New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Exotic Hardwood, Personally Sourced Worldwide. Inspected at Origin. Shop Rare Stock.

Shooting planes compared

Posts

Re: Shooting planes compared

#2

Re: Shooting planes compared

glh17

Very useful review. Thanks.

Re: Shooting planes compared

#3

Stephen Shepherd

Have you ever used...

Stephen Shepherd

a coffin smoother as a shooting plane? I use mine all the time on a shooting board, Because of the curved sides, I can adjust the skew for the particular board, works great.

Stephen

Re: Shooting planes compared

#4

Re: Have you ever used...

anotherBob

Now that's clever... never even thought of that!

Derek, thanks for the #51 dreadnought envy. :)

Re: Shooting planes compared

#5

Re: Have you ever used...

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Stephen

Thanks. That is very interesting that you use the coffin smoother as it can rock forward to skew.

The motivation behind my comparison of the planes and the boards is to try and understand the dynamics in shooting - what will lead to improved performances, either with better tools or with existing tools? I do not mean to appear to be advocating expensive tools - just that the ones I did include are recognised to be specialists for shooting.

Equally, I am not meaning to be recommending via my conclusions that everyone should use a ramped shooting board, but that they lead to improved performance. Is it the skew blade, a slicing action, a low cutting angle .. ? Clearly technique plays a large part since many are very comfortable with the performance of less-than-ideal bench planes. The #52, in taking some of the technique out of the arena, identifies that it is in the equation of shooting.

I would like my article to be the first part of two, with the second dealing with technique (which is why I included it in the Furniture Building section of my website and not the Tool Review section).

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Shooting planes compared

#6

Re: Shooting planes compared

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Very interesting, thanks, Derek. Especially the skew to ramp relationship. Do you find that important only at the initial contact?

Pam

Re: Shooting planes compared

#7

Re: Shooting planes compared

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Very interesting, thanks, Derek. Especially the skew to ramp relationship. Do you find that important only at the initial contact?

Hi Pam

At this initial stage I consider that the initial contact is the important factor. Progressive entry (of a skewed blade) reduces the area of impact. After the blade enters the endgrain it matters little. From this point the cutting angle matters most, with the lowest cutting angle reducing the effort significantly.

Note that several years ago I would successfully use a 60 degree HNT Gordon trying plane on my shooting board. Clearly any plane can work. What I am trying to deliniate is the ideal combination for the most efficient shooting.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Shooting planes compared

#8

Re: Shooting planes compared

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Note that several years ago I would successfully use a 60 degree HNT Gordon trying plane on my shooting board. Clearly any plane can work.

Still do use the HNT from time to time, although I mostly use the Mosaku, neither of which is any plane. :)

But I am thinking seriously about making a smallish ramped shooting board, thanks to your analysis.

Pam