We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
I have been struggling up the learning curve with shellac. Trying to re-finish an old clock with garnet shellac, it's OK on three sides, but does not work on the fourth side. Since that, I have been experimenting with a dewaxed blonde shellac and using bioethanol instead of the household type ethanol.
It seems to work better, and I have some success with using the shellac as both a finish on bowls and as a sanding sealer under other finishes. I am not sure if the success is due to the lower water content in the bioethanol or the dewaxed shellac.
So, here is the question: When do you need to use un-dewaxed shellac?
The priec is about the same, and the dewaxed is much easier to filter.
So you are asking what waxed shellac is good for? For one thing the colour. You can get a lot of the wax out and still have the colour. Apparently at one time there were all manner of shellac colours and flavours, when it was hand made. Now that it is chemically stripped and bleached some of these options have been lost.
I was lucky enough to have a professional woodworker give me some tips on using shellac when I first started out. His view was that waxed shellac gave more protection to the piece. My own experience is that it is easier to use dewaxed. Buttonlac, which has less processing done to it, tends to be stickier. It doesn't flow as easily to me as the dewaxed does. However, a drop of oil works wonders towards easing this stickiness. In general, if one is using shellac as an undercoat than dewaxed is the ticket. If shellac is the only finish than it doesn't matter which one uses. I'm convinced that shellac that has not been dewaxed will provide more protection because it has the wax element in it. Also buttonlac has a different look to me and this is more than just the color. Flake shellac that has not been dewaxed is not much different to me than dewaxed. I know there are many who use dewaxed exclusively and there's no reason to dispute this. Dewaxed will provide an optimal finish every time and, while I think the wax does add more protection, I don't believe there is so great a difference that makes dewaxed a lesser option. There is also the issue of an authentic look being achieved with less-processed shellac. I believe there is some merit to that argument.
I may be one of the few that does not like de-waxed shellac. I was given some dewaxed blond shellac, the stuff didn't dissolve well at all, required a bit of heating, which I don't like to do with alcohol. Then the stuff just didn't go on like the other shellac I use. The next time I needed blond shellac I bought a small can of white shellac.
I use seed-lac, still has wooden debris and bug parts and it totally unprocessed and contains all [5 to 6%] of its wax. This is not like regular beeswax or paraffin wax that can interfere with finishes. Using traditional finishes I have never had a properly applied seal coat of shellac interfere with varnish or paint.
It is also easier to French Polish with the cruder [read unrefined] shellac and the seedlac goes on easy. So I strain but never filter the stuff when I mix it up.
As for the alcohol, the proof can start out high but any alcohol has an affinity for water or water has an affinity for alcohol but they do mix readily. Using regular distillation process 190 proof is as good as you can get because of the azeotropic relationship with water and alcohol. Using any lower proof will introduce too much water leaving a flocculent precipitate at the bottom.
Methanol will actually dissolve shellac more completely than ethanol [100% vs. 85-98%], but is dangerous to use and many feel ethanol works better for French Polish. I use 190 proof Everclear, but they do offer a 151 proof Everclear and this should be avoided, too much water.
Shellac is one of those topics where every conceivable opposite exists simultaneously. Before I put up my first post, I had just finished reading some posts that:
Said waxed shellac was more water proof because of the wax, and said it was less so because the wax is responsible for water marking, a point confirmed by several.
Said that blond shellac was harder, and more waterproof.
Some people say you can't use waxed shellac under other finishes, while others say you can. Seems the ones who say you can use wax under finishes have that one.
I think a lot of it depends on what you want to do.
I think the wax is a danger long term. Because waxed shellac is softer, there's a greater risk of varnish lifting on impact, which can create white marks under the varnish, when the varnish doesn't chip. In most places this might not matter, but on something like a staircase it might. Even with de-waxed shellac I've been told not to use mare than two coats under varnish because it gets too soft.
I've always gone on the assumption that wax makes shellac softer and more permeable to water.
Just out of curiosity, what is the difference? If they are both 190 proof, it seems to me that the only difference is what makes up the other 5% no matter what the process for making the ethanol.
I can't really comment on what is better or worse when it comes to using shellac, but I like using seedlac and Everclear as a solvent. It's super easy to make, filtering is trivial, and goes on great using a rolled up t-shirt rag.
here in DK at least, household ethanol is specified as 93% alcohol by volume. The rest is water and a small amount of denaturant. The high water content is no problem for cleaning and other household uses.
Bioethanol fur stove fuel is lower in water content, no less than 95% ethanol, and if taken from auto fuel feed stock, practically water free.
Chemically, there is no difference, ethanol is ethanol, but may contain a few aldehydes - fusel oil. This is OK for use as a solvent, but not OK for consumption.
The main point is the water. One might suspect that the household stuff may actually contain more water, as it would never be noticed by the consumer.
From checking all the MSDS sheets I could find, by far the most common denaturant is MEK. This should have no ill effects on the performance of the alcohol as a solvent for shellac.
It also has the advantage that it makes you puke rather than kill you if you ingest it, and has a relatively benign effect on skin etc.
I think you're referring to the SLX in the blue container, and you're right - it's got an unacceptably high level of methanol in it.
They are replacing it locally (at least in quarts) with a "green" can of stuff for the same price at HD (and online).
The MSDS on the green kleen strip DNA is 90-100% ethanol, and I think it's about $6.99 a quart or so. I haven't used mine yet. Admittedly, I used the old blue stuff for quite a long time never really thinking about what's in it.