New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

200+ woodworking book reviews

Who here has a Chosera 10k? (i have questions)

Posts

Who here has a Chosera 10k? (i have questions)

#1

Who here has a Chosera 10k? (i have questions)

David Weaver

I have been looking for a good medium coarse stone for a while for japanese irons, and have been using 400 grit diamond hones, but I'm tired of the way they get sluggish after a while.

So I bought a chosera 400 grit last week, and while i've only done one primary bevel on it, it's superb compared to every other 400 grit stone that I've had. It didn't load, and it didn't turn into mud, and it had a very good feel for a more coarse stone.

I cannot tolerate soaking stones, too lazy, but I think for this feel, I might be able to take it, but I think I may be able to get away without it.

I didn't presoak the 400, just kept it wet while I was using it and it worked fine. That was just out of the box and in the kitchen. In the future, for as seldom as I'll use it, I can dump it in a tub in the shop when I'm going to use it. If I have any luck guessing, i would say that I could get away with not soaking the chosera 10k, but just giving it water as it needed to drink, and still get a great feel. I don't have one in my posession yet, but i'm a little past the pondering point.

Does anyone have one and use it without presoaking? I don't need to replace my 1k stone, it is just a shapton pro, and the shaptons have a nice hard but not sticky feel at that level.

Re: Who here has a Chosera 10k? (i have questions)

#2

Re: Who here has a Chosera 10k? (i have questions)

wilbur

I've used the Chosera 10K exactly once, but I remember it as being a very nice stone. In terms of feel, it was more like the Shapton 1000 than the Shapton 8000 (hope that made sense), and I'm saying that as a good thing. I know that the TFWW site says that you should soak the Choseras, and it doesn't distinguish between the low grit and high grit stones in this regard, but I remember just spritzing the Chosera 10K to get it to work.

Re: Who here has a Chosera 10k? (i have questions)

#3

Re: Who here has a Chosera 10k? (i have questions)

David Weaver

Wilbur, i know exactly what you mean by that with the feel. Somewhere around the 5000, the shaptons develop some vacuum on the surface if you do a wide flat bevel, and they get skippy, even with some dish soap.

That's shapton 1000 feel is the feel i'm looking for, and why I don't intend to replace the shapton pro 1000. I like the pro 15k quite a lot, but it does get a bit sticky with japanese irons and it leads you into side sharpening most of the way to work around that, and following with vertical strokes to put the scratches parallel to the direction of cut. It is excellent for honing guide use and hollow ground chisels, though, and I think the best value in a very fine stone for the $80 it can be had for straight from japan (as opposed to the $141 that it costs here).

No great reason to get a chosera other than gluttony, I guess.

Re: Who here has a Chosera 10k? (i have questions)

#4

Re: Who here has a Chosera 10k? (i have questions)

Raney

Hi David,

I have the Chosera 10k. I will state unequivocally that for the high carbon steels I use more or less exclusively, it is the best synthetic stone I've used -- and by a long shot. Wilbur's dead-on -- it has the feel and feedback of a much coarser stone, but leaves a finish that's better than it's 10k rating would suggest.

The one downside to it is the soaking - but to be honest I think that's the inevitable tradeoff. Better feedback = soaking. It only needs a couple of minutes to work quite well - but I had no success using it with just a spritz as I do with shaptons. It really needed a bit of a soak to soften up before slurry came up well.

hth,

r

(who just realized he's completely forgotten to send you some screws for a very very long time now. Soon to be recitified).

Re: Who here has a Chosera 10k? (i have questions)

#5

Re: Who here has a Chosera 10k? (i have questions)

David Weaver

Raney -thanks for the feedback on the stone, that's more or less what I was hoping to hear. I'm hoping for something that feels like a nice suita stone but that cuts everything, and it sounds like it's the closest thing available.

No worries on the bolts. My wife got the nutty idea that i'd build her two large pieces of furniture (and i discarded most of my power tools last year), and I have three from George Wilson and one from a cap and iron that I bought from Ron Brese, so I won't have any planes waiting incomplete whenever you have the time to box those up and send them.

Re: Who here has a Chosera 10k? (i have questions)

#6

Re: Who here has a Chosera 10k? (i have questions)

David Weaver

It's an interesting animal so far. I tried it with a moderate soak (5 minutes maybe) on a very hard mosaku iron (probably white #1 or some variant). It's OK, but I think the stone is hiding something from me.

Is there a bit of a skin on the chosera like there is on a natural stone? that skin might be hiding what I'm looking for. It cuts fast at this point, but the finish level isn't quite where I expect it, and the feel isn't quite what I expected. It's not an issue to remove hair with the stone, but there are varying levels of that. I get the sense that even if it's a little better with time, the edge will be improved with a good natural stone.

It'll take a little while to get to "know" the stone, I guess, as long as i've been sharpening on shaptons. The first go-around, the edge isn't quite as good as a shapton 15k, but I know from practice how to get the best results with that one.

I'll give it another go-around tonight with a longer soak and see if I can get a better edge.