stuff as everyone else, but for a higher price, and he has a history of exhibiting opinions that include extra salesy bits that aren't realistic (like using the term "superior metallurgy" on another forum with the IBC irons, which is undefined farce as far as I can tell) - something nearly none of the other makers do.
I wouldn't put too much weight on recommendations by anyone, you can regard mine as the same.
I can tell you, though, two things:
1) M2 lasts longer than A2 by a wide margin. The harder and more abrasive the wood, the bigger the difference.
2) if you are using your planes for rough dimensioning where you're inclined to use an iron until it pretty much stops cutting, A2 lasts noticeably longer than high carbon steel. When smoothing, if you are minding the quality of your job and sharpening often, you'll notice the difference less.
3) OK a third..all of the big brand A2 irons are similar hardness and have similar durability. You can disregard any comments from any manufacturers that imply that their A2 irons are more durable than someone elses. I have found (in one dumb stretch of actually counting strokes) that there is probably more variation within brands than there is from brand to brand. As far as A2 goes, the iron that chips out the farthest number of strokes into a count is the one that lasts less. One that develops tiny chips early on will dull much faster. Most of the irons drop this chipout behavior after they've been ground a couple of times.