New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

200+ woodworking book reviews

Assistance with choice of replacement irons...

Posts

Assistance with choice of replacement irons...

#1

Assistance with choice of replacement irons...

John Aniano in central NJ...

Hello All,

Was wondering - I need to replace two 2" wide Stanley (Bailey) plane blades. One is for a #5 , the other for a #4 smoother. Both appear to be type 25 to 30 and the old blades are the originals, but finally near the end of their lives having been ground by previous owners to just before the slot. For the #4, I also need a new chipbreaker.

The questions - which of the thicker replacement blades (and chipbreaker) are recommended? Lie-Nielsen, Lee Valley, Hock, Woodcraft "Pinnacle" - any other firms out there? I'm leaning toward A-2 or possibly M2 blades if I can locate a maker - I'm comfortable sharpening the harder steels. Any makers of CPM3 blades or similar out there other than Stephen Thomas? Are the Cryo-treated blades really worth the added cost over plain A2's? How are the "Pinnacle" cryo-A2 blades and chipbreakers sold by Woodcraft? These seem to get a lot of high-profile recommendations...

I have some concern that the blade adjustment pivot "finger" that fits through the slot in the blade fitting into the narrow slot in the chipbreaker will not be long enough with a very thick (1/8") blade. Lie-Nielsen specifically mentions this potential problem so I assume others have experienced this issue.

Thanks,

John

Re: Assistance with choice of replacement irons...

#2

Re: Assistance with choice of replacement irons...

anotherBob

I think I remember that John Payne (jcav8ter) over at WoodNet is making or was talking about making CPM-3V Stanley replacement irons. Don't know for sure... whatever you find, let us know ok?

Re: Assistance with choice of replacement irons...

#3

Re: Assistance with choice of replacement irons...

Jerry Nicholson

I use Lee Valley replacement blades in my Stanley planes. There is no problem with engaging the blade height adjuster but I do have to widen the lateral adjustment slot a tiny bit with a Dremel tool. I have several Hock cap irons but LV sells their own now. These are much heavier than the old Stanley "chip breakers". I have never tried the LN replacement blades.

Jerry

Re: Assistance with choice of replacement irons...

#4

craigd

Re: Assistance with choice of replacement irons...

craigd

I run 1/8" blades (home made O-1) on a #7 Stanley & #3 Sargent and the depth adjusters are fine. I "adapted" the chip breaker screw on the #7 because it was too short. I did need to file the the mouth on the #7 but it was so rounded over it was needed anyway.

Re: Assistance with choice of replacement irons...

#5

Re: Assistance with choice of replacement irons...

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi John

While they are not advertised, I gather that Lee Valley are now offering M2 (HSS) blades.

John Payne may also make one for you - contact via WoodNet. I have a M4 blade of his on test in my #604. It certainly gets as sharp as anything, and as quickly, using diamond paste, and then holds it a l-o-n-g time.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Assistance with choice of replacement irons...

#6

Re: Assistance with choice of replacement irons...

TomD

The best replacement blades I have ever used where the Japanese ones. In a lot of ways they don't have the features people are looking for these days, they aren't particularly thick for one thing. Best cutting performance. I have used a few cryo tools and didn't notice a significant difference. Any actually, but then people tend to try that process out and may not get it right.

http://japanwoodworker.com/dept.asp?s=JapanWoodworker&dept_id=13611

Haven't used this particular brand. I have tried several and they are all good but not the same.

Re: Assistance with choice of replacement irons...

#7

Re: Assistance with choice of replacement irons...

David Weaver

I wouldn't spend the extra money on the IBC stuff, it's money thrown away. That's my opinion, and I have used them (as well as the hocks, LV, shepherds, LN ...) . I like the WC organization OK, i just don't think there's a need for a "premium price" replacement iron that's not made out of exotic steel. For the same reason, there's no great reason to buy LN's.

Until you get into the more exotic stuff, I would buy based on price with A2 and for stanley planes, I would stick with the standard thickness replacement irons.

LV irons are nice, they take the least amount of time to prepare because of their fantastic lapping - you can go right to a polish stone on the back of the new iron, or skip it all if you're doing a ruler trick type of back. Hock irons can usually be found cheaply at craftsmanstudio.

Some of these recommendations you're talking about come from folks who lead classes and probably have scads of beginners coming in, and would like the easiest to prepare thing they can find so they don't have to deal with students preparing an iron. LV's irons are still the fastest to prepare, to me. The WC irons are not flat to my polish stones, so inasmuch as you can use the iron right out of the box, you will still be flattnening the back some when the iron first dulls if yours come like mine - the lapping is not of the same sort of perfection in flatness that exists on the LV irons (which, if your stone is not flat to them, your stone is not flat).

The cosman recommendation...definitely not uncompensated. I'd take any cosman recommendation with a grain of salt, especially anything in competition with LN or promoting something with his name on. Not that he's selling junk, just that he's selling generally the same stuff as everyone else, but for a higher price, and he has a history of exhibiting opinions that include extra salesy bits that aren't realistic (like using the term "superior metallurgy" on another forum with the IBC irons, which is undefined farce as far as I can tell) - something nearly none of the other makers do.

I wouldn't put too much weight on recommendations by anyone, you can regard mine as the same.

I can tell you, though, two things:

1) M2 lasts longer than A2 by a wide margin. The harder and more abrasive the wood, the bigger the difference.

2) if you are using your planes for rough dimensioning where you're inclined to use an iron until it pretty much stops cutting, A2 lasts noticeably longer than high carbon steel. When smoothing, if you are minding the quality of your job and sharpening often, you'll notice the difference less.

3) OK a third..all of the big brand A2 irons are similar hardness and have similar durability. You can disregard any comments from any manufacturers that imply that their A2 irons are more durable than someone elses. I have found (in one dumb stretch of actually counting strokes) that there is probably more variation within brands than there is from brand to brand. As far as A2 goes, the iron that chips out the farthest number of strokes into a count is the one that lasts less. One that develops tiny chips early on will dull much faster. Most of the irons drop this chipout behavior after they've been ground a couple of times.

Re: Assistance with choice of replacement irons...

#8

Re: Assistance with choice of replacement irons...

David Weaver

Those are good irons, but lacking in thickness some if you prefer a thicker iron - they are similar to the standard stanley iron thickness.

I don't think that's a reason not to buy them, though, especially with a heavy chipbreaker, except...

.. they are made by tsunesaburo and we now have an english speaking contact bending tsunesaburo's ear, which gives us a chance to get stanley replacement iron and LN thickness irons in the future.

In the way that they fail (very fine grained steel), they may be a better smoothing iron than anything else out there. Wish they were thicker!

Re: Assistance with choice of replacement irons...

#9

Limited experience, me

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

I tossed a replacement iron into one of my Lee Valley orders, and was thrilled to find, when it arrived, that I could plane with it right out of the box, although of course it was improved by honing.

Having read, here and other places, narratives from folks about "it took just half an hour to flatten the back" of other aftermarket irons, I particularly liked that the LV irons come flatflatflat (at least by my standards) on the back.

I'm kind of lazy about my shopping; if I find something that works well, I tend to keep on doing that, rather than doing a lot of comparison buying. So I can't compare them to Hock or other irons.

I can say I really like mine, and have continued to buy more irons, slowly converting my fleet.

Re: Assistance with choice of replacement irons...

#10

Re: Assistance with choice of replacement irons...

rob cosman

Hi John, David Charlesworth contacted me several months ago wanting to get his hands on the blade/breaker I and IBC were working on. I was doing a show with him this past weekend in London and i got to see a few of the old rehabs he has recently completed. David takes the process much further than I do, his were polished much better than new. In his booth he had a poster displaying this blade/breaker product, he receives no compensation from me or IBC. His primary interest is helping his students get the most out of their existing tools all the while aware of their limited budget. He also gets a kick out of bringing these old relics to life. This is the response he gave us with his permission to print it. To satisfy some other Davids I do get compensated $2.00 royalty per unit sold by IBC for my role in developing the chip breaker.

Mr. Charlesworth says;

"The Pinnacle matched blade/breaker is the best prepared that I have seen. The chipbreaker is outstanding and a few strokes on each surface will perfect it. Blade flatness and finish are excellent so the total preparation time is minimal.

The set will improve the performance of a pre WW2 Stanley/bailey beyond recognition. With proper tuning and sole flattening results should be comparable to premium modern planes.

The benefit of this set is the reduced preparation time and the ability to fit a thick blade to a Stanley. This option has not been available before.

I have been tuning up old Stanley planes for over 30 years. We have even salvaged planes from before 1910. Tremendous satisfaction can be had from reviving and using an old heirloom. "

www.davidcharlesworth.com

Choose your David.

Cheers

Rob Cosman

Re: Assistance with choice of replacement irons...

#11

Honestly...

John in NM

From the choices listed, I don't think it much matters :D - they're all going to perform well. Variety is fun, so why not go with a couple different ones?

I have a couple A2 blades, and while they're a little longer lasting than an O1 edge, I don't find it so pronounced that I'd buy them again. Neither have I ever bought into the whole cryo thing. People swear it helps, but I've yet to see an explanation that makes any thermodynamic sense. Haven't looked a whole lot though, there's tons of chaff to sort through if one wants a kernel of actual science.

My favorite blade is a Clifton, but that's just because it has a cool old timey kind of logo stamped in the top :D As I said, variety is the fun part.

Re: Assistance with choice of replacement irons...

#12

And flatter...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond CA

It took me forever to polish the back of one. It cuts nice though...

Re: Assistance with choice of replacement irons...

#13

Re: Assistance with choice of replacement irons...

TomD

I have one in my jointer have had that plane and combo a very long time. But for the most part I have them in smoothers, just because those are the planes I have the largest number of. I have one in my ECE smoother. I also have them in several block planes. Given how superbly they work it is hard to see the thickness as any problem at all. When I make blades, I tend to make them in 3/16" material. But these 1/8" blades work great so I don't really consider the blade thickness thing a fundamental. Both the Stanley style plane, and the ECE have some features designed to make them as effective as possible with the thin blades.

Re: Assistance with choice of replacement irons...

#14

Re: Assistance with choice of replacement irons...

David Weaver

You have laminated blue steel irons that are 1/8th thick?

The ones i've seen are all labeled as 5/64ths.

I thought about it after I posted, the thickness isn't too much of a problem when they're thin, I'd just prefer one a little thicker, especially in something other than a smoother.

I don't see a reason to put them in something other than a smoother, though. They are nice because of the way blue steel fails by wear instead of chipout (unless you hit something), but it's nice to have something a little less temperature sensitive to power sharpen for a rougher cut (when there is more camber).

I guess what I didn't say that well was that if you're accustomed to the thick blades and like the feel of them, these are a bit thinner. You can sort of cheat a little and make a thicker chipbreaker for them, though. The harder the wood, the nicer the thicker iron and/or chipbreaker. I have been going only with irons in planes that have good chipbreakers lately, and a friend prefers stock irons but with a heavier chipbreaker.

Re: Assistance with choice of replacement irons...

#15

Chris Scholz

Re: Assistance with choice of replacement irons...

Chris Scholz

Obviously the best blade is the one in your plane (i.e. the one you can use right now)...

As others already said, any reasonably well hardened steel will do just fine.

If you want to get really fancy I'd say:

1) For your #5 get a blade with best abrasion resistance (AISI A2, 1.2363, JIS SKD 12, Z 100 CDV 5, Timken D2, Rex M2 HSS, Micro-Melt� T-15 M4, etc. You might want to add cryo and a bit of snake-oil). Your'll sharpen rarely and don't care a whole lot about surface quality of the wood.

2) for your #4 get a blade that's easy and quick to sharpen, such as a GalootTools blade or many other premium blades mentioned in this thread.

Chris

Re: Assistance with choice of replacement irons...

#16

Re: Assistance with choice of replacement irons...

David Weaver

I just realized I typed something backwards here.

What I meant to say about A2 and chipout, is that the iron that develops chipout last also lasts the longest.

An iron that develops chipout after 100 strokes or so of smoothing, or less, even if the rest of the edge is very keen, will fail much earlier than one that does not chip out at all.

There is definitely some variation in this even within the same company's irons. So when you get one of the irons that doesn't exhibit chipout at all, even from the start, regard it as a very good one.

Re: Assistance with choice of replacement irons...

#17

Re: Assistance with choice of replacement irons...

David Charlesworth

The thing which seems to be consistently ignored in discussions about the IBC blade and chipbreaker set, is that it is the first and only simple way of fitting a 3.6mm blade into a Stanley or Record plane.

The throat is likely to need a little filing to widen it, but the yoke or Y lever will engage with the tabs which have been added to the slot of the chipbreaker. The short peg on the yoke has prevented extra thick blades from being fitted, up till now. This is why most replacement blades are 2.4mm thick. (L-N & Hock).

I have recently fitted this set to a Stanley 5 & 5 1/2. Flatness and chipbreaker edge machining were extremely good requiring very few strokes on my stones to perfect.

best wishes,

David Charlesworth