New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Fast and affordable laser cutting – so you can make the parts you can’t find anywhere else

Something in the water...

Posts

Something in the water...

#1

Something in the water...

TomD

Funny thing tonight. Of no consequence. But like the song says, things that make you go Hmmm.

I was in Walmart buying Tylenol for the 4 year old. Not like she is dying, so I sneak a peak at the index of FWW. I was wondering what the miracle finish mentioned on the cover was, since earlier I had spent over a hundred bucks to add yet another two options to my suite.

Anyway, right on the inside cover, there is this drawing of the clamp rack in my shop (my reaction). I guess it was the winner in their reader's tips. I was really struck by it. It wasn't just that it was the same basic idea, which isn't much of an idea really. But it used an admittedly generic enough proportion right out of a few fixtures in my shop. As I said, I was sneaking a peek at the Index, so I shrug it off, take off for Pharmacy.

I don't make it. I go back thinking, "that is just so similar", I am going to look it up in the main article, and if that guy is from Ontario, Canada - He copied it from me!

So I get the magazine open to page 26, or something, and I look at the submission. It's from Ontario Canada. I pick myself up and go get the Tylenol.

Well the thing is, very few people visit my shop at all. I don't recognize this guy's name as, say, an ebay guy who picked something up. And anyway, it is a pretty obvious idea, and a fairly generic look. But for a second there, I was drafting a non-disclosure, non-compete vehicle in case anyone else visits and wants to get rich off of my ideas. :)

Re: Something in the water...

#2

Great minds . . . yadda, yadda, yadda

steve mackay

Re: Something in the water...

#3

Re: Great minds . . . yadda, yadda, yadda

TomD

"Great" might be a bit of an exaggeration. :) Like seeing a coat rack and going - He stole my idea! Just the details and finding out that the guy was localish, getting no sleep, that kind of thing. The project is a no-brainer.

Re: Something in the water...

#4

Re: Great minds . . . yadda, yadda, yadda

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Tom

What is quite likely is that after he visited your shop he totally forgot about the rack. Then one day he needed to build one and had this great idea ... only it did not occur to him that he had seen it elsewhere ... and now he has a great idea to share.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Something in the water...

#5

David Barnett

Tom's rack, blue tits, &  missing milk in England *LINK*

David Barnett

Well, while it could be simply explanained as due to a forgotten direct exposure, as Derek has suggested, it could also have a much more complicated explanation, Occam be damned.

I think it's yet another case for morphic resonance, Rupert Sheldrake's theory* of habitual Universe.

Wikipedia's article on Sheldrake states:

"This is a feedback mechanism between the field and the corresponding forms of morphic units. The greater the degree of similarity, the greater the resonance, leading to habituation or persistence of particular forms. So, the existence of a morphic field makes the existence of a new similar form easier."

So steve mackay nailed it. Sooner, rather than later, we'll likely all have a rack like Tom's.

*Morphogenesis -- hypothesis of formative causation

http://tinyurl.com/morphogenesis


Read about blue tits and milk bottles

Re: Something in the water...

#6

Ya lost me at...

John in NM

Occam be damned, I shave daily with that razor :D :D

But the feeble pun wasn't the point. The blue tits made me think of an even more feeble visual pun, but you'll enjoy the picture :D


img

Re: Something in the water...

#7

David Barnett

That is SO not right.   

David Barnett

Re: Something in the water...

#8

Either way...

Bob Hackett

You`re bound to get the blues!

Suddenly I`m in the mood for a Gatemouth Brown CD.

PS-Read about how crows pass skills like avoidance and recognition between territories and generations.

Plants such as trees can do things like prepare for threats in advance of their arrival which would indicate the ability to communicate on some level.

Suddenly humans are not as smart as we thought we were. :O

Re: Something in the water...

#9

David Barnett

Re: Either way... *LINK*

David Barnett

A good introduction is The Presence of the Past: Morphic Resonance and the Habits of Nature*. I read this and A New Science of Life: The Hypothesis of Morphic Resonance before he lectured in Vermont, to give me a fighting chance of understanding him. His off-the-cuff anecdotes are without a doubt the most amazing I've ever heard, although I remain ever skeptical.

Even more entertaining than those two books, riveting as they are, and more accessible is Dogs That Know When Their Owners are Coming Home: And Other Unexplained Powers of Animals. Also, The Sense of Being Stared At : And Other Aspects of the Extended Mind. Also good, but quite different, are his books with the late Terence McKenna.

*How can you not read a book described in Nature as "the best candidate for burning there has been for many years."


The Presence of the Past

Re: Something in the water...

#10

David Barnett

Actually...

David Barnett

that '*' should've been on the second book, A New Science of Life: The Hypothesis of Morphic Resonance. Of course, both books are heretical enough to burn as far as the established canons of science are concerned.

Re: Something in the water...

#11

Re: Actually...

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

The blue tit story was fascinating. My hypothesis is that we incorporate the things we learn in our neurons; so everything we know before giving birth/fathering a child is passed on; and that's why we often recognize concepts rather than learn them as such. It's an incomplete hypothesis that probably wouldn't stand up to scrutiny; but it integrates with my hypothesis that we often evolve by incorporating other beings rather than trial and error.

Pam, who's really not stalking you, even though it may appear so :)

Re: Something in the water...

#13

Re: Great minds . . . yadda, yadda, yadda

TomD

Derek -

Or you invented it. We both saw your post, and are now walking around thinking we invented it. (Anyway, it is so generic we probably all invented it). Some days I can't remember my kid's names, and a few posts with a little more humility than my average are not going to hurt me.

Re: Something in the water...

#14

David Barnett

What if...

David Barnett

It's funny that we think of the brain as the actual repository of all thought, memories, knowledge, habits, skills and so on. That somehow our entirety is isomorphically mapped or even holonomically enfolded in our actual neurons, their connections. It's understandable. Wilder Penfield would probe a locus and stimulate a memory, a twitch, or provoke a perceived odor. But is this so different than a primitive who's never seen a radio receiver poking at it's insides to see what happens?

Poke one part and it emits static, another music, yet another speech. Would he not suppose that the sounds, the words, the thoughts were embodied in the very components themselves, just as Penfield and those who've followed him?

What if our three-pound wonder is instead a transceiver, a switchboard of holons and morphic units? The richness of human experience and its storage in our vast but finite neural connections hasn't been adequately proven or accounted for -- the numbers haven't been made to fit -- so Sheldrake, Karl Pribram with his holonomic model, and other hypotheses need to be examined and considered. Off-site storage is the way to go.

Another funny thing, we still say computer, but it's much more than that, now, isn't it? We're ever more shaping, modeling, molding, poking, interacting one way or another with the noosphere. The very hypothesized non-spatiotemporality of morphic resonance leads to some fairly interesting and challenging explanations for phenomena that materialistic determinism cannot. It was complicated enough with Whitehead and Popper. This stuff can boggle the bean. Which is why I go out to the shop and futz with a fid or something.

Re: Something in the water...

#15

Now

Dan Donaldson

Please translate that into words of less than three syllables ;)

Re: Something in the water...

#16

It sounds as if you'd spent some time with

Bruce, a MN Galoot

Lewis Thomas' book Lives of a Cell, back in the day.

Re: Something in the water...

#17

Re: What if...

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Well, there's always muscle memory; so I suspect the rest of the body plays some part in all this. After all, dna and rna are everywhere.

And if you're real nice, I'll tell you my theory about our universe being a massive simulation run by beings running out of water and world, watching to see what we and other intelligent beings, do.... :)

Pam

Re: Something in the water...

#18

David Barnett

Hippopotomonstrosesquippedaliophobia?

David Barnett

My God, man! Even un-der-stand-a-ble has five syllables. You are, of course, right.

"Short words are best, and old words when short are best of all."

-- Winston Churchill

Re: Something in the water...

#19

sesquipedalian

John in NM

Ironically, it means "long" :D

Re: Something in the water...

#20

David Barnett

Re: sesquipedalian

David Barnett

It was a tough call, the commonly misspelled hippopotomonstrosesquippedaliophobia, or the more correct hippopotomonstrosesquipedaliophobia. I chose the former as Google otherwise offers it alternatively to the latter. In everyday conversation, though, they're pronounced alike.

Re: Something in the water...

#21

Re: Blue what?

David Weaver

I think it has something to do with smurfs

Re: Something in the water...

#22

And the funny part is...

John in NM

I didn't even see it in there, just knew the word already :D

Anyone else have a habit of, almost sub-consciously, just skipping over huge awkward words when reading? Probably why I never learned much German for all the semesters I took :D

Re: Something in the water...

#23

David Barnett

Even funnier

David Barnett

I was once accused of prolix sesquipedalian loquaciousness for no apparent reason.

Re: Something in the water...

#24

Now, there's a problem

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

"In everyday conversation, though, they're pronounced alike."

When police officers radio names and such - such as when they're asking the dispatcher if there's a warrant out on someone they're talking with - they spell the name unless it's a common one, in which case, they'll say, "John Smith - standard spelling."

How can they possibly do that with this word if there's no standard spelling? Think of the radio time THAT one would take up; the dispatch shift would end before the officer finished spelling it.

Re: Something in the water...

#25

David Barnett

Using the ol' mati�re grise

David Barnett

"Well, there's always muscle memory; so I suspect the rest of the body plays some part in all this."

Good thinking. It seems there could be less advantage to morphic nonlocality in initial motor learning and cortical conditioning, at least before long term memory consolidation with the activated somatosensory cortices. Also, over the long term, basal ganglia gin up connections to the cerebellum. Neuroplasticity gets involved, and no single mechanism adequately accounts for how. There are multiple cortical plasticities operating even though storage may be arguably nonlocal. It's a real bean boggler all right.

I've been putting some of this together with what I've learned in rereading Human Hand Function. When I first read it, I was more concerned with fine motor memory as it relates to slow practice of difficult piano passages, but am now far more interested in haptic sensing, and so on, to better adapt to my continuing vision loss.

As for simulations by dessicated beings from ever-atrophying worlds, they need only wait until 2012 to see what happens, according to the ancient calendricists, anyway. I've pretty much given up on being rescued, though. To heck with stupid high-speed trains. We're gonna need tickets on Rapture Rail's Glory Train Express! Whoo-Whoo!