New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Veritas - Innovation in Tools

hand plane advice

Posts

hand plane advice

#1

hand plane advice

Jerry Gibbs

I am a newbie and have one old #3 smoother. I am seriously looking at the Veritas low angle jack plane. I would get 2 blades giving me cutting angles of 37 and 50 degrees. I would use the plane as much as possible for general use (eg end grain, edge jointing, general surfacing and smoothing). I am also confused by LV's A2 and O1 iron choices. I would not be a heavy user and still learning to sharpen. Thanks for your opinion. Jerry

Re: hand plane advice

#2

Moses Yoder

Re: hand plane advice

Moses Yoder

I don't have that plane but have heard lots of good things about it. Your blade plan seems sound. I have always gotten the 01 blades because that is what I was used to sharpening from Ron Hock and I know what to expect and I know they work really good. I have heard people say the A2 is a little harder to hone but lasts longer after sharpening but I would bet it's pretty hard to tell the difference. I think they give you a choice for 2 reasons. #1, it adds sizzle to the product. #2, it gives us something to argue about.

Re: hand plane advice

#3

Re: hand plane advice

David Weaver

If you are sharpening with oil stones, get the O1.

If you are sharpening with anything else, it doesn't matter what you get. The A2 will last longer.

if you don't use A2 and O1 on the same project and see how much you can complete, you may not notice the difference, but the tougher the work, the bigger the difference.

In my roughing planes, the A2 irons last noticably longer, but I never noticed it until I intentionally used two planes this past week on the same project and used them to prepare rough boards from the same tree. The A2 definitely lasts longer.

If you're going to smooth with it, you'll be less apt to see this, though, because you will want to sharpen when you're not getting the surface you want, not when the iron becomes so dull it won't cut.

Re: hand plane advice

#4

Re: hand plane advice

Mark Salomon

The LV LAJ is a nice plane and you'll be happy. I suggest that you get 01 because it's easier to sharpen. Also, just get two 25* blades and sharpen them to the angle that you want. This will give you a small bevel at your desired angle. If you try sharpening/honing the 50* bevel it'll take you all day because you'll be sharpening the entire bevel at 50*.

Re: hand plane advice

#5

Re: hand plane advice

Frank D. in Montreal

I think that plane would be a great choice. I have one and, even if the handles don't suit my hands too well (I haven't heard many people complain about this, so chances are it won't be a problem), I still think it's one of my most practical planes.

What I like most about A2 steel over O1 is the resistance to burning (I do all my primary bevels on a grinder, and O1 is trickier to grind) and reistance to rust (O1 rusts faster). I do secondary and tertiary bevels on both oil and water stones, and don't really see a difference. I do an occasional primary bevel on my stones and don't really find a big difference in the steels either, but perhaps I just haven't done it enough to make valid comparisons.

Re: hand plane advice

#6

I say once. Say again...

Bogdan Kiryakov - Blagoevgrad, Bulgaria

LV plane like marry good wife.

Strong like bull. Make hard work. Stylish like Bulgarian police shoe.

Not so pretty, maybe, but moles no matter after fourteenth childs.

Re: hand plane advice

#7

Re: I say once. Say again...

TomD

I have the LN Jack, and the LV jointer. I think you will enjoy a low angle plane.

I love that thing about a Bulgarian Police shoe, though I think my LV jointer is actually quite handsome. I think LV made a kinda error, when they figured their slot was on the ugly side of LN. Turned out they turn out a premium plane performance wise, and it is hard to believe the ugly bit is saving anyone any money. Like a discount grocery store where they take a regular store and spend a million in reno making it look like a place that sells cheap food.

Blade wise you have two decisions:

- Whether to buy two blades. I think this is a waste of money, you should be shooting for specialized planes so you can just pick them up and go. In the real world, I would probably opt to set the one plane for a good compromise setting like 40 degrees. That said, I don't see how it will hurt to do what you are planing, and it could be rather fun as an experiment. Depends on whether you are playing at being a tool experimenter, or are a get 'er dun, kinda user. These days a lot of us are into the tool games stuff since that is one of the strong messages of magazines etc... Tools are something you test, vs use. For the kind of person who just wants to get the sideboard done, you are better off not complicating maters.

- O1 or A2. I like O1 for a variety of reasons. Trying to see things from you perspective, the argument would be: Less discouraging for a beginner to sharpen. The plane you are choosing is relatively easy to do a sharpening cycle on, compared to an old Stanley or something. Most of the other tools currently available will not be available in A2 or other super steels. It is best in my book to have one type of steel on the go so you are doing the same thing with the same gear.

The contrary position favouring A2 would be if:

- Most of your woodworking is maple or harder woods

- You are going to raise heaven and earth to get only super steels in the rest of your tools

- You are going to adopt from the outset production methods of sharpening

- You aren't interested in traditional tools, and the woodworking they produce, so you won't later want C&W planes, hollows and rounds, antique tools for restoration, Japanese tools, etc... Speaking broad brush.

Re: hand plane advice

#8

David Barnett

Re: I say once. Say again...

David Barnett

"I think LV made a kinda error, when they figured their slot was on the ugly side of LN. Turned out they turn out a premium plane performance wise, and it is hard to believe the ugly bit is saving anyone any money."

I think you're right. I saw a Canadian fashion show once. Same thing. Sad.

Really, what's not to like about a plane that functions so well? Moles or not.

Re: hand plane advice

#9

Re: I say once. Say again...

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Well, it does tend to test your limits living with a man who spends more money on beer and gambling than his family, who makes no effort to make good sex. After 20 years of that, who really cares what they look like? And I'd like to see you guys wear high heels for even a minute. :)

Pam

Re: hand plane advice

#10

Re: hand plane advice

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Yes, it all depends on how you want to sharpen and the woods you use. I always choose O1.

Pam

Re: hand plane advice

#11

David Barnett

Aha!

David Barnett

"And I'd like to see you guys wear high heels for even a minute."

If that's where you're drawing the line, that's where you're gonna lose, girlfriend!

Re: hand plane advice

#12

No. Is wrong.

Bogdan Kiryakov - Blagoevgrad, Bulgaria

I no drink beer. No gamble. Smoke, yes. And I make good the sex. Ask wife. Ask mistress.

Re: hand plane advice

#13

Moses Yoder

Re:Who is this guy?  *LINK*

Moses Yoder

Whoever he is, at least he chose a real name for his location. Perhaps he really is a Bulgarian? Who knows. Funny thing is, red heads usually have moles and I happen to like them. Perhaps that explains why I am starting to think the LV planes look nice in a kinky sort of way.


Read about Blagoevgrad

Re: hand plane advice

#14

I Bogdan, son of Desislav

Bogdan Kiryakov - Blagoevgrad, Bulgaria

I real. I am to study here the fashion in American University in Bulgaria here in Blagoevgrad. Have girlfriend she wish model in Miami. Wife not know.

Re: hand plane advice

#15

(Message Deleted by Poster)

Bogdan Kiryakov - Blagoevgrad, Bulgaria

Re: hand plane advice

#16

OK, let's see. 

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Re: hand plane advice

#17

Re: I Bogdan, son of Desislav

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

You've already told me way more than I want to know. What does all this have to do with woodworking? Oh, right, LV planes are like a good wife. OK.

Pam

Re: hand plane advice

#18

In need of a heeling

Bob Hackett

Got any heels in 8-1/2 EEEE? If you do then I`m game for a footrace.

You forget I also spent some time in Texas and the heels on some of those cowboy boots run a close second to what some women have on their high heels.

Come to think of it,I always wondered about that.

I asked my wife why most women gain weight after they get married.She told me most single women come home,look to see what`s in the fridge and then go directly to bed.

Married women come home,look at what`s in bed and then go directly to the fridge. :D

Re: hand plane advice

#19

Choosing a steel

Bob Hackett

Here`s how I roll.

O1 for the tools I want to be able to quickly strop to refresh an edge on.I have tons of old laminated plane irons and chisels(close to O1 but more like W1) and love them all even have a few old O1 turning tools I use for detail work.

A2 and above for the work horses and tough/abrasive woods.

I have a cut down HSS planer blade in my scrub plane and various tough tool steels in things like jack planes,scrapers and rough out chisels.If I`m going to be concentrating on wasting away wood I don`t want to have to break my stride to sharpen half way through a job.

As far as sharpening goes,if you buy your initial set-up to sharpen modern steels you can still sharpen O1 with it.Buy at a level that`s only sufficient to sharpen O1 and you`re gonna struggle to sharpen most modern steels if you can do it at all.

That`s all I`m gonna say about that without waking the "zombie horse". (shudder)

Re: hand plane advice

#20

Tug tug....

John in NM

I feel one leg getting longer :D

Re: hand plane advice

#21

Jesper, Denmark

Re: In need of a heeling

Jesper, Denmark

Good one, I'll have to remember that. :D

Re: hand plane advice

#22

Re: I say once. Say again...

TomD

You're in Maine right? I know a bit about that, and in Maine a Canadian passing through from Montreal, is about as close as you get to a fashion show. Come to think of it, someone from Montreal is pretty much a fashion show for the rest of us in Canada as well.

Re: hand plane advice

#23



Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

There's this little thing about being pregnant that tends to add on the weight. Oh, yeah, and some gain it on birth control pills.

As to heels, I gave up on them when I left corporate America. Occasionally I had to wear them as my company's main salesperson; but only 1-1.5" and a very expensive pair that fit perfectly. Managed to make them last 20+ years. Working my way back to barefoot. :)

Re: hand plane advice

#24

ROFL !

steve mackay

Re: hand plane advice

#25

Re: I say once. Say again...

Frank D. in Montreal

I'D argue with you about O1, but thems fightin words...

I DO know one lady from Montreal who's a fashion show to herself. I call her the plane lady because she's sold me many a used plane for pennies (long story). She wears high heels and likes to vacation in Miami, in case Bog is interested.