New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Live Edge Slabs, Hand-Selected in the Berkshires. Shop Unique Hardwood Pieces.

The #51 Shooting Plane: Lie-Nielsen and Stanley

Posts

Re: The #51 Shooting Plane: Lie-Nielsen and Stanley

#2

Re: The #51 Shooting Plane: Lie-Nielsen and Stanle

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Thanks, Derek.

I'm ready for two things to happen in this order:

1. LN recreates the #52 shoot board.

2. I win the lottery.

Until step 2, I guess I'll just drool on my keyboard periodically.

Re: The #51 Shooting Plane: Lie-Nielsen and Stanley

#3

Nice review, Derek, thanks.

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Re: The #51 Shooting Plane: Lie-Nielsen and Stanley

#4

Re: The #51 Shooting Plane: Lie-Nielsen and Stanle

Paul Erickson

Hi Derek,

Great review, care to comment on how the #51 compares to your LV BU plane for chuting?

cheers, Paul

Re: The #51 Shooting Plane: Lie-Nielsen and Stanley

#5

Re: The #51 Shooting Plane: Lie-Nielsen and Stanle

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Great review, care to comment on how the #51 compares to your LV BU plane for chuting?

Hi Paul

Thanks.

There are a number of relevant differences between the LV LA Jack and the #51 (Stanley and LN). The LAJ has a lower cutting angle (37 degrees vs the 45 of the #51), the #51 has a skewed blade (20 degrees), and the #51 has a dedicated handle/tote. Further, the LAJ has tended to be used on a ramped shooting board (5 degrees). Finally, the #51 has greater mass than the LAJ.

I have observed the following ..

A ramped board, while not replicating a skew blade, does allow the blade to enter the wood progressively, and this results in less jarring compared to a flat board. The LAJ on the ramped board is much nicer to use than on a flat board.

The #51 is more comfortable to push that the LAJ (using the thumb hole and lever cap for grip). The planes are equalised when a hotdog handle is added to the LAJ.

The #51 slices as a result of the skew, and this also leads to less jarring on entry. The #51 on the flat board experiences less jarring than the LAJ on the ramped board (this is a combination of skew and extra mass). The combination of a #51 on a ramped board is the best of all.

Regards from Perth

Derek